Dragy
Legend
Incorrect assumption.the energy he got from pushing off and uncoiling is wasted.
Incorrect assumption.the energy he got from pushing off and uncoiling is wasted.
True but you make me sound like a crazy person in my own little tennis world!I agree with the poster that says that Curious FH is pretty decent and he misses most of his FH because of footwork and spacing.
But I believe Curious likes to experiment with different stuff and it makes him happy to make such experiments and try different things with his stroke, so who are we to judge his decisions, just let him enjoy what he enjoys doing.
Everybody is limited, yet some limits are very highI'm afraid I might be limited there in terms of inborn skills, athleticism, yeah ok talent!
I agree with the poster that says that Curious FH is pretty decent and he misses most of his FH because of footwork and spacing.
But I believe Curious likes to experiment with different stuff and it makes him happy to make such experiments and try different things with his stroke, so who are we to judge his decisions, just let him enjoy what he enjoys doing.
I’m only suggesting against making unnecessary changes because I’ve seen a friend destroy what was probably the strongest part of her game by making an unnecessary change (as directed by her coach).
Rather than working on the problems that needed to be fixed, she became convinced that she needed to “fix” something that wasn’t broken. And since the change didn’t come naturally to her and she couldn’t get the hang of it, it just caused a problem where there wasn’t one before.
She eventually stopped playing matches because of it.
You should work on your weaknesses, true.
But you should also work on your strenghts, and build weapons with them.
Check Federer here at minute 5
Roger Federer: Strengths VS Weaknesses, The Team, Work-Life Balance, Winning As A Bonus... | SS Podcast | The Presto Post
Today’s show is all about arguably the greatest—and definitely the most graceful—tennis player to step foot on the court, Roger Federer. Instead of doing our own intro, here’s the first, quite astonishing, first paragraph from his wikipedia page...prestopost.org
I take your point seriously but let's just assume that tennis is about getting to the ball and hitting it well, broadly speaking. Aren't they both equally important?You should implement changes that will lead to improvement. As I mentioned before, I don’t think the change that @Curious is trying to make will do that, which is why I call it an unnecessary change.
If he wants to improve his forehand, then he should focus on his footwork, because that’s what is causing problems. If he can get his footwork to be more consistent, then he’ll consistently hit solid forehands with his current technique.
He’s trying to make himself do something that doesn’t come naturally and won’t lead to a noticeable improvement. He’s got a glaring weakness and an obvious route to improving his main weapon, but he’s focusing on a style change instead.
I take your point seriously but let's just assume that tennis is about getting to the ball and hitting it well, broadly speaking. Aren't they both equally important?
If you don't have the skill to hit the ball well, you will hit it badly even if you're there at the ideal time and ideal position. The opposite is also true.
You tighten up and muscle so much during the backswing that you lose a ton of power and sort of jam yourself up.
Try letting the racket drop begin sooner and with more gravity vs muscle. Also, that is the part of the swing that needs to incorporate the shoulder turn.
You're missing the point of a compact swing if you're still just going to arm and wrist the ball around.
@Curious is trying to engage his body, but it's all out of sync, so he is essentially arming it.
Put a tennis ball in your right armpit and keep it there as you hit. That should keep your swing nice and compact (and you can ditch the ball once you get the feel of it).
I may be wrong, but I'm pretty sure @Topspin Shot is more like 4.5/5.0-ish.You're a 3.5 player, correct?
How is he arming the FH when his shoulders rotate over 90 degrees?
He's also got great racket lag and RHS.
@Curious FH is better than most rec players, and is the last thing he should focus on.
No harm in academic debates dissecting video, but I would not waste any time trying to correct anything.
I take your point seriously but let's just assume that tennis is about getting to the ball and hitting it well, broadly speaking. Aren't they both equally important?
If you don't have the skill to hit the ball well, you will hit it badly even if you're there at the ideal time and ideal position. The opposite is also true.
Tonight I tried to focus mostly on torso rotation and extending the left arm to the right fence during the loading phase. This left arm extension is so important.
Here’s some points.
What exactly is being flat footed?The problem with your footwork is not that you don’t get to the right spot; it’s that you sometimes get to the spot early and stop, which leads to you being flat footed when you hit the ball. And when you stop in the wrong spot, you’re flat footed and your spacing is off.
This sounds like a great idea!Next time you have a light hit with someone, try to position yourself to hit the ball at the same height every time, no matter if it is a moonball or flat drive. Do not allow yourself to be lazy and hit balls shoulder/head high or scoop them off your shoelaces.
You'll find just how much more you have to move to accomplish this, but it'll also groove your strokes in a way that you don't really get when you allow yourself to stand in one spot and hit balls back at varying heights.
It's important to have a cooperative hitting partner so they aren't making you run extra just to screw with you.
I know someone who knows you! He’s probably around your level, also a forum member here. See if you can figure out who he is.It's some good hitting, seems much improved since the last one i saw
Where abouts are these courts?
By the way, i think we might have a mutual friend, we should have all have hit sometime
What exactly is being flat footed?
I see 3 issues here:
1. not being in the ideal position (spacing)
2. not being ready to swing
3. not being stationary/balanced when I get to the ball. This is similar to hitting the first volley on the run without a split step when you serve and volley. Pros always slow down to be balanced when they’re about to hit the ball although they get there very fast. ( unless they’re pushed wide by the opponent and hit on the run)
Watch the video from your first post again and check out the forehand at 1:49. That’s what a flat-footed shot looks like. Because you stopped moving your feet too early, you didn’t get your shoulders turned enough, you weren’t able to adjust to the spin on your opponent’s shot, and you didn’t step into the shot as you hit it. As a result, the ball got too close to you and you had to muscle it over the net.
Now, compare that to the forehand at 0:48. That’s what happens when you get your footwork right.
Pros are almost never stationary when they hit the ball. Most of the time, they step into the shot, even when hitting off the back foot. And when they don’t step into the shot, they still load up by bending their knees and turning their shoulders so that they can generate power by uncoiling.
Here’s David Goffin showing how it’s done.
True but you make me sound like a crazy person in my own little tennis world!
Anyway it's true I can get obsessed with small things, details but the quest is to play this bloody game better and better. I'm not ignoring the hugely important part of the game: fitness and footwork. Actually I'm one of those people here who are really interested in that too., having made a lot of threads.
The reality is I'm sure I can improve in the movement department but spacing with the ball, timing, coordination are the hardest things to improve in. I'm afraid I might be limited there in terms of inborn skills, athleticism, yeah ok talent!
It’s not that bad now actually. Especially after focusing on stretching left arm along the baseline during the turn without bending the elbow made a big difference. That way I turn more fully and don’t have to take the racket too far back to get power.Btw @Curious
Was bored today and went to check ur forehand in slow motion a bit for fun, and im wondering, how exactly does your forehand have a WTA takeback as you claimed? It looks completely the same as most ATP forehands bar some extremely compact ones like Federer, Dimitrov etc..
It seems like lately theres alot of vids about this short super compact forehand ala Federer, but in reality its not that common to have such an extremely compact one
WTA takeback is completely different
It’s not that bad now actually. Especially after focusing on stretching left arm along the baseline during the turn without bending the elbow made a big difference. That way I turn more fully and don’t have to take the racket too far back to get power.
Extreme behind the back racket take back?Do you have any other video where you were doing it more extremely?
Extreme behind the back racket take back?
Can't find now. It wasn't quite WTA actually but there was no flip of the racket.yeah
Speaking of on fire, white short is truly on fire, good form, good serve good FH, move well, play smart. this guy definitely took lessons.Here’s a full set from last night. It was great fun overall.
True. He’s got everything. The best in the group.Speaking of on fire, white short is truly on fire, good form, good serve good FH, move well, play smart. this guy definitely took lessons.
I recently got tempted again to give another go about working on developing a compact forehand Federer style especially after watching the Macci video once more ( @1stVolley posted the other day ).
Here’s my first attempt. The racket tip still annoyingly and stubbornly wants to go back behind me before I start the forward swing. I don’t want it to go beyond 5 o’clock position but that WTA style is so ingrained in my stroke that it sneaks in somehow. How do I stop it? Whaddaya reckon?
Based on this video, blame it on your partnerDestroyed by two young men last night although we didn’t play terrible. We lost 1-6 1-6. They were just too sharp.
I watched the first game and a half. My conclusion is that your partner can hit groundstrokes, but he is an awful doubles player. He is holding you back.Destroyed by two young men last night although we didn’t play terrible. We lost 1-6 1-6. They were just too sharp.
Ahahahahaah!I watched the first game and a half. My conclusion is that your partner can hit groundstrokes, but he is an awful doubles player. He is holding you back.
The point in the second game where Curious’ partner gave up his perfect net position to sprint-backpedal to no man’s land sealed my conclusion. I didn’t watch past that.Ahahahahaah!
I especially liked the lob he threw up from the baseline, to make damn good and sure the opponents could aim for poor Curious at the net with their overhead.
sorry to derail the thread, but Dragy in this post hits at something i have been struggling for years now (and have found myself in forehand purgatory like the one spaceman_spiff mentions about).If you wish to have Federer as example, here're you go. You lack going through position in frame 4. You get roughly to frame 3 and pull through with a level swing from there.
But Fed is kind of "post-textbook". There are players who are better demonstrating the basic sequence:
- take the racquet back high;
- initiate the pendulum drop - down and forward through close to the hip;
- meanwhile initiate torso uncoil, and as the racquet passes lowest point, drive with your right leg to accelerate the swing; let your arm and racquet trail into full lag;
- as soon as chest faces the target swing your arm towards and past the ball executing internal rotation - so that racquet head rises towards above handle.
Hey mate! I don't quite agree with that. Many pros actually do demonstrate pendulum drop initiating their FHs. Here is Stef Tsitsipas coming out of my Mad Skillz Photo Edition :the current atp players, including fed, differ from the basic sequence in that they don't do a pendulum drop
Don't watch your partner hitting the ball. Unless thats a really hot chick.Destroyed by two young men last night although we didn’t play terrible. We lost 1-6 1-6. They were just too sharp.
I’ve always wondered about that and thought of asking people here. I want to see where my partner is and what sort of shot he’s hitting. I have a habit of doing that although I didn’t learn it from anyone.Don't watch your partner hitting the ball. Unless thats a really hot chick.
Your eyes should be on the guy/gal on the otherside.
I’ve always wondered about that and thought of asking people here. I want to see where my partner is and what sort of shot he’s hitting. I have a habit of doing that although I didn’t learn it from anyone.