scotus' Extreme Low Tension Playtest of Ashaway Monogut ZX Pro red
String, gauge, & color received
Monogut ZX Pro 17 gauge Red
Tension used for playtest
35 lbs on Stringway contant-pull foot-pedal machine.
Yep, that's 35 lbs. Since everyone else has been testing it at high tensions but I have been playtesting various polys at extreme low tensions since the winter, I figured reviewing the string at an extreme low tension might make a valuable contribution to this forum.
Regular string set up
For the longest time I used gut/poly hybrids at very high tension but as previously mentioned, I have been playing poly hybrids at 30 lbs for the last 5-6 months.
Racquet brand and model used for test
Wilson BLX Five tail-weighted to 12 oz. The beam width may be too thick for most people, but comfort is second to none. Anyone with a sensitive elbow or TE problems should give this frame a try.
Stringing
The ZX Pro was very easy to string up. It had low to moderate coil memory and felt like a soft co-poly. The string tips were rigid rather than mushy and could be cut very sharp, which is always helpful when pushing the string through blocked holes. The string was round, so very easy on the fingers, and unlike some polys, finger-weaving the crosses was a breeze. But like co-poly strings, it is difficult to cinch a tight knot.
One thing that struck me as odd was that the string was not stretching much, even though I let the constant pull do its work for about 15 seconds on each pull. Not once did I have to double-pull (which I often have to do for some multis and gut). Nor did I notice the constant-pull tensioner gradually move further away to compensate for the elongation. My suspicion is that the 35 lbs is simply not strong enough to pull this string much, or that ZX Pro behaves like a stiff string at an extremely low tension. The resulting stringbed felt stiff to me, just like a co-poly setup.
The First Playtest
When I playtest a new string, I like to compare it to my more familiar setup side by side. So here I had my 2 matched racquets, one strung with ZX Pro at 35 lbs, and the other strung with Dunlop Black Widow 16g mains and Solinco Tour Bite 19g crosses at 30 lbs. I felt the 5 lbs difference would be fair given the supposed differential in stiffness.
What I immediately felt during the warm-up was that even at mere 35 lb of tension, ZX Pro felt stiff. Yes, stiff! I have a very sensitive elbow, so I can feel the slightest shock and vibration that players with healthy arms never notice. I kid you not. The Black Widow / Tour Bite at 30 lbs was far more arm-friedly than the ZX Pro at 35 lbs.
Let me also point out another turn-off before I get to more important matters. The ZX Pro produces a very dull yet annoying plasticky sound at impact that simply cannot be silenced! Usually my Gamma Shockbuster is quite capable of deadening awful sounds, but even its Zorbicon-gel smothering of 8 main strings was powerless to stop this irritating noise!
I found acceptable control and acceptable spin, but the gut-like feel was nowhere to be found. I have been using gut for over a decade so I should know what it feels like. And power was nothing to write home about.
Then I picked up the Black Widow / Tour Bite hybrid, and there you go. Awesome spin, crisp feel, precise control, power on demand, and no annoying sound!
Well, as you may have guessed, I played my 4 sets of doubles mostly with the poly hybrid that evening. Every time I grabbed the ZX Pro, I was losing points and wasn't feeling confident. With a quick change of racquets, I would be back in the game.
The Second Playtest
Three evenings later, I went out for a second test. Same sticks, same setup, the same strings that have been sitting in the bag for the last 3 days.
This time the ZX Pro felt even stiffer. I could either cut this out and write up a highly negative review or do something to get more out of this string.
Well, in hopes of reducing the stiffness, I put the racquet down on the court and stepped on the string bed for 2 seconds. That probably took off a few pounds of tension.
Finally, the string began to perform. I felt comfortable hitting with this setup from anywhere. The groundies were nice with heavy spin, the volleys were well controlled, and I hit a couple of kick serves that went over the returner's head (okay, maybe it was just over the shoulder...)
Now I was switching back and forth between ZX Pro and the Black Widow / Tour Bite setup seamlessly, feeling confident with both, and sometimes even favoring the ZX Pro setup, which still felt a bit tighter (the full poly setup must have lost more tension) and beefier (ZX Pro setup felt slightly heavier in weight).
One thing that did not change is the annoying sound. Maybe the pitch was a bit lower but still the same dull plasticky noise that is 10X worse than that of MSV Hex.
Also, it is still no gut. Not even close.
I shall now fill out the rest of the review criteria based on the improved, reduced-tension setup.
Power of test string
I don't think I necessarily want a lot of power from my string, especially if it undercuts control. In comparison to my full-poly setup, I would say the ZX Pro has about the same power level.
What I really like about natural gut (when coupled with co-poly) is that if I just want to have a topspin rally, it allows me to do that with ease, but if I want to hit a flat winner, it gives me that EXPLOSIVE power. I don't know how to describe it, perhaps more speed or accelaration without necessarily sailing the ball long? Whatever it is, I get that extra zip that adds to my racquet head speed.
Does ZX Pro have that EXPLOSIVE power? No.
Does it perhaps have that EXPLOSIVE power but to a lesser degree? I don't think so. I think what you put in is what you get out with ZX. No extra zip there.
I should also point out that I didn't have a whole lot of confidence in going for flat winners because a few that I tried ended up sailing very long without any added zip. It could just be that I need more time with this string, but as of today, that's all I can say about it.
Also, volleying with this string was very much like volleying with a co-poly. You can get precise directional control, but you need to generate your own power. It takes effort to hit those nice deep volleys. And those instances when you are totally stretched out and all you can do is get your racquet on the ball with little to no forward momentum, gut can often bail you out but this string won't.
Feel
I cannot describe its feel without being biased, because feel is by nature very closely associated with sound (much like how smell and taste go hand-in-hand), and you know by now how I feel about the noise this string makes.
I would describe it as firm, not stiff (at the reduced tension, that is). Defintitely not mushy but not crisp either. But there's some solid beefiness to the feel that I kind of like.
Spin
Spin is very good to excellent. If I were to give my Black Widow and Tour Bite hybrid 9/10 in spin, I would give ZX Pro about 7.5 to 8 out of 10. For those who do want spin but do not want poly, the ZX Pro is a good candidate. Beats most of the multis and synthetic gut.
Comfort
Very good to excellent. But bear in mind that even during my second outing I still felt that the soft co-poly hybrid of Black Widow 16 g and Tour Bite 19 g trumps ZX Pro in the comfort department.
Durability
I apologize to TW for having only had 2 playtests. Due to a major injury, I was only able to start playing this week.
But the string so far looks like a champ that would endure weeks of playing.
Control (predictable trajectory? performance on different strokes and swing speeds?)
The launch angle was absolutely normal. It responded best to spin-guided strokes, especially when going for the kill. I wasn't very successful with flat winners with ZX Pro.
Compare to the string you use most often
Thus far, I don't see a reason to switch from the polys that I have been using at extreme low tensions, which include Black Widow, Tour Bite Soft, Tour Bite 19, and Volkl V-Torque. All of these are extremely soft co-polys with very high spin potentials.
ZX Pro doesn't seem to offer any improvement in comfort, spin, or explosive power that makes it a better candidate than any of the above co-polys, although being a string junkie that I am, I might start mixing up ZX Pro with the above-mentioned polys.
Tension recommendations (after hitting it, would you recommend a different tension? Why?)
Well, everyone is different. But if you are into extreme low tensions, this is a review you might consider. As for me, I strung this at 35 lbs. If I were to do it again, I would probably just go for 30 lbs.
List any final thoughts.
This string was a surprise in that it didn't behave like how I imagined Zyex would behave. At least in the context of extreme-low-tension stringing, it was every bit polyesque in its attributes with the important exception of tension maintenance. Come to think of it, using this string as a hybrid with a co-poly might allow the setup to last longer simply because ZX Pro is at least gut-like in its ability to maintain tension.
Many thanks to TW for making me part of the playtest group, and thanks to fellow posters for putting up with this long, hastily written review.