What was your worst (vintage) racket?

I'll start with the Head Competition Edge (Arthur Ashe signature). I wanted to like it but it cracked too easily.I remember exchanging it a couple of times and each time it cracked. I recently spoke to fellow league player who used it back in the day and he had the same experience.
 
Last edited:

kevin qmto

Hall of Fame
Hate to pick on poor Arthur Ashe. But the original Ashe Comp 1 is my pick. Ultra heavy, ultra floppy, and ultra demanding that you find the tiny sweet spot otherwise your arm will take a beating in no time. The Comp 3 was much better IMO. Lighter, stiffer, and more forgiving once I put in a multi strung at 45lbs.
 

graycrait

Legend
Davis Imperial. Use my last red cent to buy that beauty and not long after it cracked in the hoop at 3 o'clock. See dark spot in photo. I used some kind of glue and wrapped the crack with glue laden braiding fishing line for the "repair." Moved on to JK Autograph after that. Back in those days earning 1.35/hr as a dish washer didn't allow for a lot of extravagance.

H98OrkC.jpg
 
Last edited:

USMC-615

Hall of Fame
Had a helluva time playing with the ol’ Wilson T3000…but played fine with a couple of Wilson T2000’s. I guess the 3000 gets my vote.
 

dkmura

Professional
In the late 70's , I played with an open throated wood graphite racquet advertised in World Tennis Magazine. It was during the period when racquets like the Head Vilas were popular. Unfortunately, this racquet warped if you looked hard at it. I returned five frames in the space of a six weeks before giving up.
 

Sanglier

Professional
In the late 70's , I played with an open throated wood graphite racquet advertised in World Tennis Magazine. It was during the period when racquets like the Head Vilas were popular. Unfortunately, this racquet warped if you looked hard at it. I returned five frames in the space of a six weeks before giving up.

Are you referring to the Grafighter? I believe it was the only graphite reinforced wood racquet that had its own mail order ad in WT within that time frame. They were developed in San Diego and were one of the most gorgeous frames ever produced, in my opinion.

Despite making small improvements along the way, they only lasted a couple of years before disappearing. It sounds like you were partially responsible for putting them out of business! :)

7SzAjLu.jpg
 

retrowagen

Hall of Fame
Volkl Worldcup MS24… an exotic frame with a perfect head size, and beautifully made, but ruined by its clunky nylon throat bridge, which made it look like a downmarket aluminum racquet. It was heavy, slow through the air, had no ball feel, and there was no evident stringing solution to improve on its lackluster performance. I was given some of these, and even hit with Volkl’s top WTA player, as a junior and was offered a sponsorship, but I disliked the racquet so much, I politely declined.

Kneissl White Star Twin… It was Kneissl’s answer to the popular Rossignol F200 Carbon, with approximately the same +20% head size, two-handed grip, and super flexy mostly fiberglass composition, but it played as though it had a hinge in the middle.

Leach… I’m pretty sure this one DID have a hinge in the middle! One of my first coaches played this frame, which looked like the ubiquitous plastic Leach racquetball racquet on the end of a stick. It was nothing like a “game improvement” racquet; switching from the Head Graphite Vector I was playing at the time to the Leach, I suddenly couldn’t hit the ball over the net, let alone direct it in any general direction.

Donnay Wimbledon Mid… I picked this beautiful black number off a rack of a Northern California Big 5 sporting goods store, after mowing lawns for weeks in 1983. It looked like something Borg would swing, and had a cool-sounding name, but was evidently Donnay’s foray into the (non-) lucrative sector of balsa-graphite composites… bad flexy, no control, a power sponge, and quickly warped within a few weeks of me trying really hard to hit balls with it. When its smooth leather grip slipped out of my hand on an overhead smash, and it rocketed down, bouncing off the hardcourt and popping up in a splintered mess, I was mortified but simultaneously relieved.
 

dkmura

Professional
Are you referring to the Grafighter? I believe it was the only graphite reinforced wood racquet that had its own mail order ad in WT within that time frame. They were developed in San Diego and were one of the most gorgeous frames ever produced, in my opinion.

Despite making small improvements along the way, they only lasted a couple of years before disappearing. It sounds like you were partially responsible for putting them out of business! :)

7SzAjLu.jpg
OMG- you nailed it. The Grafighter truly was a beautiful frame and had a nice feel to it. But they were never able to solve their warpage problems. I won't take any responsibility for their demise, as I gave them plenty of chances to make good!
 

kevin qmto

Hall of Fame
It seems a lot of us were fooled by beautiful racket aesthetics into trying a frame only to be disappointed.
 
They all give me tennis elbow, but the worst one was the Metal Head one. Don't truly know the name but it was long (like a wooden racket shape) and had a red "head" logo at the neck. I remember vibrating every time I hit the ball with that thing. Might as well have been a self defense prop or an industrial tool of some kind.
 
They all give me tennis elbow, but the worst one was the Metal Head one. Don't truly know the name but it was long (like a wooden racket shape) and had a red "head" logo at the neck. I remember vibrating every time I hit the ball with that thing. Might as well have been a self defense prop or an industrial tool of some kind.
Sounds like the Head Professional. I actually kind of liked it at the time.
 

Ronaldo

Bionic Poster
They all give me tennis elbow, but the worst one was the Metal Head one. Don't truly know the name but it was long (like a wooden racket shape) and had a red "head" logo at the neck. I remember vibrating every time I hit the ball with that thing. Might as well have been a self defense prop or an industrial tool of some kind.
RedHead? Pro? Hit the best volley of my life with one. No vibration, just an extension of my hand.
 

coachrick

Hall of Fame
Were any of the Rossi F... good, or was the concept of making the mains uniformly short a total mistake?
I don't think the equal-length mains concept was horrible, just not the big deal they wanted it to be. I played as much with the wood Strato as I did
with their composites...but for only one year.
 

Ronaldo

Bionic Poster
So so many
Vacuumpro 90 stich frame truly anemic for me
Volkl tr 25 killed me that I played my worst tennis with this
Max 200 g ..I know I know
Rossi 200g only cuz it weighed 15 oz
Prince graphite 110
Decided I was not worthy of the Fischer Vacuum Pro 90. Prob strung it too taut. Major racquets were a major pain
 

Henry Hub

Professional
This, 100% this. The fruits of Donnay’s forays into turbo-cardboard racket construction. Think Vijay Amritraj may have used it to fend off the baddies in Octopussy, which given its composition must be the most unbelievable moment in the whole film (take a seat, crocodile submarine).

Donnay Wimbledon Mid… I picked this beautiful black number off a rack of a Northern California Big 5 sporting goods store, after mowing lawns for weeks in 1983. It looked like something Borg would swing, and had a cool-sounding name, but was evidently Donnay’s foray into the (non-) lucrative sector of balsa-graphite composites… bad flexy, no control, a power sponge, and quickly warped within a few weeks of me trying really hard to hit balls with it. When its smooth leather grip slipped out of my hand on an overhead smash, and it rocketed down, bouncing off the hardcourt and popping up in a splintered mess, I was mortified but simultaneously relieved.
 
It seems a lot of us were fooled by beautiful racket aesthetics into trying a frame only to be disappointed.
I certainly was fooled by the Snauwaert Brian Gottfried Autograph. I was seduced by the beautiful guitarlike woodwork, Fairway grip and snazzy suede head cover. It had no plow through and felt unstable in my 15 year old hand. Went from that straight to the aluminum Prince Pro followed by the POG and my game was transformed.
 

Bambooman

Hall of Fame
I certainly was fooled by the Snauwaert Brian Gottfried Autograph. I was seduced by the beautiful guitarlike woodwork, Fairway grip and snazzy suede head cover. It had no plow through and felt unstable in my 15 year old hand. Went from that straight to the aluminum Prince Pro followed by the POG and my game was transformed.
Those wood racquet works of art were such a shame. I saw a badly warped racquet in a thrift shop that had unbelievable detailing in the workmanship.
 
I'll mention another one here- I know I have seen people mention that of the Head Edges the Composite Edge plays the best. I guess I'm in the minority- I cannot hit with it to save my life. To me it seems like too flexy with no plough lacking stability. I do have a SL version and a couple of regular versions of it and I just can't make it work at all.
 

coachrick

Hall of Fame
I was gifted the Oh-so-sleek Pro Am cast aluminum racket a few years back. Can't hit it worth a darn. Flexy, twisty, just plain odd...but it looks cool!!!
 

LOBALOT

Hall of Fame
Not sure if it qualifies as Vintage but I bought two Prince Triple Threat graphites when they first came out...terrible rackets.

My neighboor behind me still plays with those and I string them for him. Yikes! That is quite the contraption.
 

retrowagen

Hall of Fame
This, 100% this. The fruits of Donnay’s forays into turbo-cardboard racket construction. Think Vijay Amritraj may have used it to fend off the baddies in Octopussy, which given its composition must be the most unbelievable moment in the whole film (take a seat, crocodile submarine).
Indeed… with a stiffer Donnay featuring more swingweight, his backhand drives would have stung more. It also appears that strings don’t last long in this model, which appears to be the Mid 25 or perhaps the Mid 25S. You decide:
 

JW10S

Hall of Fame
I'm not sure where people draw the line on 'Vintage' but for me the worst racquet I ever hit with was a Wilson Hammer 'Spin' version about 20 or more years ago. Ironically after having success with the wide body Profile racquets Wilson came out with super thin beamed (IIRC 14 mm) "Spin' racquets. The idea was that if you hit with a lot of spin, either topspin or slice, having a really thin beamed racquet meant you were less likely to mishit or catch the frame when executing spin shots. Because it was a Hammer it was balanced head heavy but that just couldn.t make up for the lack of power or feel those racquets had. Unsurprisingly, they were only on the market for a short time.
 
Last edited:

galain

Hall of Fame
I'm not sure where people draw the line on 'Vintage' but for me the worst racquet I ever hit with was a Wilson Hammer 'Spin' version about 20 or more years ago. Ironically after having success with the wide body Profile racquets Wilson came out with super thin beamed (IIRC 14 mm) "Spin' racquets. The idea was that if you hit with a lot of spin, either topspin or slice, having a really thin beamed racquet meant you were less likely to mishit or catch the frame when executing spin shots. Because it was a Hammer it was balanced head heavy but that just couldn.t make up for the lack of power or feel those racquets had. Unsurprisingly, they were only on the market for short time.

I remember them! Nice looking sticks I thought at the time but I never got to hit with one.
 

StringGuruMRT

Semi-Pro
This is probably considered blasphemy on these boards, but I despised the Prince Original Graphite OS and the Original Michael Change longbody... Just mushy and disgusting...
 

SeeItHitIt

Professional
I broke 3 Long handled Borg Pro’s (wood, Donnay), which made me broke as I was in college or shortly thereafter. They felt great though. I’d say the worst, just because of a a total board with no feel, no power and no nothin’ was a Head Arthur Ashe 2…the brown one. I jumped on the AA bandwagon too late and the ‘2’ was nothing like the original.
 

StringGuruMRT

Semi-Pro
Ever use the Prince Precision Graphite OS?
Not really. I was (and am) not a fan of OS racquets. My all time favorite is the Prince Graphite II MP, and when that got discontinued, I wandered in the wilderness for a couple years... I tried just about anything with a stabilizer bar in the throat, and reluctantly settled on the Precision 730, which was a Graphite II longbody. I finished up my college career with 5 of them, all of them cracked at 5 o'clock. At that point I started teaching, and became a Wilson guy, where I stayed for the next 10 years.
 

Ronaldo

Bionic Poster
Not really. I was (and am) not a fan of OS racquets. My all time favorite is the Prince Graphite II MP, and when that got discontinued, I wandered in the wilderness for a couple years... I tried just about anything with a stabilizer bar in the throat, and reluctantly settled on the Precision 730, which was a Graphite II longbody. I finished up my college career with 5 of them, all of them cracked at 5 o'clock. At that point I started teaching, and became a Wilson guy, where I stayed for the next 10 years.
Still own four Graphite II mp along w/NXG mid
 
Last edited:

Steve Huff

G.O.A.T.
By "worst", I wasn't judging them by the way they play. Everyone has a different taste in rackets. I was judging by how they held up. The Fischer Superforms warped easily. Also, the Head Arthur Ashe Comps warped if left in the heat. I had one once that I left in my dad's car and it's head warped to almost a 75-80 degree angle. So, if you're collecting them, make sure you look at them in person before buying.
 
Top