better player - hewitt or roddick

[The_Punisher]

the only thing that hewitt has that roddick doesn't is one extra slam, and more weeks at number one.

hewitt peaked and then fell. roddick has been consistent throughout the years, by staying in the top ten for so long.

 

[NAS]

Every tom dick and harry know that Hewitt has a better career but somehow TTW poster on this thread claimed ( 48-47 in favor of Roddick) that Roddick has a better career.
This is why never blindly trust eye test result