I was going to point this out. I'm not sure the gross measure of serve games won is much of a measure of return at this level, but, when you compound that even further by correlating serve ability with ranking....I think the validity flies right out the window.
And that's another thing I'm worried about. I don't want to be rigid so I'll give in to some points. It seems to me that point of the article was whether Agassi is the default choice for GOAT of service return and whether there is debate on his status as the best returner in his time. I think we'll muddling in too many different scenarios and examining whether it's top ten, top twenty. We now should go whether the serves of Chang's opponents are superior to Agassi's opponent. It's getting too complicated for a simple point and it's very simple. Can anyone say with 100% or 90% or even 5% confidence that Agassi is the best serve returner of his time? I think it's debatable.
It's not quite like Sampras who led the ATP in percentage of holding serve in most of the ten years and even when he wasn't leading he was very close. Sampras is legit in his argument for greatest server.
Agassi led the ATP only a few times in percentage of breaking serve during the ten years examined and some years he wasn't in the top ten. The GOAT of returner should be better than that.
I guess we just have to disagree. I don't want to keep beating a dead drum. My point is Agassi doesn't have enough when we examine his record to be call the return GOAT.
We don't have all the information for the amount of games played. It's just not substantial enough information for me.
I'm just going to stop on this topic. I understand everyone's reasoning and it is all logical and does make sense. Below is the information again. If the returners are in the top ten, it is listed. If they are out of the top ten, the ranking is not shown.
1991
Agassi 29% service games won-56 matches
Chang 36% 67 matches-3rd in ATP
1992
Agassi 34% 57 matches-6th in ATP
Chang 37% 80 matches-1st in ATP
1993
Agassi 37% 44 matches-1st in ATP
Chang 33% 87 matches-5th in ATP
1994
Agassi 34% 66 matches-5th in ATP
Chang 33% 87 matches-6th in ATP
1995
Agassi 36% 82 matches-2nd in ATP
Chang 32% 84 matches- 8th in ATP
1996
Agassi 31% 52 matches-8th in ATP
Chang 35% 84 matches-1st in ATP
1997
Agassi 28% 24 matches
Chang 33% 68 matches-2nd in ATP
1998
Agassi 32% 86 matches 3rd in ATP
Chang 30% 52 matches
1999
Agassi 33% 77 matches-1st in ATP
Chang 26% 52 matches
2000
Agassi 28% 55 matches
Chang 29% 68 matches-5th in ATP