iPhone 5 or Samsung Galaxy s3?

Which phone is better overall?

  • iPhone 5

    Votes: 129 49.0%
  • Samsung Galaxy s3

    Votes: 134 51.0%

  • Total voters
    263

Ico

Hall of Fame
The iPhone 5, Nexus 4, and HTC's 8X all earn bonus points because they leave the manufacturer and carrier logos on the back. Verizon's Note II looks absolutely ridiculous with its logo ON the home button.
 

DRII

G.O.A.T.
Huge win for my i5 and Verizon. I'm on the highway in the middle of nowhere and am able to get lte speed and stream in hd the end of lsu game. Picture quality was amazing with no buffering. Here is the screenshot. Sprint never got me a signal out here.

weicA.jpg

You can't watch true HD on the iPhone!

Try again...
 
The Google Galaxy Nexus is a pretty good phone for the money. Too bad that they do not sell it anymore. My daughter has one. Slightly bigger screen, 4g, lots of features though not as fully-functioned as an S3. For $350 unlocked, though, it was a nice phone.

They really dropped the ball with the camera on this phone though, it's terrible. The screen is pretty mediocre too compared with current phones available.
 

movdqa

Talk Tennis Guru
They really dropped the ball with the camera on this phone though, it's terrible. The screen is pretty mediocre too compared with current phones available.

Well, you're comparing it to phones well north of $500 unlocked.

The feature-set is very good for what you pay.
 

acura9927

Semi-Pro
Anyone have Sprint. Any success in calling them and saying stop charging me 10 bucks extra for premium net access when its all 3G and not the advertsised 4G LTE. In Seattle they might never get 4G LTE here. I was a bit suckered into the umlimited plan or I would have stuck with Verizon. I was unlimited with them but had to pay full price for the note 2.
 

Power Player

Bionic Poster
No, you are screwed. That is why when you made your thread asking for carriers I suggested verizon. That is also why everyone in here, regardless of phone choice universally pans sprint.
 
G

guitarplayer

Guest
Apple fired the guy in charge of their iPhone MAPS today. Siting it was a disaster from the start.
 

Power Player

Bionic Poster
I have gotten lucky so far. Maps has delivered for me. Used it for a family excursion last weekend with pinpoint success.

This phoan is goating for me. Cards app is sick..get it. Dali, I got the Foap. Im going to be rich one day when I capture the perfect sunset over the hills of Lauderdale and filter the crap out of it for the win.
 

movdqa

Talk Tennis Guru
Well, Apple Maps is better than Nokia Maps. It looks like the new Nokia Here App is worse than Apple Maps.

I use Apple Maps for navigation and a quick overview of traffic. Apple Maps is much faster than Google Maps and Nokia Maps because it does vector drawing instead of bitmap drawing. It also uses much less bandwidth.

To get detailed traffic information, I use Google Maps, even though it's slower.

I use a dedicated Garmin Nuvi to do actual navigation.

Google should have a new vector implementation of their Maps App by the end of the year. I imagine that it will also have turn-by-turn and ads. Nokia has stated that they are working on getting vector drawing; what they recently put out was just a first pass.
 
D

Deleted member 232704

Guest
I loved the Nokia maps. Tried the Apple Maps for a quick sec on a friends phone but it looked like Nokia Maps was faster. Sadly i sold my Lumia 900 :(
 

acura9927

Semi-Pro
For those with Sprint and able to get 4g LTE is it up to the hype?
I had 4g Verizon and it was god awful, it was probably the phone, the htc thunderbolt. It ran faster on 3G.
 

DRII

G.O.A.T.
For those with Sprint and able to get 4g LTE is it up to the hype?
I had 4g Verizon and it was god awful, it was probably the phone, the htc thunderbolt. It ran faster on 3G.


Verizon's 4g is less consistent than AT&T as far as speed, although they have more coverage.
 

mikeler

Moderator
The Apple maps application continues to quietly improve with the background data getting better. It is fast and when I was in NYC, the 3D thing was really cool. When I was up there, I turned my work e-mail off for a few days. Once I did that, I would use my phone a lot all day and never use more than 1/3 of my battery by the end of the day. There is something with my work servers that drain the battery.
 
For those with Sprint and able to get 4g LTE is it up to the hype?
I had 4g Verizon and it was god awful, it was probably the phone, the htc thunderbolt. It ran faster on 3G.

The Thunderbolt was a notorious flop. Just a terrible phone. Battery that lasted for 20 minutes, spotty signal, slow performance.

Verizon LTE is currently very, very good if you live in or near a city. ATT has the benefit of having HSPA+ ("4G"), as well as a more limited LTE deployment, so non LTE speeds on ATT are typically faster, but you're more likely to be on HSPA+ than LTE.

I live in Phoenix, and I get 15-35Mbps download speeds on Verizon LTE. The places I've traveled (Portland OR, Seattle, WA, Los Angeles) give me similar speeds.
 

Power Player

Bionic Poster
Getting 35 down here as well. The VZW customer service is incredible as well. I am stunned at the overall difference in quality in every single aspect. My bill is also a little less. I may not have unlimited data, but I do have unlimited talk time and I am finding that to be a very fair tradeoff.
 
Getting 35 down here as well. The VZW customer service is incredible as well. I am stunned at the overall difference in quality in every single aspect. My bill is also a little less. I may not have unlimited data, but I do have unlimited talk time and I am finding that to be a very fair tradeoff.

Yeah I'm happy with the switch to VZW. My bill is a bit more than it was on TMo, but the service is way better, LTE, unlimited talk and text, etc.

My wife and I split 4GB of data, and we use like 1.5GB a month...Not sure how it's so low, we're both on WiFi at home, but I stream Pandora/Spotify in my car, use the phone quite a bit when out and about, stream video, etc. 4GB is proving to be plenty for our needs.
 
Anyone have Sprint. Any success in calling them and saying stop charging me 10 bucks extra for premium net access when its all 3G and not the advertsised 4G LTE. In Seattle they might never get 4G LTE here. I was a bit suckered into the umlimited plan or I would have stuck with Verizon. I was unlimited with them but had to pay full price for the note 2.

I fought the Sprint battle for years and lost. They are flat out lying to and ripping their customers off. Their 3G speeds are the slowest anywhere (slower than AT&T's EDGE [2G] speeds). You need to cut your losses now and leave them. I did and have never looked back. Never been happier.
 
The Thunderbolt was a notorious flop. Just a terrible phone. Battery that lasted for 20 minutes, spotty signal, slow performance.

Verizon LTE is currently very, very good if you live in or near a city. ATT has the benefit of having HSPA+ ("4G"), as well as a more limited LTE deployment, so non LTE speeds on ATT are typically faster, but you're more likely to be on HSPA+ than LTE.

I live in Phoenix, and I get 15-35Mbps download speeds on Verizon LTE. The places I've traveled (Portland OR, Seattle, WA, Los Angeles) give me similar speeds.

AT&T's LTE 'switch' was flipped where I live 2 weeks ago and it's been great. I do think I am ditching the iPhone 5 for the new HTC One X+. iPhone 5 is great but I loved the One X back over the summer and now that a super charged version is available I'm all over it.
 

acura9927

Semi-Pro
I fought the Sprint battle for years and lost. They are flat out lying to and ripping their customers off. Their 3G speeds are the slowest anywhere (slower than AT&T's EDGE [2G] speeds). You need to cut your losses now and leave them. I did and have never looked back. Never been happier.

I cant go back to Verizon, I ported the number already to Sprint and they probably wont offer me back that unlimited data for 30 per month since they dont offer unlimited net anymore.
 
D

Deleted member 232704

Guest
Paid for AT&T's 4GLTE service to realize that there is little to no coverage in our area.
 

JoelDali

Talk Tennis Guru
I spoak to several Internet critix last night at Terminal 5 and they all agreed that the iPhone 5 is the greatest iPhone evar. Sorry iPhone 3GS.
 

DRII

G.O.A.T.
The Thunderbolt was a notorious flop. Just a terrible phone. Battery that lasted for 20 minutes, spotty signal, slow performance.

Verizon LTE is currently very, very good if you live in or near a city. ATT has the benefit of having HSPA+ ("4G"), as well as a more limited LTE deployment, so non LTE speeds on ATT are typically faster, but you're more likely to be on HSPA+ than LTE.

I live in Phoenix, and I get 15-35Mbps download speeds on Verizon LTE. The places I've traveled (Portland OR, Seattle, WA, Los Angeles) give me similar speeds.

AT&T scored the best regarding 4g among the major carriers. Although Verizon scored highest overall. Verizon's signal is relatively inconsistent, speeds vary more than with AT&T. Verizon does have higher top end speed but doesn't stay there (Venus vs Serena analogy to tennis)...

http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/2012/11/29/att-mixed-results-consumer-reports-survey/1733287/

I may switch to AT&T, just to see how it is with them; especially if Verizon tries to downgrade my unlimitied data for loyal customers. i think AT&T has the best phones and gets them sooner as well...
 

Polaris

Hall of Fame
I may switch to AT&T, just to see how it is with them; especially if Verizon tries to downgrade my unlimitied data for loyal customers. i think AT&T has the best phones and gets them sooner as well...

Do you think that unlimited 3G data for existing month-to-month customers is going away soon? That would suck. The last time I spoke with a VZ customer service representative, he mentioned that I could have my unlimited 3G data as long as I didn't purchase my devices from VZ.

I know that eventually, they will take unlimited 3G data away from us. I just hope that it is not too soon. Maybe, they can offer unlimited coverage as a lollipop to those who stay with 3G rather than upgrading to blazing fast LTE? :)
 

Power Player

Bionic Poster
The positive about LTE besides the 35mpbs down is that it does not drain the battery at all like I thought. My 4g experience with sprint was so bad that I rarely enabled it even when the coverage came because my battery would drain to nothing in no time. The LTE with verizon is absolutely incredible. when I had that game streaming in the middle of Nowhere, FL with no buffering and in a gorgeously crisp resolution, I knew I had made the right choice.

AT&T or Verizon, you cant really go wrong. I just need strong cell reception where I live so Verizon was the easy choice.

I5 battery is still the best I have used. I frequently go for 2-3 days without charging. The days I have drained it to zero involved a lot of GPS nav, heavy web browsing, video editing, picture taking phone calls. Best battery I have experienced by a long shot.
 
Last edited:

DRII

G.O.A.T.
Do you think that unlimited 3G data for existing month-to-month customers is going away soon? That would suck. The last time I spoke with a VZ customer service representative, he mentioned that I could have my unlimited 3G data as long as I didn't purchase my devices from VZ.

I know that eventually, they will take unlimited 3G data away from us. I just hope that it is not too soon. Maybe, they can offer unlimited coverage as a lollipop to those who stay with 3G rather than upgrading to blazing fast LTE? :)

Yea, I'm not sure...

but if they want to keep me they better grandfather me into unlimited data :twisted:
 

movdqa

Talk Tennis Guru
I don't have LTE in my area but AT&T's 3G in my area runs at DSL (3.5 MB) speeds (they might call it 4G without the LTE) whereas Verizon 3G in my area is miserable.

In Boston, though, speeds are excellent with both Verizon and AT&T. I do not do a lot of bandwidth-heavy things in general on my phone and would probably be fine with AT&T 3G. I decided to generally stick with Verizon and AT&T because of their generally superior coverage. Their prices are crazy but you pay for coverage.
 
AT&T scored the best regarding 4g among the major carriers. Although Verizon scored highest overall. Verizon's signal is relatively inconsistent, speeds vary more than with AT&T. Verizon does have higher top end speed but doesn't stay there (Venus vs Serena analogy to tennis)...

http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/2012/11/29/att-mixed-results-consumer-reports-survey/1733287/

I may switch to AT&T, just to see how it is with them; especially if Verizon tries to downgrade my unlimitied data for loyal customers. i think AT&T has the best phones and gets them sooner as well...

The issue with ATT is that their true LTE is in less than 100 markets, while Verizon is pushing 400 markets.

The plus side to ATT is the fact that their HSPA+ coverage is very good, which can get people 4-10Mbps download speeds, while Verizon's 3G is 2-4Mbps at best.

I like Verizon so far, after a couple months. ATT always gets poor marks for their cellular reception, but it does seem to be getting better. I agree about them having the best phones.
 

DRII

G.O.A.T.
So how long will the Note 2 be top dog?
I really really enjoy mine, I think there is nothing out there close to it.

The HTC DNA might have something on it. Its the only true 1080p display. But, I'm pretty sure HTC has nothing on Samsungs software and stylus...

I got to say that HTC spoils you with their displays. My Rezound display is truly great and still one of the best, if not the best, one out there even though its an 'old' phone (still has the greatest pixel density). Many times with old tennis matches on youtube, i get a better picture on my Rezound than on a HD computer monitor! Helps me reminisce when Venus was a force to be reckoned with and played the most athletically dominating tennis I’ve ever seen from a woman (her 2000 USO semi against Hingis and 2001 against Capriati was an amazing display of athleticism and power)!!!
 
So how long will the Note 2 be top dog?
I really really enjoy mine, I think there is nothing out there close to it.

For anyone looking for a phone with a really large screen, you can't beat the note. It's got computing power that rivals some laptops and tablets, and their stylus software is pretty cool.

It will rule that world, likely until the note III comes out next year.
 

acura9927

Semi-Pro
Not sure I'll ever go back to HTC after that Thunderbolt mess. It was worthless way too often trying to get a signal.
With the Note 2 I no longer need to bring my IPAD when I travel.
 
I cant go back to Verizon, I ported the number already to Sprint and they probably wont offer me back that unlimited data for 30 per month since they dont offer unlimited net anymore.

How long has it been. I know with AT&T if you leave with your number you have 60days to come back and reactivate your account.
 
The HTC DNA might have something on it. Its the only true 1080p display. But, I'm pretty sure HTC has nothing on Samsungs software and stylus...

I got to say that HTC spoils you with their displays. My Rezound display is truly great and still one of the best, if not the best, one out there even though its an 'old' phone (still has the greatest pixel density). Many times with old tennis matches on youtube, i get a better picture on my Rezound than on a HD computer monitor! Helps me reminisce when Venus was a force to be reckoned with and played the most athletically dominating tennis I’ve ever seen from a woman (her 2000 USO semi against Hingis and 2001 against Capriati was an amazing display of athleticism and power)!!!

HTC dropped the ball with the DNA not having an option for expandable memory. 16GB stinks especially on an Android where bloatware already consumes too much precious storage room. went with the HTC One X+ today and even though it doesn't have a chance for expandable memory it comes in a 64GB size.
 

akind

Banned
iPhone's map putting lives at risk

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/nation/map-fail-putting-lives-at-risk/story-e6frg6nf-1226533703649

VICTORIA Police has warned that a glitch in Apple's new iPhone mapping system has left a string of motorists stranded for up to 24 hours.

Over the past month, officers in the far northwestern Victorian town of Mildura have had to rescue five motorists who followed directions from their iPhones operating on the new iOS6 system but were led more than 70km off-course.

Motorists had intended to drive to Mildura but ended up lost in isolated and dangerous terrain inside Murray-Sunset National Park.

Some of the motorists who were left stranded waited up to 24 hours without food or water and had to walk long distances to get phone reception, police said.

Victoria Police issued a warning about the potentially life-threatening situation.

"Police are extremely concerned as there is no water supply within the park and temperatures can reach as high as 46 degrees," a police statement said.
Digital Pass $1 for first 28 Days

The Mildura mapping flaw is one of many complaints users have levelled against Apple since the company's software update and new mapping application made its debut earlier this year.

In September, Apple CEO Tim Cook apologised for the string of problems with its maps application and recommended users rely on other map applications instead.

Victoria Police has notified Apple of the problem.

Anyone travelling to Mildura or other locations within Victoria is being urged by police to rely on other forms of mapping until this error is fixed.
 

acura9927

Semi-Pro
Sprint sucks, just got my first bill and they have double the fees Verzion has, Verizon has state and gov fees while Sprint has their own fees that cost just as much as those fees. I regret leaving Verzion now.

I'm not holding my breath 4 G LTE is ever coming to Seattle.
 

quest01

Hall of Fame
I downloaded the jellybean update last week to my gs3 for at&t. It makes it smoother overall and adds a few features like google now voice assistant, better picture quality in low light, and the ability to use personal photos as a background while texting among other things.
 

movdqa

Talk Tennis Guru
I wish that they didn't change the login screen for JB over ICS. I got rid of mine but will only do that when it's at home.
 

Power Player

Bionic Poster
The people who bought my prior phone - the EVO lte are being left in the dust. HTC now released a plus version of the same phone and will put JB on that. LTE owners are left hoping to get jellybean still. Thats just a shame. 6 months later, and HTC released a "oops, sorry this one is better" version of their flagship phone instead of taking care of the people who bought the first version. so glad I got rid of mine in time.
 

movdqa

Talk Tennis Guru
That's why I bought a smartphone and tablet directly from Google. Google is doing a pretty good job at pushing updates for their own products. It's really the carriers that are responsible for updating the OS - not the manufacturers. Except for the Google-branded stuff.
 

Power Player

Bionic Poster
I agree. The google phone is the best option, but they are not as feature rich. That is the problem - you buy a flagship droid phone and are stuck with it for 2 years, but it can be a guessing game as to which one will get supported throughout that life.
 
Rumor mill in full force today for the next iPhone.

Jefferies is saying the iPhone 5S is coming in June of 2013:

Misek is predicting the iPhone 5S has a new "super HD camera/screen, a better battery, and NFC," and "possible updates include an IGZO screen for Retina+, 128GB storage." He's also predicting it comes in 6-8 colors, presumably similar to the iPod Touch which comes in a bunch of colors.

http://www.businessinsider.com/the-...8-colors-says-jefferies-2012-12#ixzz2EfYPnx5p

There's also a rumor of iPhone 6 prototypes, including a 4.8" model...Interesting.

Several iPhone 6 prototypes appear to be floating around. The model with a 4.8" screen is the most interesting. It has a Retina+ IGZO screen, a new A7 quad-core processor variant, and a new form factor with no home button. Full gesture control is also possibly included.

http://www.businessinsider.com/ipho...ototyped-says-jefferies-2012-12#ixzz2EfYxkhef
 
Top