I for one find this article to have a lot of merit! For several years now I am wondering why I don't like the way Nadal plays and what is wrong about the picture that I dislike it this much. And I know lots of people in here do know what I am talking about.
I even tried with the comment on that above mentioned site, but I went too far and too wide and lost my compass all together! Since then I was thinking more about that and here is my final conclusion.
The main reason why I hate to watch Nadal's game is because I don't like that type of game. One of my friends that I play a lot with has decent forehand, but very weak backhand and most balls are just defensive slices one after another. Whenever I tried to play high looping top spin ball to his backhand he would suffer so much and I would win most of the points. But, I can't do that kind of game because it is lame for me to win that way! And great part of Nadal's game looks just like that!
Now, there is a huge difference between my perspective and Nadal's and that is in why we do this! For Nadal, this all job that pays big bucks and all the rest that comes from winning the games and tournaments. In order to do so, people will do whatever works and if hitting every single ball through your legs would gain most points everybody would be doing it! And, for Nadal his type of game obviously works extremely well and get him his praises! And he might even enjoy what he does and for him that is the way to do it! And all of it is just the way it should be! Asking for anything different in Nadal's case would be like asking Pete not to serve that well since most people have difficulty returning them. There is no difference for me between those two.
Now from my angle, I don't play tennis for leaving and I don't have to win all those matches to pay my bills. I play tennis because I enjoy hitting balls the right way (whatever is that for me). I enjoy hitting one handed backhand down the line or cross court even if I loose point after that. I enjoy hitting the serve well that goes in the corner where I wanted it too go regardless if my opponent returns it so well that he/she wins the point right there! Those are some of the things that make me to get out to the court and hit the balls!!
So, from that perspective, I don't like Nadal's type of game because I don't like to do that myself. and when I do some of it the way he does it, the winnings that I get from it are bitter enough to make me not to do it again! If I would have to live like a samurai and loosing of the game would mean loosing your life, I would definitely do things differently. But, that is not the case, at least for me and those are my reasons for not liking his game.
What is your reason for liking or disliking Nadal's game? How about Federer? Or anyone else? The point here is that all these guys are great athletes and we all have so much to learn from each one of them. Find out what you like and try to do it the same or even better. Recognize what you don't like from them and make sure you don't do the same. That is the best way to gain from this article or anything else around us instead of just plain calling names and unnecessary confrontations.
All the best!
Fedja