Why did Nadal not play FO 04?

Duzza

Legend
He played Wimbledon 03, US Open 03, Australian Open 04 and US Open 04, but not the French. He won it in 05 obviously, but I was just wondering if there was a reason he didn't. It looks like his ranking was high enough to get in.
 

Feña14

G.O.A.T.
He played Wimbledon 03, US Open 03, Australian Open 04 and US Open 04, but not the French. He won it in 05 obviously, but I was just wondering if there was a reason he didn't. It looks like his ranking was high enough to get in.

He broke his foot :]
 

ninman

Hall of Fame
If he's been injured at the FO before, he could be injured again, maybe the tennis gods will stop playing around with Federer and let him win it next year.
 

beedlejuice22

Semi-Pro
Well since Federer has been injured before in his lifetime too, he can also get injured again. maybe the tennis gods will stop making him believe that he can win it.
 

zagor

Bionic Poster
If he's been injured at the FO before, he could be injured again, maybe the tennis gods will stop playing around with Federer and let him win it next year.

That's just an awful thing to say for Nadal,you crossed the line here.It's not much worse than some Nadal fans making threads about how Fed should retire and is finished(a lot of wishful thinking there from them) but you shouldn't wish injury to come to anyone.
 

cucio

Legend
If he's been injured at the FO before, he could be injured again, maybe the tennis gods will stop playing around with Federer and let him win it next year.

Wow! Stop the presses! Ninman is acknowledging that Nadal is a tennis god! :lol:
 
That's just an awful thing to say for Nadal,you crossed the line here.It's not much worse than some Nadal fans making threads about how Fed should retire and is finished(a lot of wishful thinking there from them) but you shouldn't wish injury to come to anyone.

So zagor, what do you have to say to beetlejuice22's comment then?.

Surely if you are going to put one person in his place for making a silly comment. Then if someone else makes the same comment against someone else. Should't that comment be jumped on also?
 

zagor

Bionic Poster
So zagor, what do you have to say to beetlejuice22's comment then?.

Surely if you are going to put one person in his place for making a silly comment. Then if someone else makes the same comment against someone else. Should't that comment be jumped on also?

I didn't notice his comments,I answered him now.Wishing an injury to happen to any tennis player is very disturbing IMO.
 

cucio

Legend
Yeah, guys, go injure yourselves if you are so keen on injuries, and let us enjoy the clash of titans at the height of their powers.
 

Azzurri

Legend
So zagor, what do you have to say to beetlejuice22's comment then?.

Surely if you are going to put one person in his place for making a silly comment. Then if someone else makes the same comment against someone else. Should't that comment be jumped on also?

Heard about the earthquakie in Japan..hope you nior anyone within yoiur family/friends netwoirk were affected.
 
Heard about the earthquakie in Japan..hope you nior anyone within yoiur family/friends netwoirk were affected.

Thanks slap.. The quake was up north, so we didn't get anything here.. But if you live in this part of the world, then you gotta get used to them..

We had a big one here a few years back. But since then just the odd tremmor or two..
 

dh003i

Legend
I didn't notice his comments,I answered him now.Wishing an injury to happen to any tennis player is very disturbing IMO.

Yes, I agree with this; although it's fine to note that some players get injured more often than others, some styles are more prone to injury, etc. But evoking the "tennis gods" does seem to be wishing for injury to befall on someone.

It is unfortunate, but a reality -- and most likely to cotinue to be one if trends continue -- that Nadal has knee issues so often. I attribute it partly to playing style, but also partly to playing too much (where I think his team around him should be exerting more influence, telling him not to play all these minor tournaments).
 

anointedone

Banned
If he's been injured at the FO before, he could be injured again, maybe the tennis gods will stop playing around with Federer and let him win it next year.

You assume Federer would now win the French if Nadal is out of the way. That period may well have passed. Djokovic played stronger, more consistent, and much more solid clay court tennis at this years French then Federer did and almost certainly would have straight setted Federer had they played at this years French. Clay does not favor the old, and Federer will find clay the hardest surface to perform as he gets older. There will probably be others on clay in the future to surpass him other then Djokovic
 

flyer

Hall of Fame
Thanks slap.. The quake was up north, so we didn't get anything here.. But if you live in this part of the world, then you gotta get used to them..

We had a big one here a few years back. But since then just the odd tremmor or two..

chris, if you don't mind me asking, what takes you to japan?
 
M

Morrissey

Guest
Ankle problem. I think it was a stress fracture. He got it in Valencia vs Gasuqet. He basically had to quit the match.
 

Cup8489

G.O.A.T.
You assume Federer would now win the French if Nadal is out of the way. That period may well have passed. Djokovic played stronger, more consistent, and much more solid clay court tennis at this years French then Federer did and almost certainly would have straight setted Federer had they played at this years French. Clay does not favor the old, and Federer will find clay the hardest surface to perform as he gets older. There will probably be others on clay in the future to surpass him other then Djokovic

that's a little too bold to say. djokovic plays on clay like most players do now, which is just trying to outhit your opponent. i don't mean to belittle his game in any way, for obviously it is effective, but i believe that federer probably would rather face djokovic in the final than nadal, for djokovic is more easily dispatched by federer than nadal, mainly because nadal's style absolutely crunches federer's weaknesses, largely because of nadal's leftiness, and spininess. but djokovic has neither inherent advantage, which would even the field, allowing federer most likely a much easier time on clay against djokovic than against nadal. but we need a clay match between to two to prove, or disprove, my beliefs.
 

The-Champ

Legend
If he's been injured at the FO before, he could be injured again, maybe the tennis gods will stop playing around with Federer and let him win it next year.

Or Federer can die in two days and there will be no more wimbledon for the man.
 

The-Champ

Legend
As bad as what ninman said is,this is even worse,you're beyond pathetic IMO.


yeah..but mine is a joke! I don't want anything bad happening to Federer, because I want to see Nadal smash him in every surface from now on. I actually wish him in the best physical shape he can be.

I was waiting for a response from ninman, not from you. And please stop acting like freakin' mother Theresa, all over the place, (this is a tennis forum). You are more pathetic IMO.
 
Top