This is gonna be a titanic battle with Rafa. I have to say thank God he's in good form. I would hate for what could be the only time they meet at the US Open, for Federer to not be in form. I hope for a classic match like the old days!
No. I dunno whether you are just being overly optimistic or preparing to congratulate Nadal on beating the mighty Federer again, but Federer is not going to do squat against Nadal. You are a Nadal fan, rejoice that Nadal is almost 100% certain to beat Fed at the last remaining slam he hasn't beaten him at. This is good for him. I know it's nice that you don't want to see Fed beaten badly but as a Fed fan it's also sad to see Nadal fans actually wanting Fed to play well because they know there is no way Federer is winning no matter what he does these days.
Right now is the biggest the gap there has ever been between these two players. Nadal is at his most successful on HC at any point in his career. On the other hand Federer has slipped to number 7 in the world, lost in the second round of a major, won only a 250 all year, has already been beaten 3 times by Nadal this year, 2 of which were absolute kickings.
It's been 6 years since Fed beat Nadal in a slam, since then he's lost 5 slam meetings in a row, and it's 4 years since he took more than a set of Nadal. Federer is not getting close to beating him and despite the few games lost this year you have to look at who Federer has played.
I dunno, maybe you will get a classic match like the old days if Federer plays the best tennis he can right now (which means like the old days Federer will get close to winning but lose, probably in 4 this time but no way in 5) I guess I'm overly cynical because even if it's a classic match like the old days, it's one where Federer has no chance to win. I'm sure Fed will make some stupid charges to the net to set Nadal up with some great passing shots that will make his fans vamos, and make Nadal play some great points for the highlights reel. At least you are one of the fans that appreciates Fed for that. But I think the time for a competitive match between them at the USO passed long ago (well maybe 2011 at the latest)