From a Fed fan: Nadal is extraordinary

Federev

Legend
Would you have made this thread if Rafa beat Fed in the final?
I don't know. It was to some degree a defense of Rafa against some of the over the top garbage I read on the forum. Some of that came out again after his injury and MTO last night and I got tired of it.

Not all the critique is bad at all on those fronts. Some good arguments get made.

But a lot gets so nasty and extreme and personal on him. (Tons of that happens against Fed here too).

And I felt bad for him after watching him fight hard.

So I dont think I would have.
 

Kalin

Legend
I’m a Fed fan first and foremost. No close second.

But I’m sure there are many Fed fans around here who would agree that Nadal is simply extraordinary.

He retired injured today and he’s catching a lot of flak for it - And for his grinding style and medical timeouts. ( something legal and which Fed is increasingly familiar with we should admit.)

But Man, The Dude. Is. A. Freaking. Warrior.

I watched him play much of that match with Schwartzman, hoping as a Fed fan the little dude would take it. The Shwartz was playing incredible. Redlining and painting the lines. Seriously extremely high-quality and he was on fire.

But it became plain clear enough that he just had no chance. Rafa just wore him out time after time after time with quality positioning, great defending, consistent court placement, incredible spin, and his usual unmatched intensity that just would not go away as Schwartzman faded.

I know it was only Schwartzman. But he was playing at an extremly high quality and that’s not really the point. Nadal Was just doing what he always does: taking just about everything anybody can throw at him and sending it back with interest. And it just reminded me that even when he isn’t playing his best-which I don’t think he was playing his best that day - no one is more committed than Nadal.

What keeps him down most of the time -is simply his body. It’s not his commitment or will and it’s not his underrated skill and brilliance.

You can fault him for grinding it out and making his body suffer for that, but he’s a massively gifted physical and mental athlete with an incredible drive to win and a work ethic that’s insane. World class Athletes pay a price for that. Fed’s not the rule on longevity at his level. ...That’s another way to look at it.

He’s number one in the world at 31 and even now his play bears out that when healthy he is usually able to vanquish just about everybody he plays - except Fed off clay.

Simply put : His body holds up today and Cilic goes home. Losing the war of attrition to the Bull like just about everybody else.

Even after last year, there is nobody I would rather Fed play less than Rafa. The scar tissue is too thick in my brain to ever actually want to see him on the other side of the net from the GOATERER.

He’s probably one of the two best players in history, in large part due to how he’s responded to Federer’s greatness with his own brand.

Much more I could say about Rafa. And even though some of his fans here leave a lot to be desired by the way they post - (and some Fed fans can be likewise obnoxious)-that’s not his fault.

So a universe size tip of the hat to the extraordinary Rafa, and wishes for a speedy recovery, provided of course, that he never catches Fed’s slam count.

Your post has finally made me see the light.

Never thought I'd say that, not to mention put it in writing, but now I have to admit that Rafa is indeed a somewhat better player than Schwartzman.
 

tennisaddict

Bionic Poster
i feel like some of this praise is over the top

i really doubt these sentiments would be expressed had rafa pulled through in 5 today and was still looming large for fed to face in the final

not saying everyone is fake about it but it kind of has this "thank god he got bounced, let me say really nice and sweet things about him because i'm so relieved" kind of feel

Well , OP had a choice - He could have said Nadal faked an injury but instead he chose to praise Nadal for his fighting spirit . Guess it was a poor choice ?
 

cc0509

Talk Tennis Guru
Well , OP had a choice - He could have said Nadal faked an injury but instead he chose to praise Nadal for his fighting spirit . Guess it was a poor choice ?

I don't think he faked an injury in that match but he most certainly shouldn't be moaning about injuries and too much play on hardcourts after he lost and after he fills up his schedule with too many tournaments. It wasn't the time or place.
 

Federev

Legend
Your post has finally made me see the light.

Never thought I'd say that, not to mention put it in writing, but now I have to admit that Rafa is indeed a somewhat better player than Schwartzman.
That is really all I could ask.

Perhaps from anyone ever.

Finally someone understands me.

Thank you
 

fedfan39

Rookie
Nadal is a very good player who's won 16 slams.

Outside of that, all this stuff about *having champion's heart* etc. is pure baloney.

Nadal grimaces, plays heavy topspin moonballs, jumps up and down, fist pumps and just *looks like in a warrior mode*.

If Federer played someone like Schwartzman, he would finish him off in a 3 set clinic in half the time playing half the shots without breaking a sweat.

Who is the champion here? Inquiring minds would like to know.
 

Legend of Borg

G.O.A.T.
Well , OP had a choice - He could have said Nadal faked an injury but instead he chose to praise Nadal for his fighting spirit . Guess it was a poor choice ?

whatever

hopefully people are this gracious when Fed inevitably loses some big match somewhere down the line
 
Last edited:
Top