Irvin has a good idea above. If you want more control from gut, simply increase tension 4-5 lbs.
Most good multi's will feel similar to gut but not quite as good. And, I don't think you will get as much spin but it will be close. TF NRG2, TF X1 BiPhase, Bab Excel, Wilson NXT are all good multi's and worth a try. My favorite is NRG2 but the others are very good.
Arjunt1216 idea about a gut main/poly cross hybrid is also very good but it will not have the same level of comfort as all gut. But, the poly cross will tone down the liveliness/power of the gut and the poly will give more control and spin than all gut.