Is it ever a good idea to attack Nadal's FOREHAND with topspin moonballs?

thomasferrett

Hall of Fame
Look at this moonball hit by Monfils;

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d2zOIXHVHFc#t=34

The next Nadal forehand drops the ball short because he was forced to hit his forehand at serve-height.

Check here at 3:40;

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2pYSah0_I-Q#t=221

Again, Nadal is forced to hit a really high forehand, and doesn't look comfortable doing it despite hitting it from the middle of the court when he wasn't rushed. It clips the net-tape so he nearly made an outright error.

Nadal can obviously hit a lot of topspin on his forehand, but remember his grip is not fully western, it is a semi-western grip. If he is forced to hit forehands at a contact point several feet above his head, perhaps his grip is not comfortable doing this, and also remember that in order to hit topspin you have to come over the ball. If the ball is already several feet above Nadal's head, there is not much space for Nadal to hit over, which may result in his subsequent forehand having less topspin on it - so his opponents can attack it.
 
you need to hit it very deep because nadal is very good at crushing shorter balls.

dimitrov played well against him hitting higher topspin shots very deep to the middle of the court so that nadal could not use angles. not easy to execute though.
 

Backspin1183

Talk Tennis Guru
It's a bad tactic to use it against Nadal. You don't attack Nadal's forehand for too long or you become the hunted.
 

President

Legend
I have seen Nadal hit huge winners or forcing shots off of many high topspin shots, I think those videos you posted in the OP are isolated examples.
 

tipsa...don'tlikehim!

Talk Tennis Guru
I have seen Nadal hit huge winners or forcing shots off of many high topspin shots, I think those videos you posted in the OP are isolated examples.

was about to write the same, 2 examples of bad FH from Nadal on a high ball but i guess it would be pretty easy to find examples of the opposite (winners on such balls)
 

FanOfLu

Professional
fTF36_.gif
 
Top