Fact is though, Roger has defeated Rafa the 5 last times they have played, on hard courts. Raf's career has been great enough so that he need not win any more HC slams or other HC tournaments to be considered an ATG.What a Nadal hater.
In the last 1.5 years, Nadal reached the 2019 AO final (Federer lost in the 4 R), won 2018 Toronto, reached the 2018 USO SF (Federer hasn't done that since 2015) and won the 2017 US Open (Federer hasn't done that since 2008). So it is far from true that "the only one he's finished in the last 1.5 years or so is the AO 2019".