THUNDERVOLLEY
G.O.A.T.
The problem is that you reference them as though they have merit in this discussion, when the latest results--from the Wimbledon final--prove that nothing from the "experts" has transformed Roddick into a Federer-beater, or more than a one-slam wonder. There's no logic in supporting a system (meaning the "expert" coaches) which has been proven (by Roddicks's grand slam finals record) to be a complete failure (beyond his 1 slam) up to the last slam played.
I grew up loving Connors' game and appreciating Gilbert's (to a degree), but as a coach, either they failed--or Roddick is so hobbled by his own psychological and physical shortcomings, that no star coach (including his current) can help him win more slams/beat Federer in a slam.
You're essentially advocating fans saying nothing due to your reverence for pros. I reject that belief, for if a high-paid coach cannot see and correct the obvious flaws in Roddick's game--but fans are acutely aware of the flaws, then the have the right to make their suggestions, which are worthy for this reason: they will not follow the failed pattern set into motion by Roddick's coaches.
