J. Mcenroe coaches are "overqualified" to teach Manhattan recreational players

klu375

Semi-Pro
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/08/s...agewanted=1&seid=auto&smid=tw-NYTStraightSets

Collete Lewis about another advertisement piece about JMAC academy:
"Twelve-year-old Ingrid Neel is the subject of this article from the New York Times, which explores her exposure to John McEnroe via his new tennis academy in New York. I saw Neel play for the first and only time at the Junior Orange Bowl this year, and perhaps because the surface was Har-Tru, the coming-to-net slant of her game wasn't immediately obvious to me. She did display variety and confidence, but I have to admit that I was surprised to read in this piece that she was No. 1 in the 18-and-under Northern section rankings. She is, after all, very small, and not one of those girls that has physically matured early. Given McEnroe's previous experience with touting a youngster, that being, famously, Donald Young, I approached this story with trepidation, but it is handled well, with a minimum of hype. And while it is primarily about Neel and her family, it is also about the choices necessary for all those who live in places where the competition isn't world class. I had thought McEnroe was emphasizing a local angle to his academy, yet that isn't what this article implies, and I would think attracting students to such an expensive city, with indifferent weather, would be extremely difficult, given the other options available. If they do "work at the net more than any other program," as Neel's mother says, that could be a selling point for some, but there is a huge population base in the area, so I'm unsure why McEnroe is not getting the best local players. Instead, he calls his staff "overqualified," which doesn't make a lot of sense, unless you believe that talent simply arrives at your doorstep, just needing a few tips before going out to win slams."
 
I've actually met this girl in Minneapolis with Nick B. when he came down. This girl is the real deal!! She hit's hard and beautifully with right on precision!! I think she can make it realllllyyyy far.
 
Cool story. I like how the mother seems to get it, let the girl's personality reflect in her game. The quote about the girl being in no man's land and no one telling her to back off is cool. She is aggressive, wants to attack the net, let her. When she is older she can adjust her game to mediate the strong passing shots she will encounter with the older girls. And she might become a great doubles player.

My girl has the same instincts. Many times she is too aggressive and attacks every ball and ends up too close to the net, but there is plenty of time long term to temper those instincts into a great all around game. I think we have plenty of kids who never venture off the baseline already.

Johnny Mac is seeing it takes a long time to get those special players he is looking for. It may be the super athletic 6 year old he needs to work with for years. Being on Randall's Island, he will not get tons of walk on super talents. His scouts will have to go find them.

This Neel girl looks interesting so far, lets see how she grows and competes.
 
my 8 year old son just beat the top 9 year old out of J.mcenroe academy, kid had mc style serve, net game etc.... My son just baselined and beat him 6-1
 

PennAlum

Rookie
my 8 year old son just beat the top 9 year old out of J.mcenroe academy, kid had mc style serve, net game etc.... My son just baselined and beat him 6-1

Woopie do, Basil. Jeez, it's not about winning in the 9's, it's about development so you can win in the 18's.
 

jhick

Hall of Fame
I just played against Ingrid in doubles this past Sunday. My 4.5 partner and I (was 5.0 successfully appealed to 4.5 recently) played her and a seasoned veteran and were down 1-4 before coming back on serve at 5-4. Currently her level is competitive against 4.5 level adult players. She played a seasoned 4.5 veteran (formerly a strong open player and Gustavus alum) and beat him in a close tiebreaker set 7-6.

The only thing holding her back is her height and overall strength at this point. She is something else.
 

jhick

Hall of Fame
FYI...how do you guys feel about her playing boys HS tennis?

I'm kind of mixed. Mayo HS has a very strong program and many of the boys have worked very hard to make the team. Most likely Ingrid will take one of these positions away.

She could play girls, but the competition isn't there for her. She already beats the 2 girls regularly from Rochester who finished first and second state last year.
 
Top