You can't ever guarantee Nadal will win multiple majors in a season for 3 years straight anyway. He has way too many peaks and valleys in his level of play to sustain that level for any long amount of time.
That's why you see Nole and Fed winning 3 majors a season more than once. They know how to stay consistent with their level, Nadal just peaks for a few tournaments and his level sinks deeper than the Mariana Trench when he's satisfied.
You can stick to ur opinion Sab.
Fedal h2h is much more about mental. Game wise fed has a huge matchup issue, which shows on all surfaces barring indoor. The mental block issue is not a problem for fed indoors then?
The reality is Nadal has been stopped by Nole 7 times in finals. The h2h record Fedal has shows Nadal woukd have won the majority of those encounters if he had faced fed. Its a peak fed vs peak Nadal conversation.
As to 2012 no.1, it doesn't even matter, since you have already admitted Nadal would have won 2 slams, so who's the real no.1?
As to his injuries, Nole is probably the biggest contributor to that, having so many long matches with Nadal. The reality was Nadal didnt get injured until mid 2012. Take Nole out of the picture everything else being equal, Nadal would have had 4 consecutivr multislam year.