Is Roger Federer's game declining, or is he just mentally 'out of it?'

What is Federer's problem?

  • His game is declining. The end is near.

    Votes: 35 40.7%
  • This is all apart of the Federer cycle.

    Votes: 22 25.6%
  • Miscellaneous reasons (We'll never know)

    Votes: 29 33.7%

  • Total voters
    86

jukka1970

Professional
I can't believe that most people think the end is near. Though I suppose it depends on what the end is standing for. does the end mean no more slams, or does the end mean that he won't win more then 1 slam each year.

I personally think this is just his cycle, and things will turn around. Though I also think there are other factors such as working on his serve

Jukka
 

markwillplay

Hall of Fame
suny, what I meant to say was that his serve was under pressure from a great returner who was hitting some smoking returns on his second serve and even first when it was not good enough. Tends to make even the Great Fed press a bit...and that can make the serve go off for sure.

Same happened last year when delpo started to dial it in. I think that we don't fully understand that when those guys hit just a few really hard returns that it does make the server press. Some times it is hard to see because the motion looks the same. However, for me to believe that one of the best servers in the game just happens to have his serve go off against these better players in late grand slam matches ...well..i ain't drinking that coolaid. Bottom line is that when most pro's serves go "off" it is usually because the returner is in their head a bit and they are pressing. that is what I meant to say.

There is no way anyone will ever convince me that all the sudden, Fed just starts missing serves and it has nothing to do with the opponant. Naaaaa, he sees one of his decent serves come back with interest and he is human just like anyone.
 
Fed is mentally out of it. As I said in a previous post, he didn't seem all that fired up about losing. Same thing happened when he lost to Delpo last year, sort of like, "eh whatever"

He has twin babies now, puts all this in perspective, right now he has lost a little bit of the killer edge. Plus, that Djoko/Fed match was awful. I mean I have never seen Fed play that bad, missing routine FH/BH, and it still was a 5 setter. Fed demolished a red hot Sod in some nasty conditions and made it seem like it's just a walk in the park.

That's what's scary. He does seem a step slower but I still think it's more mental than physical. I bet once the kids get a little older and away from the baby age in the next 6 months he'll retool and be ready to go.

If PA really helps I think you will see Fed have a more aggressive net game. He would set people up for a zinger FH or BH outright winner but I think to conserve himself he'll work on truncating points. I actually wouldn't be surprised to see all top 10 player sstart adopting all court games now.

The bar to win out in baseland bashing is so high and demanding that once you get past 27-28 it gets really hard to sustain those rallies in terms of pace/depth/angles and chasing things down too. Just look at Roddick, he used to have some heat on his FH, now he tries to outlast players with a baseline game and at his age it's not working. No zip to his FH anymore, just almost pushing. And he never developed a solid all court game where he can come in to close out points. He comes to net and you cringe. Obv Fed/Roddick are worlds apart, Fed at 30 moves better than almost everyone and Roddick has never had good movement but the point is guys like Djoko, Murray, Sod, Berdych, Delpo can bash away now but they need to be focused on longevity, 20 stroke killer rallies within their peer group will just wreck them long-term.
 

SirGounder

Hall of Fame
I really do think that his family has a lot to do with it. He's got young twins so that definitely takes a toll. Perhaps he's really committed as a father and does not want to use nannies and what not all the time.

Obviously age is catching up with him. He will have to gradually make adjustments to his game to deal with it.

Other players are also figuring him out and have gotten better. It's more competitive all the way around.
 

servevolley

New User
He had TWO MATCH POINTS on ND's serve and played them both very passively! whatever happaned to chip and charge the net and put the pressure on yur opponent to come up with a winner under pressure. He played very tentatively and waited for the match to come to him. Guess what? He's still waiting because ND took it.
 
Top