2019 Barcelona General discussion – ATP 500

Who will be this week's King of Clay?


  • Total voters
    32
  • Poll closed .
Good for Medvedev. That's two weeks in a row he has played well. Maybe a win in this event. There are no players left in the draw who will slice the tall Russian to death and draw errors like Lajovic did last week.
 
D

Deleted member 765152

Guest
Med may become the modern Robin Soderling on clay.
He is already working on a new string, DM Barcelona.
 

Mainad

Bionic Poster
Ouch that's got to hurt for Nishi. 3-1 up in the deciding set and can't close it out. I felt that it had become a test of stamina between him and Medvedev because there was so little to choose between them level wise and Medvedev has the advantage of being younger. Besides, we all know what long matches do to Nishi's fitness levels so I had my doubts he would have had enough left in the tank for tomorrow's final anyway. In that sense, maybe the fitter guy won.
 

mike danny

Bionic Poster
Ouch that's got to hurt for Nishi. 3-1 up in the deciding set and can't close it out. I felt that it had become a test of stamina between him and Medvedev because there was so little to choose between them level wise and Medvedev has the advantage of being younger. Besides, we all know what long matches do to Nishi's fitness levels so I had my doubts he would have had enough left in the tank for tomorrow's final anyway. In that sense, maybe the fitter guy won.
Just like it should be. Enough with these old geezers grinding down the young ones.
 

mike danny

Bionic Poster
If Medvedev brings this level to the slams on a regular basis, he'll be a consistent top 10 player if he avoids injuries.

He may not win a major, but I wouldn't put a Berdych-like career past him.
 

reaper

Legend
If Medvedev brings this level to the slams on a regular basis, he'll be a consistent top 10 player if he avoids injuries.

He may not win a major, but I wouldn't put a Berdych-like career past him.

He probably will win a major if he keeps playing like that. Last year 7 different players made a slam final, and today Medvedev beat the world number 7 who was playing well. If he takes that form to slams over the next decade, he'll make several slam finals and probably win one...or more.
 

mike danny

Bionic Poster
He probably will win a major if he keeps playing like that. Last year 7 different players made a slam final, and today Medvedev beat the world number 7 who was playing well. If he takes that form to slams over the next decade, he'll make several slam finals and probably win one...or more.
We'll see.

He needs to shorten points more in the slams. His grinding style won't do him any favors in BO5.
 

Meles

Bionic Poster
He probably will win a major if he keeps playing like that. Last year 7 different players made a slam final, and today Medvedev beat the world number 7 who was playing well. If he takes that form to slams over the next decade, he'll make several slam finals and probably win one...or more.
Meddy's not even serving all that well in 2019. Put that with the ground game and slams assured.:p
 
Thiemerer knows slice, no? Nadal knows slice, too. Both know to use it when it works.

Hmmm... I can't recall a match in which Nadal or Thiem had the patience to work over an opponent with slices. That may be because I don't watch enough tennis, but to my memory they both like to bludgeon their opponents. Can you name a match in which one of them switched to low slices when "plan A" wasn't working. I'm struggling to do so.
 

gerko

New User
Hmmm... I can't recall a match in which Nadal or Thiem had the patience to work over an opponent with slices. That may be because I don't watch enough tennis, but to my memory they both like to bludgeon their opponents. Can you name a match in which one of them switched to low slices when "plan A" wasn't working. I'm struggling to do so.
Djokovic us open 2013 slice down the line forehand down the line
 

stringertom

Bionic Poster
Hmmm... I can't recall a match in which Nadal or Thiem had the patience to work over an opponent with slices. That may be because I don't watch enough tennis, but to my memory they both like to bludgeon their opponents. Can you name a match in which one of them switched to low slices when "plan A" wasn't working. I'm struggling to do so.
I didn’t imply either will have to go to “plan B” and wholeheartedly rely on slice but here’s a perfect example of what Thiem can do vs a taller, power oriented opponent not usually known for steady clay rallying:


Thiem’s touch and even the amount of sidespin imparted on his ohbh drives that often induce errors or weaker responses is quite overlooked when people stereotype him as a monotonous ball basher.

Nadal doesn’t have the advantage of disguising his dropper from the backhand but he also gets winners or set-up putaways from changing pace and spins.
 

mike danny

Bionic Poster
And yet another young one (well, comparatively so) has ground down yet another of these old geezers. Do we sense a turning of the tide at long last?
If it starts happening at the slams, then yes.

Until then, the young guys still suck in my eyes.
 

van_Loederen

Professional
He probably will win a major if he keeps playing like that. Last year 7 different players made a slam final, and today Medvedev beat the world number 7 who was playing well. If he takes that form to slams over the next decade, he'll make several slam finals and probably win one...or more.
defeating 2019 Nishikori makes one a candidate for winning Slams? :unsure:

How come he is peaking at his worst surface:unsure:
peaking? :laughing:


it's often hard to tell the level of play if the match is close.
 

van_Loederen

Professional
Medvdv is the prototype of 'the next gen' player. physically he's even more economic than Zverev.
that's why he might have less issues with the best-of-5 format, but still a lot.
 

reaper

Legend
defeating 2019 Nishikori makes one a candidate for winning Slams? :unsure:


defeating 2019 Nishikori makes one a candidate for winning Slams? :unsure:


peaking? :laughing:


it's often hard to tell the level of play if the match is close.

Was it hard to tell the level of play in that match? Both players are top 10 in the race, with winning ratios around 70% and it was good to watch. There's no reason to believe either were playing to a level below Nishikori's ranking of 7. That's a good level to be playing too with the top 6 looking as fragile as it is.
 

Meles

Bionic Poster
Hope that jogs your Melesian memory. Sadly, due to illness Cecchinato will not defend Budapest, leaving it open perhaps for a bad clay courter like Coric to win.
Well at least Cecch had a decent Monte Carlo. Where is @Checkmate 's crystal ball this year?
giphy.gif
 

stringertom

Bionic Poster
Kei was almost unbeatable in the deciding. I don't know how to explain it.

FTFY...since AO, Kei is an abysmal 1-5 in deciding sets after the mdvdv loss. Only Mannarino lost and that was a TB. Two to Hurkacz and one each to Stan, Lajovic and now mdvdv.
 

Meles

Bionic Poster
How come he is peaking at his worst surface:unsure:
I thought it possible his vanishly low UE counts of the last six months might translate to clay. I suspect Thiem will expose the Medvedev game rather badly on clay as both he and Nadal pretty much devour slices and Meddy's flat balls work best when they stay low.
 
Top