There is a lot less of this crap at 40+ vs 18+
The 40+ 3.5 guys who won SC Title had solid players and only one 3.5S out of 12 players - the other 11 were mostly B rated players - just a solid team with very good players from top to bottom.
The 18+ team who won the SC Title has five 3.5S players (actually won is 3.5D) out of the 12 3.5 players on the team - they also have a 3.0B and he did quite well- beating a lot of 3.5 guys- so hats off to him. The other 3.0 beat a few 3.5s so badly (one win was 1&1, another 2&3 over 3.5s) , that he he DQed at 3.0 - these type of teams can win at Districts and probably some will win Sectional and go to Nationals- some might even win nationals at 3.0 or 3.5. PR seems to get a lot of attention and comments -
But there are successful teams that don't cheat. The ones who assemble solid, smart players - the ones who can gut out wins - and yes even beat the sandbaggers.
I personally think this is what JRB's team and Mikler's 4.5 team did - so again congrats to you and team's like yours. It is great to hear of success like this from honest teams.
I just happen to see a lot of 18+ sandbagging at 3.5 and 4.0 in SC, but I can't say I witnessed any of this crap at 40+ in SC
And for the record, I went 17-1 at 3.5 for the spring of 2013. 6-0 at 40+ (3-0 at State in singles ), 12-1 at 18+ (2-0 at State in singles). I got an easy draw it seems all year. The last time I self rated was 2007, and the USTA seems to be happy with me at 3.5, because I spilt sets with two 3.5C players, I also spilt sets with two 3.5S players- beating one at State.
I lost one match at singles this year- yep the guy was self rated and in the 18+ league. . He remains unbeaten at singles - he lost one set this year, and said after the match said " I didn't expect a competitive match" When I asked, "what did you expect ?" He actually said to beat me 0&0. I am adamant I have the right to call him a sandbagger.
He dropped 4 aces on me in the 10 Pt TB. It was his first match if the season. I doubt I get one game off of him now.
So to the guys like JRB and others who went to Nationals the honest way- congrats . But please understand that what Ron Charles did with his 18+ team did in fact happen. And it happens elsewhere. They didn't win Sectionals, but can you imagine being on a team that played Harrison Read when he self rated 3.5? He went 5-0 at State at 4.0, and 4-1 and Sectionals losing to another 4.0S.
I play pickup matches with a 60+ year old guy who played at UMASS- he is so smooth, he glides around the court and makes other 4.0s look foolish - he refuses to play any 18+ leagues for the exact reasons this thread addresses - He plays tennis for fun and plays 40+ and 55+, and I've learned more about the game from this gentleman than I can ever repay him.
Thankfully there are 100 to 1 players like this man for every Ron Charles.