Fed fans would you want him to make the F ?

Sunny014

Legend
Roddick of 2004 is about same level as Raonic 2016. Top 10 servebot guy who is displaced soon as better more athletic and talented players such as Thiem, Zverev, Tsitsipas fully matured.

Have to disagree on the final point. For example, the 2019 Wimbledon semi final between Fedal was much higher quality than the 2006-2008 trilogy there.

Roddick 2004 would beat Djokovic 2018-2021 on Grass

Only Djokovic 2014-2015 can win vs Peak Roddick.

Jokers like raonic are never even in the conversation, Roddick forehand of 04 itself was enough to bury everyone playing now.
 

Sunny014

Legend
Peak Federer (03-07) > Peak Djokovic (14-15) > Peak Nadal (07-10) > Peak Roddick (04 and 09) > Peak Murray (2013)> Djokovic (2018-21) > Old-Fed-error Grandpa (19-21) > Peak Raonic

This is the hierarchy on Grass @NoleIsBoat

Sorry to break it to you, Wimbledon final 2019 was low quality Tennis.
 

NoleIsBoat

Hall of Fame
Peak Federer (03-07) > Peak Djokovic (14-15) > Peak Nadal (07-10) > Peak Roddick (04 and 09) > Peak Murray (2013)> Djokovic (2018-21) > Old-Fed-error Grandpa (19-21) > Peak Raonic

This is the hierarchy on Grass @NoleIsBoat

Sorry to break it to you, Wimbledon final 2019 was low quality Tennis.
tenor.gif
 

Terry Tibbs

Hall of Fame
It's an interesting question. On the one hand, just reaching the final would set another record and an amazing achievement but on current performances Djokovic could embarrass him which nobody would like to see as well as the not so small fact of winning all 4 finals against him.
 
I’ve watched both and yes would of beat that Djokovic in his prime I agree but that was a 32 year old Djokovic so he is hardly in his prime too. Also you would expect Fed to be beating out of prime Djokovic in W if he was in his prime.

Djokovic at his slam has been schooling Fed since it was Peak Fed against a young Djokovic.

I always see these things brought up, not just by Fed fans by every fan base and it makes no sense. Fed in his prime would obviously beat a 32 year old Djokovic at W
Djokovic in his prime would beat any Fed at AO
Nadal in his prime would beat both at RG regardless. No point in arguing it.
I think u did not see how fed used to play, oldie Roger dragged peak novak into 5 sets at wimbledon
 
Top