Roger Fined

pmerk34

Legend
Are you serious? The rules extend to all players, regardless of ranking and number of titles, if they took a skip on the incident, then what kind of example would they be setting to the other players?

The same example they set with McEnroe and Connors for years. And the other players didn't turn unto profane jerks
 

icedevil0289

G.O.A.T.
Are you serious? The rules extend to all players, regardless of ranking and number of titles, if they took a skip on the incident, then what kind of example would they be setting to the other players?

exactly. He cursed, he got fined. Fed is not above the rules. Got that fed haters/*********s, fed is not above the rules.
 

Moose Malloy

G.O.A.T.
From reading the article: what did Nestor do?



NEW YORK -- Canada's Daniel Nestor is out of the U.S. Open after an ill-tempered quarter-final loss in men's doubles action Tuesday.

The Toronto native and his Serbian partner Nenad Zimonjic suffered a 6-7 (4-7), 6-4, 6-0 loss to Max Mirnyi of Belarus and Andy Ram of Israel.

Nestor was furious with chair umpire Lynn Welch for not controlling what appeared to be a rowdy bunch who stood out in the sparcely populated Grandstand stadium. They yelled and distracted in support of Mirnyi and Ram, which bothered Nestor and Zimonjic enough to complain.

"Your job is to say something, this is not Davis Cup," the 37-year-old Canadian told the chair. "There is something called sportsmanship."

He and the burly Ram then exchanged harsh words after the loss.

"I don't mind losing if we get beat," said Nestor. "But not losing if some guy in the crowd is acting like a jackass. I remember him from Cincinnati last year making the same kind of noises and clapping between serves.

"I got in his face about it and got a warning (fifth game of the third set). I asked Ram about it in the locker-room and he claimed not to know anything -- said he was too focused on his game or something."

http://www.tsn.ca/tennis/story/?id=290440
 

OddJack

G.O.A.T.
Are you serious? The rules extend to all players, regardless of ranking and number of titles, if they took a skip on the incident, then what kind of example would they be setting to the other players?

Yes, serious.. If they want to fine they should fire that incompetent umpire.
 
1500 bucks, For profanity. Pretty stupid. If I were him, I would threath them not to play in their tourny so they would lose hundreds of thousands.

http://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/news_di..._US_Open.html?siteSect=104&sid=11233104&ty=nd

Roger was right to say what he said.

If anything Del Potro should be the one to pick up a fine or 2. He stalled and questioned the umpire before he made his challenge and that took way too long . Also he was aced at one point and was really trying to read that serve but failed and after the ball had hit the curtain and ground after it had passed him , he decide to claim he was not ready due to some paper or what not.. The ace was nullified and Fed lost the point that was palyed instead of getting the ace he had delivered

Besides that Del Potro played a great great match.
 

T Woody

Rookie
If anything Del Potro should be the one to pick up a fine or 2. He stalled and questioned the umpire before he made his challenge and that took way too long.

:) You're not serious about this right? This type of thing stems from officials and tourney directors giving far too much leeway to the players and not standing their ground on the so called 2 second rule.
 

jmverdugo

Hall of Fame
Well, seems more than fear to me, he did the wrong thing he should be fined, what about when he broke the racquet I am pretty sure he got fined that time too.
 

P_Agony

Banned
Roger was right to say what he said.

If anything Del Potro should be the one to pick up a fine or 2. He stalled and questioned the umpire before he made his challenge and that took way too long . Also he was aced at one point and was really trying to read that serve but failed and after the ball had hit the curtain and ground after it had passed him , he decide to claim he was not ready due to some paper or what not.. The ace was nullified and Fed lost the point that was palyed instead of getting the ace he had delivered

Besides that Del Potro played a great great match.

Fed's mistake was that he let that get to him instad of just staying focused and winning the match. I'm not saying he'd have won the match if none of this would have happened, but I'm pretty sure Fed wouldn't have been so angry as he was.
 

rocket

Hall of Fame
Fed's mistake was that he let that get to him instad of just staying focused and winning the match. I'm not saying he'd have won the match if none of this would have happened, but I'm pretty sure Fed wouldn't have been so angry as he was.

Tennis players are known for taking it out on the umpires. Fed was extremely frustrated with his serve that day.
 
S

SerbWhoLovesDelPo

Guest
It's no big deal really. They all get fined for saying things on court.

I still can't believe Sky stayed with him and didn't go to the break.:)

Yeah, I watched the recorded match from Shy and there was the whole thing. ESPN, on the other hand, cut to the commercials when he was going nuts.
 

pmerk34

Legend
Tennis players are known for taking it out on the umpires. Fed was extremely frustrated with his serve that day.

Which is why I was glad Serena took it out on the moron who made that awful call. Instead of yelling at the ump who had nothing to do with it
 

Tshooter

G.O.A.T.
No one cares about doubles at the USO unless it's the Williams or the Bryans. That's reality. There had to be 10x the number of people at the food court then at the Men's finals this year.

Nestor should be thankful people actually showed up and were interested in the match.
 

Bud

Bionic Poster
They should have taken the sportsman awards of him aswell.

If he gets that lame sportsman award after this year's multiple outbursts, a smashed racquet and a string of profanities... it's more of a joke than I already assumed.
 

topspin

Semi-Pro
They should have given him a discount on the fine for making it sound so classy:)

Well it's right that the rules were followed with the fine. I'm sure it's just gum money to him. The ref should also get reprimanded for allowing that to happen in the first place. They should make it clear to all players as to how much time is tolerated before a challenge is called and whether or not they are allowed to consult with their coaches. From what I know, this is not allowed, but I'm not 100% sure since it seems to happen a lot.
 

quest01

Hall of Fame
Federer shouldn't have been fined for using simple profanity. I can understand why Serena was fined for using profanity and telling someone that "I want to kill you" but not Federer. Federer and Serena are completely different individuals, Federer has a lot of class while Serena is all trash.
 

JennyS

Hall of Fame
Federer shouldn't have been fined for using simple profanity. I can understand why Serena was fined for using profanity and telling someone that "I want to kill you" but not Federer. Federer and Serena are completely different individuals, Federer has a lot of class while Serena is all trash.


thatsracistgm751224856460.gif

(just kidding)
 

ksbh

Banned
If they give Federer the Stefan Edberg sportsmanship award again this year, that award will have as much credibility or value as used Kleenex tissues!

If he gets that lame sportsman award after this year's multiple outbursts, a smashed racquet and a string of profanities... it's more of a joke than I already assumed.
 

ksbh

Banned
Exactly! John Mcnroe came and went. So did Pete & Andre. Federer's absence will make no difference. The game has survived over a 100 years!

And by the way, there were probably more people cheering for Juan MDP anyways!

i see you believe Roger is bigger than the game!

well...

what can we say about that...?
 

35ft6

Legend
Fed should have pulled the money out of his socks.

The cynic in me wonders if this fine was issued partly so that they can minimize the events surrounding Serena. You know, she was fined, but hey, so was Fed, the most beloved player in tennis. Stuff happens.
 

Tyrus

Professional
The fine of pocket change is whatever to Fed, and just a way for the USTA to say "we don't tolerate profanity." Think of the children!

However the real issue is that the chair ump should be fired for letting that happen.
 

Chadwixx

Banned
If they give Federer the Stefan Edberg sportsmanship award again this year, that award will have as much credibility or value as used Kleenex tissues!

Kinda like when jimmy "cracker" carter was awarded the nobel peace prize for disarming north korea

Fed was almost provoked though with the incompetence shown.
 

Bud

Bionic Poster
Kinda like when jimmy "cracker" carter was awarded the nobel peace prize for disarming north korea

Fed was almost provoked though with the incompetence shown.

Please save the right-wing talking points for the Rants & Raves forum :oops:
 

Chadwixx

Banned
Please save the right-wing talking points for the Rants & Raves forum :oops:

"If they give Federer the Stefan Edberg sportsmanship award again this year, that award will have as much credibility or value as used Kleenex tissues!"

Feel free to make a better comparison, if not, then you know what todo :)
 
Top