I have to face facts: Murray has not beaten either Djokovic or Federer for 2 years now! They are the current world # 1 and # 2 players.
The back surgery has proved to be the great divide in Murray's career. Prior to that, he had won his last matches against Federer (2013 AO) and Djokovic (2013 W0). Since the surgery (Sept 2013) he has gone 0-8 v Djokovic and 0-4 v Federer.
Where does he go from here? Has he just declined or have they got better? Will he ever get back to his pre-surgery level and start winning some matches against them again or has he simply become their gatekeeper?
Thoughts? (No troll haters please)
I think he should have a different coach for a start. Check my comments re Mauresmo in the past (so I am not jumping on the bandwagon because of the today's loss) but why total head-case in her own career who lost numerous matches she should have won is the right coach for Andy?
Come on loosing 6:0, 6:1 at WTF last year was the pits. Why was she still a coach after that?
Completely unknown coaches (ok Brad was known) achieved more or the same than Mauresmo before Lendl arrived.
Which raises obvious question: what did Lendl do which others could not? I think it was a mental toughness which came with Lendl overcoming losses in many finals before becoming a multiple winner.
Lets look at today's match. If you believe people like Roddick and Henman and usual BBC crowd Andy was playing well but was outplayed by Roger playing best ever etc.
Ok, Roger was serving well and Andy usual 2nd serve problem came to the fore in critical moments, but where was the game plan?
Andy looked like playing his old passive game playing slow, looping shots with no depth straight into Federer's hitting zone especially on the forehand.
BBC commentators all swoon over Roger's great play, but how often this was the result of Andy putting his shots not even pass the service line?
Against the Roger it is suicidal tactic. For whatever reason Andy looked very sluggish around the baseline, not getting into position to execute even basic (for his level) shots.
What happened to Andy cross court backhand? It has no penetration nowadays, i.e. it has neither angle nor pace to elicit weak reply.
It my well be that Andy just can not improve any more for whatever reason. Novak serve was a total joke 5-6 years ago, but look at it now. For whatever reason Andy like Gasquet, Sharapova and Venus Williams can not fix it.
I am as disappointed as you are. I thought that this year Wimby title will be decided between Novak and Andy with Roger (my favourite player) being too old to win GS anymore.