Then perhaps you should condition your response to: "among those I've ever seen."
There is a difference between a pusher hiting backspin lobs to good depth (Wilander), and a slice as a weapon. Here's a slice as a weapon:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nCnOpY5mfhY#t=78m15s
Sorry, let me rephrase, best slice backhands ever regardless of my having seen them.
Men: Becker
Women: Graf
Hows that?
Wilander was not a pusher....he hit a heavy solid ball, loved a target and could pass on a dime. He played brilliant clay court tennis and was fast and hit everything back. But he had lots of pace and his BH dipped like hell. His slice was a change of pace shot at the early part of his career and developed more into a setup for his volleys layer. Just revisit his classic 82 Davis Cup match v JMac in St Louis -
I've seen lots of his matches against Lendl. Just 6 hours of slice backhand pushes.
I don't think so. It helped him a lot against Lendl. Maybe against other players he used it too much -- and he did say himself that in '88 he wasn't hitting his topsin BH as well as he used to, because he was slicing so much. But that slice diminished Lendl's ability to attack him; Lendl could punish him far better when he got higher shots into his FH strike zone. I think Lendl like Wilander's topspin BH more than the slice.I agree with you. Wilander let that slice become far too pervasive in his game in later years. It was a good shot, steady and accurate but it was not offensive, and it did not worry opponents much except to move them around a bit and keep a rally going.
When he came to net in that match Wilander hit topspin approaches -- can't remember if there was any slice approach in there. There were some reports in the media that observed that his topspin approaches were not as effective as Noah's slice approaches.Was Wilander using slice BHs back then, or do you mean only Noah? I watched that final but I can't remember how Wilander was playing - Noah sort of stole the show.
I know that Wilander was using a lot of slice around 1987-88, but my impression has always been this was a shot he developed around that time, and that he used mostly his regular two handed drive in the early years.
If you right-click on the video itself, at the point you want to link to, you should get an option to generate a link to the clip at the current point.How do you post a link where the video starts at a chosen point?
If you right-click on the video itself, at the point you want to link to, you should get an option to generate a link to the clip at the current point.
There is a difference between a pusher hiting backspin lobs to good depth (Wilander), and a slice as a weapon. Here's a slice as a weapon:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nCnOpY5mfhY#t=78m15s
For Graf, you can make a pretty good argument. For Becker, that's pretty clueless!
Apparently my opinion that Boris Becker had a superior or perhaps the best ever slice bh makes me "clueless".
The slice is not a shot off of which winners are hit, it is used to set up the opportunity to hit a winner. My contention is that BB hit the backhand slice approach with unequaled ferocity and when he utilized this shot on his way to net the result was usually a volley hit for winner. Based on what I've witnessed and the opinion of a very respected tennis acquaintance of mine Becker could put more RPMs and bite on that shot than anyone.
If somebody disagrees with my opinion that's fine but it doesn't give one just cause to throw insults at me.
I'm kind of surprised to see Graf's name so much. If you had to pick the weakest part of her game, it was definitely her backhand. If there was one shot of her's you could exploit, it was her backhand. When experts commented that she would be unbelievable if she could consistently add a topspin backhand to her game, it was a backhanded compliment (excuse the pun); another way of saying her slice backhand was not enough on its own if she faced a real contender like Monica Seles. Her opponents would all hit to the backhand side, and she would run around it so much, it was common to see her on the left hand side of the left sideline during a rally.
Steffi Graf was one of my favorite women players of all-time, but I won't let that bias my opinion of her backhand. If her opponent was on the offense she used it to keep herself in the point until she had a chance to hit a winner with her forehand. At best she used it to set up a sitter for her forehand if she was in a position to do that. I'm guessing that her name is brought up just because we've all seen it so much, it was good enough to keep her at the top of women's tennis, and it's tough to think of other top women besides Martina, Billie Jean, and Evonne Goolagong who relied on slice as much.
I really don't know of a woman whose slice backhand would compare to a Rosewall or Laver. Rosewall's slice was widely known as one of the best shots in tennis. You can't say that about Steffi's backhand. The best backhands on the women's side are all topspin backhands. Justine Henin, for instance, had an incredible one-handed topspin backhand that Steffi Graf could only dream of having.
Nobody thinks Federer?
Apparently my opinion that Boris Becker had a superior or perhaps the best ever slice bh makes me "clueless".
The slice is not a shot off of which winners are hit, it is used to set up the opportunity to hit a winner. My contention is that BB hit the backhand slice approach with unequaled ferocity and when he utilized this shot on his way to net the result was usually a volley hit for winner. Based on what I've witnessed and the opinion of a very respected tennis acquaintance of mine Becker could put more RPMs and bite on that shot than anyone.
If somebody disagrees with my opinion that's fine but it doesn't give one just cause to throw insults at me.
I'll nominate this for most insane thread ever. There is no question that Rosewall had the best slice backhand in the game. He could drill that thing and skim right above the net with a regularity that no one has ever come close to. Laver, Graf, etc. all had nice slice BHs, Conners had a great slice 2HBH, and Edberg could knife a slice approach with the best of them. But they all look like a bunch of high-schoolers (very good high-schoolers for sure) next to "KR the slice ninja." I'd be amazed if anyone ever came close to him...
No some of us have seen live guys like Laver or Rosewall and current players and are able to compare. Were not little fanboys blinded by what we have seen only the last 7 or 8 years.
I personally think Roger is the 2nd or 3rd greatest player - but not his backhand.....
No some of us have seen live guys like Laver or Rosewall and current players and are able to compare. Were not little fanboys blinded by what we have seen only the last 7 or 8 years.
I personally think Roger is the 2nd or 3rd greatest player - but not his backhand.....
Rosewall had the best, most versatile slice ever. But, I wouldn't go so far as to say that Emerson, Laver, Ashe and Roche's slices looked like high schoolers by comparison.
Apparently my opinion that Boris Becker had a superior or perhaps the best ever slice bh makes me "clueless".
The slice is not a shot off of which winners are hit, it is used to set up the opportunity to hit a winner. My contention is that BB hit the backhand slice approach with unequaled ferocity and when he utilized this shot on his way to net the result was usually a volley hit for winner. Based on what I've witnessed and the opinion of a very respected tennis acquaintance of mine Becker could put more RPMs and bite on that shot than anyone.
If somebody disagrees with my opinion that's fine but it doesn't give one just cause to throw insults at me.
Yes, it's certainly a bit of hyperbole, but I think the 'slice ninja' bit was pretty solid...
Show me the video where Laver/Rosewall have hit those amazing(and difficult) slices like Fed have done.
So what if you ranked Fed 2nd or 3rd greatest player, that doesn't prove to me that you are not biased.
Show me the video where Laver/Rosewall have hit those amazing(and difficult) slices like Fed have done..
Rosewall was also a bit of a forehand, net game and footwork ninja as well. Further, IMO, Rosewall had some of the most beautiful looking groundstrokes and volleys I've ever seen. His timing and tempo were artistic in their beauty.
Check out this short video showing Rosewall and Roche warming up and see how fluid and flawless his timing, tempo and technique were warming up from the baseline with Roche at net:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=txaztRVQC94
Cochet, right?Henri
i am to old for graf's game
Have you forgotten? This is a former player talk forum, which means it's a Laverion/Rosewallion forum. And some of the old-timers haven't seen enough(if any) of Federer to begin with.
Just for the Fed's fans, here's a few of Fed's amazing slice.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B01nhqJizTc
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=igicoafWhT0
Don't worry about Fed's slice not making the top list of all time in here. We know how good he is.
WONDERFUL!! LOL! The fact that he thinks those slices are unique to Federer is so ridiculous...well it's a perfect example of TMF's tennis ignorance.
Aren't you a little judgemental here? You know people here respect Federer but some don't think his slice backhand is the best ever. So would you expect everything about Federer to be the best ever?
His forehand could be the best ever. His footwork is superb. His serve is superb and he has a good volley. I think most here if not virtually everyone would agree. So if some here who may have seen more slice backhands than most think Federer doesn't have the best slice backhand, why indict everyone who posts here?
Again, has anyone seen Margaret Court hit any backhand without slice or underspin? Can anyone show me any? I can show you Graf's topspin backhand
Is there really a difference between a player who never hits a topspin backhand and one who hits maybe one or two in a match? It's one thing to hit a good topspin backhand when you have a perfect setup. It's another thing to hit one on a regular basis (like Justine Henin).
If there were a poll for most elegant player ever, I would give the title to Rosewall for sure - taking it from Edberg by half a length.
Nope. I just don't believe so many players are put ahead of Federer, which in this case, the slice shot.
Elegant.
Evonne.
Adriano.
Henri
Orantes had a super sliced backhand.My uncle showed me some videos to prove it the other week. It was a knife of a slice. i think he is underrated in this compartment.