torpantennis
Legend
I got a bit interested of the bagels within the H2H of the Big 4. Being able to bagel a fellow Big 4 member requires utter dominance, playing in the god-mode, the absolute highest peak of the respective player. OTOH, if the opponent can bagel you, it's a sign of a mental collapse, weak mental toughness and weak abiity to fight when everything is going against you.
Here are all the Big 4 matches that got bagels:
Federer-Nadal:
WTF 2011: 6-3 6-0
RG 2008 1-6 3-6 0-6
Hamburg 2007: 2-6 6-2 6-0
Wimbledon 2006: 6-0 7-6 6-7 6-3
Federer-Djokovic:
2012 Cincinnati: 6-0 7-6
Federer-Murray: NO BAGELS
Nadal-Djokovic: NO BAGELS
Nadal-Murray:
Tokyo 2011: 6-3 2-6 0-6
Rotterdam 2009: 3-6 6-4 0-6
Djokovic-Murray:
Monte Carlo 2008: 6-0 6-4
Miami 2007: 6-1 6-0
Bagels served:
Federer: 4
Nadal: 1
Djokovic: 2
Murray: 2
Bageled:
Federer: 1
Nadal: 5
Djokovic: 1
Murray: 2
Going by bagel stats, the players' level peak-to-peak:
Federer > Djokovic = Murray > Nadal
An players' mental toughness:
Federer = Djokovic > Murray >> Nadal
All in all
Federer > Djokovic > Murray > Nadal!
Here are all the Big 4 matches that got bagels:
Federer-Nadal:
WTF 2011: 6-3 6-0
RG 2008 1-6 3-6 0-6
Hamburg 2007: 2-6 6-2 6-0
Wimbledon 2006: 6-0 7-6 6-7 6-3
Federer-Djokovic:
2012 Cincinnati: 6-0 7-6
Federer-Murray: NO BAGELS
Nadal-Djokovic: NO BAGELS
Nadal-Murray:
Tokyo 2011: 6-3 2-6 0-6
Rotterdam 2009: 3-6 6-4 0-6
Djokovic-Murray:
Monte Carlo 2008: 6-0 6-4
Miami 2007: 6-1 6-0
Bagels served:
Federer: 4
Nadal: 1
Djokovic: 2
Murray: 2
Bageled:
Federer: 1
Nadal: 5
Djokovic: 1
Murray: 2
Going by bagel stats, the players' level peak-to-peak:
Federer > Djokovic = Murray > Nadal
An players' mental toughness:
Federer = Djokovic > Murray >> Nadal
All in all
Federer > Djokovic > Murray > Nadal!