nousername
Rookie
Does it bother anyone else that the Hawk-eye system uses 12 HIGH-SPEED CAMERAs, yet challenges are based only on the digitized 3D ball-trajectory estimation?
Why not use the figiggin' high-speed video??? at TWELVE angles!!!
Hawk-eye has brilliantly conned the ATP and Grand Slam events into thinking their system is needed for challenges.
Is it not obvious to everyone that an umpire with access to 12 high-speed camera angles could do a MUCH better job than a computer generated estimate?
Shouldn't the high-speed video with a human at the wheel be used instead?
Especially in "unique" situations like this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IhUmGiT5GqY&feature=related
The ball clearly hit Petzchner's leg, and the point should have gone to the Poles. Playing back the 12 high-speed video feeds surely could have cleared this up.
The digital 3D ball-trajectories are good for commentary and teaching. But the video feeds that generate those trajectories should be the source used for resolving challenges, NOT the digital 3D trajectory.
this has been my pet-peeve with the pro game ever since the advent of hawk-eye ...
Why not use the figiggin' high-speed video??? at TWELVE angles!!!
Hawk-eye has brilliantly conned the ATP and Grand Slam events into thinking their system is needed for challenges.
Is it not obvious to everyone that an umpire with access to 12 high-speed camera angles could do a MUCH better job than a computer generated estimate?
Shouldn't the high-speed video with a human at the wheel be used instead?
Especially in "unique" situations like this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IhUmGiT5GqY&feature=related
The ball clearly hit Petzchner's leg, and the point should have gone to the Poles. Playing back the 12 high-speed video feeds surely could have cleared this up.
The digital 3D ball-trajectories are good for commentary and teaching. But the video feeds that generate those trajectories should be the source used for resolving challenges, NOT the digital 3D trajectory.
this has been my pet-peeve with the pro game ever since the advent of hawk-eye ...