Was that really out?

[AM95]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r0SYPntUcws

The point is at 1:37...djokovic misses his forehand but that looked well in...

what do you think?

 

[Changmaster]

C'mon, if it was "well in", do you really think both players, the umpire, the linesman, the crowd, and the commentators would make such an obvious mistake? Both Nadal and Djokovic didn't even take a second glance at the ball.

In any case, it looked out.

 

[Serendipitous]

It was out......

 

[AM95]

C'mon, if it was "well in", do you really think both players, the umpire, the linesman, the crowd, and the commentators would make such an obvious mistake? Both Nadal and Djokovic didn't even take a second glance at the ball.

In any case, it looked out.

its just my opinion..im not saying that im right..

in any case i said that it looked well in

 

[tacou]

I can't really tell but Changmaster is right, there's not even a murmur from the crowd so in person it must have been clearly out.

 

[aliciasace]

yeh must have been out.

 

[maddogz32]

looked out to me

 

[Justin Side]

Looked out. Djoker or Nadal didn't even give it a 2nd glance. In past matches, they've called a lot of misses by each other.

 

[P_Agony]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r0SYPntUcws

The point is at 1:37...djokovic misses his forehand but that looked well in...

what do you think?

Looks out to me.

 

[Mdubb23]

Agreed. Definitely looked out to me.

 

[Deleted member 25923]

How can it definately look out to anyone? It's pretty difficult to tell on that youtube video.

 

[HunterST]

How can it definately look out to anyone? It's pretty difficult to tell on that youtube video.

No it's pretty obviously out.

 

[tacou]

How can it definately look out to anyone? It's pretty difficult to tell on that youtube video.

super cool people may disagree, but there's no way you can tell in that video. it is indeed a very close call. I'm only going on reactions of umpires/players/crowd. but anyone who thinks that ball is CLEARLY out, kudos, you've got super powers!

 

[THESEXPISTOL]

Instead of look at the line when the ball lands look to the ball.. You will have your answer.

 

[featherlight]

out
10 char