Honestly, I don't think any of these racquets would be good for someone just starting out. They headsize and weight might be too much of a challenge. That is not to say that a beginner can't use a control racquet, but that I would recommend getting a racquet that is 102-110 sq. in. depending on your hand-eye coordination. Also, a racquet that is neutral balance or headlight but that is over 10.4 oz strung with a lower swing weight and medium flex can be a very good racquet for someone who is athletic but is new to the game. In these cases, I tend to recommend something like the Wilson BLX Blade Team or Head Youtek Radical Oversize. Get 4 demos and try them before buying. The larger head-size but the control of the frame will make it a good racquet to grow into.