McEnroeisanartist
Hall of Fame
Updated Comparison of Nadal and Federer at 17 Grand Slams won:
Nadal
17 Grand Slams, 1 Australian Open, 11 French Open, 2 Wimbledon, and 3 US Open
24 Grand Slam finals: 4 Australian Open, 11 French Open, 5 Wimbledon, and 4 US Open
27 Grand Slam semifinals: 5 Australian Open, 11 French Open, 5 Wimbledon, and 6 US Open
34 Grand Slam quarterfinals: 10 Australian Open, 12 French Open, 5 Wimbledon, and 7 US Open
Federer
17 Grand Slams: 4 Australian Open, 1 French Open, 7 Wimbledon, and 5 US Open
24 Grand Slam finals: 5 Australian Open, 5 French Open, 8 Wimbledon, and 6 US Open
32 Grand Slam semifinals: 9 Australian Open, 7 French Open, 8 Wimbledon, and 8 US Open
37 Grand Slam quarterfinals: 9 Australian Open, 9 French Open, 11 Wimbledon, and 8 US Open
After 17 Grand Slams
Nadal?
Federer 3 Grand Slams, 3 Grand Slam finals, 5 Grand Slam semifinals, 4 Grand Slam quarterfinals
Nadal
17 Grand Slams, 1 Australian Open, 11 French Open, 2 Wimbledon, and 3 US Open
24 Grand Slam finals: 4 Australian Open, 11 French Open, 5 Wimbledon, and 4 US Open
27 Grand Slam semifinals: 5 Australian Open, 11 French Open, 5 Wimbledon, and 6 US Open
34 Grand Slam quarterfinals: 10 Australian Open, 12 French Open, 5 Wimbledon, and 7 US Open
Federer
17 Grand Slams: 4 Australian Open, 1 French Open, 7 Wimbledon, and 5 US Open
24 Grand Slam finals: 5 Australian Open, 5 French Open, 8 Wimbledon, and 6 US Open
32 Grand Slam semifinals: 9 Australian Open, 7 French Open, 8 Wimbledon, and 8 US Open
37 Grand Slam quarterfinals: 9 Australian Open, 9 French Open, 11 Wimbledon, and 8 US Open
After 17 Grand Slams
Nadal?
Federer 3 Grand Slams, 3 Grand Slam finals, 5 Grand Slam semifinals, 4 Grand Slam quarterfinals