Why is Serena "fat"?

Status
Not open for further replies.

TMF

Talk Tennis Guru
Why do you continue to use this Martina Sanchez argument as though she was totally innocent. Do you think that it is o.k. to cheat? I wouldn't have handled it in the manner Serena did but at the same time.........I can't says I blame her.

Explain to me where Henin violate any rule from the rule book. If you can't, then she's not a cheater. You don't make the rule. Now be quiet!
 

babbette

Legend
couple reasons:

  1. This message board for the most part is american.
  2. serena is american
  3. serena is more popular than henin (in america)
  4. serena has had a better year than henin
  5. serena is a worse sportswoman than henin
  6. serena is fatter than henin

None of the top 4 ATP are Americans...does it stop the board being about them? Your reason=pants
 

plum556

Semi-Pro
LOL. You don't blame her for displaying thuggish on court tactics and trying to intimidate players? She should have been disqualified from matches dozens of times and yet she always got away with it because the officials were scared she would play the race card. She was responsible for ruining great tournament like Indian Wells with her diva attitude. Hope she "boycotts" more events in the future.



Yeah..........that's exactly what I said.Re-read if necessary. Can you remove the brick you have between your ears for one day out of the year? My point.......dippity...doo...dah, was that TMF continues to refer to this incident as though MS was just an innocent bystander. You can stand on the top of Mount Everest and yell for all to hear and it is not going to change my opinion as you are entitled to keep yours.


Most of your posts are generally irrational and distasteful and I don't know how you have continued this long without being banned,trollericious.


Now continue to do what you do best...........STOP,DROP AND TROLL
 

heftylefty

Hall of Fame
where are the endless huge threads on people's intense hate for Henin?:confused: None of the Henin threads are to this extent.

As plum556 said, there might be numerous reasons why she's vastly hated but it is intensified because she is black.

Outside the Federer/Nadal debates, some of the longest thread revolve around Serena or the Williams sisters and why they suck; they are not the best (regardless of the numbers they have put up); they have bad attitudes (yes because they are the only players in the history of the sport that ever to display 'tude).

But if you read a post that calls them "thugs" "animals" especially gorilla, you should never question that person motivation. Now, I feel this is free forum that should not be restricted. But if you going to say stupid racist crap, don't whine when someone calls you out.
 

drakulie

Talk Tennis Guru
None of the top 4 ATP are Americans...does it stop the board being about them? Your reason=pants

atp is much more poular than the WTA. I know me saying this makes me a racist against women, but oh well.

fact is, serena is one of the most popular tennis players in the world (man or woman).
 

Ronaldo

Bionic Poster
People use the race card b/c it's an easy way out to cover up the player(Serena) bad behavior. Quite convenient if he/she's black, but not for white, no matter how phony it is. Was Zina Garrison, maveli washington or Monfils got the same treatment as Serena? Or how about we swap Serena's character and all of her past actions with Venus. It would be VENUS getting all the heat today, not Serena.

Wow, Venus Envy
 

plum556

Semi-Pro
Explain to me where Henin violate any rule from the rule book. If you can't, then she's not a cheater. You don't make the rule. Now be quiet!


First of all I wasn't even referring to Henin,try reading....it is said to be fundamental. What? You just assumed I was talking about Henin because your blind fanatacism put you on automatic defense where Henin is concerned?


What rule are you talking about? Are you awake yet?


I'll be quiet when I get good and ready. You might fair better if you wake up,grow up and try to be a little more objective. This is my space for posting,I am not invading yours. I will continue to post in my space as long as I want. If you my posts are not to your liking,feel free to ignore.
 

TMF

Talk Tennis Guru
First of all I wasn't even referring to Henin,try reading....it is said to be fundamental. What? You just assumed I was talking about Henin because your blind fanatacism put you on automatic defense where Henin is concerned?


What rule are you talking about? Are you awake yet?


I'll be quiet when I get good and ready. You might fair better if you wake up,grow up and try to be a little more objective. This is my space for posting,I am not invading yours. I will continue to post in my space as long as I want. If you my posts are not to your liking,feel free to ignore.

Ok, you imply Sanchez cheated in 2009 FO.

Now prove to us where Sanchez cheated? You claim something that we expected you have fact behind it. Do your homework and if you can't come up with anything then be quiet!
 

plum556

Semi-Pro
Ok, you imply Sanchez cheated in 2009 FO.

Now prove to us where Sanchez cheated? You claim something that we expected you have fact behind it. Do your homework and if you can't come up with anything then be quiet!

Stop telling people to be quiet,that is disrespectful and uncalled for. I wish I could come through the net and grab you by your ear and wash your mouth out with soap.


Stop playing dumb........you now MS said a ball didn't hit her and it was shown on replay that it did. If this is not a good example of cheating then I don't know what is.


I think you are the one that needs to do your homework and while your at it be sure to bring the teacher an apple.
 
Dude, how many players you've met say they like the William Sisters? And/or their behavior? Only OJ and Barry Bonds gets a worse reaction. And Lebron lately

Actually Clijsters mentioned that Serena is one of the nicer girls in the locker room, and Kuznetsova and Wozniacki are also good friends w/ Serena.
“When you see (Serena) in the locker room, she is one of the funnest and coolest girls to hang out with. She’s so relaxed. You know in the locker room there’s some girls who don’t even look at you when you come in . . . But you have a few girls who really like to have a good time in there because you spend a lot of time at the courts, and Serena’s definitely one of them. She’s a girl who likes to have fun. She takes tennis very seriously but the other side of tennis is the personal life and she’s always up for a good joke and that’s what I like about her.

“That’s something I’ve always admired about Serena even when I was younger, so I’m glad I’ve got to know her better over the last few years”

http://www.gototennisblog.com/2010/...-rematch-back-at-bitter-defeat/#ixzz0trdhIUoF

Funny thing is Venus is looked at as less personable in the locker room from what I've heard over the years.
 

Arthuro

Semi-Pro
Being clinically overweight is a scientific measure of obesity which spans across cultural lines. In short, it doesn't matter what culture you come from, science has determined what being overweight and obese entails.

The topic of this thread is "why is Serena fat?" and you've somehow tried to morph the discussion into a question of her beauty from a cultural sense. Again, I think it is part denial and part ignorance that someone attempt to attach culture and science in the manner you've chosen.

Serena is clinically overweight, and her body mass index would support it, which has nothing to do whether or not she is a beautiful person, which is another topic for debate.

Henceforth and Always Right,

Mother Marjorie


This is false. Clinically overweight differs from ethnic group and even within groups based on athleticism, and activity. Even now BMI is being challenged as an indicator of disease or predictor of disease in people.

If your argument is true, then it would suggest that certain Asian groups of people are simply unfit, because they are smaller and have less "muscle mass" vs. "fat" than the west. This is clearly false.
 

Arthuro

Semi-Pro
Outside the Federer/Nadal debates, some of the longest thread revolve around Serena or the Williams sisters and why they suck; they are not the best (regardless of the numbers they have put up); they have bad attitudes (yes because they are the only players in the history of the sport that ever to display 'tude).

But if you read a post that calls them "thugs" "animals" especially gorilla, you should never question that person motivation. Now, I feel this is free forum that should not be restricted. But if you going to say stupid racist crap, don't whine when someone calls you out.

This is absolutely true. I was shocked or rather disgusted to say the least when I read how many threads compare Venus and Serena to animals, especially monkeys and ghetto thugs because they are from compton. I would think a tennis board would be more about tennis and not let racism like this be posted freely.
 

Ronaldo

Bionic Poster

Ronaldo

Bionic Poster
This is absolutely true. I was shocked or rather disgusted to say the least when I read how many threads compare Venus and Serena to animals, especially monkeys and ghetto thugs because they are from compton. I would think a tennis board would be more about tennis and not let racism like this be posted freely.

Rafa gets the tennis monkey treatment as well.
 
Stop telling people to be quiet,that is disrespectful and uncalled for. I wish I could come through the net and grab you by your ear and wash your mouth out with soap.


Stop playing dumb........you now MS said a ball didn't hit her and it was shown on replay that it did. If this is not a good example of cheating then I don't know what is.


I think you are the one that needs to do your homework and while your at it be sure to bring the teacher an apple.

For the record, here's the Martinez Sanchez incident.

http://ballhype.com/video/serena_wi...williams_acuses_martinez_sanchez_of_cheating/

Reverse the roles and people would be asking for Serena to be suspended and banned for lying and cheating like MJMS obviously did here.
 

TMF

Talk Tennis Guru
Stop telling people to be quiet,that is disrespectful and uncalled for. I wish I could come through the net and grab you by your ear and wash your mouth out with soap.


Stop playing dumb........you now MS said a ball didn't hit her and it was shown on replay that it did. If this is not a good example of cheating then I don't know what is.


I think you are the one that needs to do your homework and while your at it be sure to bring the teacher an apple.

Where did I say the ball didn’t hit Sanchez? Whether it hit her or not, it’s up the umpire making the call. If the umpire missed the call, it’s not Sanchez fault. Serena can only blame the umpire for missing it. And umpire are all human…they make mistakes and it happened all the time. Serena has no right to take action in her hand. You don’t watch other sports and I can understand why you are so clueless!! Every sports referees make bad call all the time, the players don’t have to say anything, it’s part of the game. You got the concept of “cheating” all wrong!
 

Tanya

Hall of Fame
Where did I say the ball didn’t hit Sanchez? Whether it hit her or not, it’s up the umpire making the call. If the umpire missed the call, it’s not Sanchez fault. Serena can only blame the umpire for missing it. And umpire are all human…they make mistakes and it happened all the time. Serena has no right to take action in her hand. You don’t watch other sports and I can understand why you are so clueless!! Every sports referees make bad call all the time, the players don’t have to say anything, it’s part of the game. You got the concept of “cheating” all wrong!

Congratulations, you have just increased your troll level. Really, defending Sanchez in an incident where she is clearly wrong? If it were anyone but Serena on the other side of the net you wouldn't have a thing to say about the subject. Perhaps it is the responsibility of the chair umpire to make the call, however if Sanchez had an iota of class she would have fessed up to cheating (yes, that's what it is when you break the rules - if the ball touches your skin you lose the point; the ball clearly hit her arm, therefore she should have lost the point, however she won the point and the game because she did not confess) and given Serena the point. For you to constantly be condemning Serena for her "classless" attitude it sure is fishy that you defend this blatant case of classlessness from Miss Sanchez.

Your act is getting so tired sweetie.
 

TMF

Talk Tennis Guru
Congratulations, you have just increased your troll level. Really, defending Sanchez in an incident where she is clearly wrong? If it were anyone but Serena on the other side of the net you wouldn't have a thing to say about the subject. Perhaps it is the responsibility of the chair umpire to make the call, however if Sanchez had an iota of class she would have fessed up to cheating (yes, that's what it is when you break the rules - if the ball touches your skin you lose the point; the ball clearly hit her arm, therefore she should have lost the point, however she won the point and the game because she did not confess) and given Serena the point. For you to constantly be condemning Serena for her "classless" attitude it sure is fishy that you defend this blatant case of classlessness from Miss Sanchez.

Your act is getting so tired sweetie.

People just don’t know what to classify a cheater. Every players from other sports such as futbol, basketball, and football(American) are all cheaters too??? Referees makes mistake but players don’t ask them to overturn despite knowing exactly the ref make a mistake. Why should Sanchez be an exception? Because she’s playing against Serena? haha!

And Serena wouldn't say anything either had she was in Sanchez shoes. She certainly not going to be intimidated by a light weight Sanchez.
 
People just don’t know what to classify a cheater. Every players from other sports such as futbol, basketball, and football(American) are all cheaters too??? Referees makes mistake but players don’t ask them to overturn despite knowing exactly the ref make a mistake. Why should Sanchez be an exception? Because she’s playing against Serena? haha!

And Serena wouldn't say anything either had she was in Sanchez shoes. She certainly not going to be intimidated by a light weight Sanchez.

More trolling, baseless conjecture, and nonsense from TMF, all to hide his true hatred of Serena. This really is becoming tiresome, fella.
 

Tanya

Hall of Fame
People just don’t know what to classify a cheater. Every players from other sports such as futbol, basketball, and football(American) are all cheaters too??? Referees makes mistake but players don’t ask them to overturn despite knowing exactly the ref make a mistake. Why should Sanchez be an exception? Because she’s playing against Serena? haha!

And Serena wouldn't say anything either had she was in Sanchez shoes. She certainly not going to be intimidated by a light weight Sanchez.

Oh, so because everyone else does it that makes it right. Fantastic logic. Truly you are a visionary.
 

TMF

Talk Tennis Guru
More trolling, baseless conjecture, and nonsense from TMF, all to hide his true hatred of Serena. This really is becoming tiresome, fella.

What makes your conjecture more credible than mine?:confused:
You have to proof that she's a cheater in the rule book.

Your right, it's nonsense to if anyone's happened to be different from JBF. Wow!
 
What makes your conjecture more credible than mine?:confused:
You have to proof that she's a cheater in the rule book.

Your right, it's nonsense to if anyone's happened to be different from JBF. Wow!

Just answer this question, TMF: If the ball hit Serena and she refused to give her opponent the point, would you be singing the same "Everyone does it" card, or would you be screaming from the mountaintops about how Serena is horrible and should be fined and suspended immediately? I have to think it's the latter.
 

Chadwixx

Banned
Congratulations, you have just increased your troll level. Really, defending Sanchez in an incident where she is clearly wrong? If it were anyone but Serena on the other side of the net you wouldn't have a thing to say about the subject. Perhaps it is the responsibility of the chair umpire to make the call, however if Sanchez had an iota of class she would have fessed up to cheating (yes, that's what it is when you break the rules - if the ball touches your skin you lose the point; the ball clearly hit her arm, therefore she should have lost the point, however she won the point and the game because she did not confess) and given Serena the point. For you to constantly be condemning Serena for her "classless" attitude it sure is fishy that you defend this blatant case of classlessness from Miss Sanchez.

LOL, you have never been on a tennis court have you?
 

Chadwixx

Banned
Just answer this question, TMF: If the ball hit Serena and she refused to give her opponent the point, would you be singing the same "Everyone does it" card, or would you be screaming from the mountaintops about how Serena is horrible and should be fined and suspended immediately? I have to think it's the latter.

Trying to make points with hypotheticals again jbf?
 

TMF

Talk Tennis Guru
Just answer this question, TMF: If the ball hit Serena and she refused to give her opponent the point, would you be singing the same "Everyone does it" card, or would you be screaming from the mountaintops about how Serena is horrible and should be fined and suspended immediately? I have to think it's the latter.

Why would I called Serena a cheater if the ball hit her. If I really want to blame on the player(getting hit by the ball) I would get on Gonzalez case during the match against Blake at the Olympic. But like I said, it’s part of the game. You don’t call cheat when it’s not in the rule book. Cheating would be like Rafa getting on court coaching, or surpassed the time limit between points. Those are in the rule book.
 

plum556

Semi-Pro
Where did I say the ball didn’t hit Sanchez? Whether it hit her or not, it’s up the umpire making the call. If the umpire missed the call, it’s not Sanchez fault. Serena can only blame the umpire for missing it. And umpire are all human…they make mistakes and it happened all the time. Serena has no right to take action in her hand. You don’t watch other sports and I can understand why you are so clueless!! Every sports referees make bad call all the time, the players don’t have to say anything, it’s part of the game. You got the concept of “cheating” all wrong!




There you go spewing your unsolicited garbage again. Not only do I watch many different sports,I also played three different sports at the Varsity level. I was a starter in all three. My daughter will be going off to college in about a month.....she has a full ride......compliments of her athletic skills and academic prowess. She also plays three different sports and could have gotten a scholarship for any of the three. My husband and I travelled all over the country for tournaments and were very involved in her development.
The bottom line is ............once again you put your foot in your mouth. You don't know me,so how do you fix your mouth to even utter such crap without having even the first clue.



Throwing in all your "red herring" will not change the facts. Try that crap on a 2nd grader. I believe all of us have at least taken Psych 101,so you need to go elsewhere to make that garbage you just posted wash. You and I both know I never said you made any mention about a ball hitting Sanchez and furthermore you know that was not the point being made.


I don't mind having a debate but now you are just playing games. I don't have time for that and definitely have no respect for it. At least be truthful to yourself. You are downright ridiculous. I see I can longer have any type of debate with you because when you are called on something, you make feeble attempts to twist and divert attention from the original subject.
 

Ripper014

Hall of Fame
Does this mean your brother would not have this problem if he were of a different nationality? My point is obesity.......whether due to child bearing,overeating,lack of exercise or otherwise can be found in all nationalities. I do agree that some cultures do have a propensity towards eating foods that are not that healthy........hence more of a weight problem. Americans are right there on the top of the list but that does not include all Americans nor does it mean all Blacks,Whites,Asian or otherwise.


We are just going in circles now so let me cut to the chase. Do you agree with the poster who stated "black women get way too fat after having children"?


Just Sayin

I have no idea... but would not make that assumption. Those that take my mother's side are all a little weight challenged... it could be the same for Serena's family... if you compare Serena to Venus and her father to her mother. What I am saying though is you do have some control over it... and Serena chooses to be the person you are. My brother is making his choice by his eating, exercise habits and he is what he is because of it.
 

drive

Semi-Pro
I don't know in america.. i've been there twice and i think people is bigger. In spain a girl like Serena is just fat, fat in terms of size, not in terms of being out of form. It's obvious that she's fit, she couldn't win slams otherwise.
 

Ripper014

Hall of Fame
atp is much more poular than the WTA. I know me saying this makes me a racist against women, but oh well.

fact is, serena is one of the most popular tennis players in the world (man or woman).

I would not go as far to say popular... perhaps infamous...
 

Chadwixx

Banned
I would say NO... and if you truly believe this then you have some personal issues about racism.

Imagine how silly this country (i say country because racism is a business in america) would be if white people played the race card everyone someone said something negative about them.
 

babbette

Legend
plum556 said:
We are just going in circles now so let me cut to the chase. Do you agree with the poster who stated "black women get way too fat after having children"?


Just Sayin

Another spot on generalization in this thread:shock:





 

Ripper014

Hall of Fame
Where did I say the ball didn’t hit Sanchez? Whether it hit her or not, it’s up the umpire making the call. If the umpire missed the call, it’s not Sanchez fault. Serena can only blame the umpire for missing it. And umpire are all human…they make mistakes and it happened all the time. Serena has no right to take action in her hand. You don’t watch other sports and I can understand why you are so clueless!! Every sports referees make bad call all the time, the players don’t have to say anything, it’s part of the game. You got the concept of “cheating” all wrong!

TMF I agree with you... if the umpire missed the call there is nothing that can be done. It then becomes a question about the integrity of the player... Ken Flach had the same type of incident hang over his head, or players... like Agassiz not admitting to an out ball... that he knew was clearly in. But like you... I believe that there are people in place to enforce the rules of the game. Now in saying that I also believe in the integrity of the game... and if you know that the ruling is incorrect I would hope you would own up to it, but I don't expect you to.

Now in saying all of this... Serena is even a worse offender if we are speaking of having any integrity... her USO incident shows the true nature of who she is. People are going to argue "how can you make that call?".... easy if you do not you are cheating Clisjters... Serena suggested that she didn't footfault... I would argue she was in no position witness whether she did or not... per my earlier statement... the have people in place to enforce the rules. And finally what amazed me was how easily and comfortable she felt at attempting to intimidating a lines person. And how casual she was about it at the press conference like it was no big deal.

Lets not forget this was not her first issue of court rage that day... the reason she got defaulted was because this was her second incident giving Clisjters a penalty point.

I guess what I am trying to say is play the game... let those that you have accepted to apply the rules do their job.
 

Chadwixx

Banned
If someone is trying to pop you, you arent gonna help them out. I dont think you will find any players disagreeing, well players who actually play competitively.

Serena just isnt very bright (kinda like blake vs gonzo) you dont aim high on the body because if your off sideways the ball is going deep.
 

Ripper014

Hall of Fame
If someone is trying to pop you, you arent gonna help them out. I dont think you will find any players disagreeing, well players who actually play competitively.

Serena just isnt very bright (kinda like blake vs gonzo) you dont aim high on the body because if your off sideways the ball is going deep.

I think it depends who you are... I have seen players give up points.

On the other hand I have seen a pro golfer ask spectators to pickup and move a large boulder claiming it was a movable object. This just added to my lack of respect for him...

You would hope a competitor would correct an error.. but like I said I don't expect it.
 

TMF

Talk Tennis Guru
There you go spewing your unsolicited garbage again. Not only do I watch many different sports,I also played three different sports at the Varsity level. I was a starter in all three. My daughter will be going off to college in about a month.....she has a full ride......compliments of her athletic skills and academic prowess. She also plays three different sports and could have gotten a scholarship for any of the three. My husband and I travelled all over the country for tournaments and were very involved in her development.
The bottom line is ............once again you put your foot in your mouth. You don't know me,so how do you fix your mouth to even utter such crap without having even the first clue.



Throwing in all your "red herring" will not change the facts. Try that crap on a 2nd grader. I believe all of us have at least taken Psych 101,so you need to go elsewhere to make that garbage you just posted wash. You and I both know I never said you made any mention about a ball hitting Sanchez and furthermore you know that was not the point being made.


I don't mind having a debate but now you are just playing games. I don't have time for that and definitely have no respect for it. At least be truthful to yourself. You are downright ridiculous. I see I can longer have any type of debate with you because when you are called on something, you make feeble attempts to twist and divert attention from the original subject.



Because when you come up with this nonsense, it doesn’t sound like you’re paying attention to other sports except tennis....

Stop playing dumb........you now MS said a ball didn't hit her and it was shown on replay that it did. If this is not a good example of cheating then I don't know what is.

Anyone watch other sports will know Sanchez incident is nothing to brag about. Bad calls will exist, and no matter what the players have to say or kept their mouth shut, the ref has the final answer. If not, why hire umpire/line judges to begin with. Just play the game and trust the players making all the call? :confused: My point is that you are wrong about judging a cheater when you have little knowledge. Now stick to the point I made and stop adding irrelevant materials. You are so emotional I don’t know how your husband can withstand it.

On a side note: Even the ref don't overrule his own call when he knew he made a mistake. Why? B/c of his ego and to save the embarrassing. Guess the ref is a cheater too.:shock:
 

Grass_for_cows

Semi-Pro
Now in saying all of this... Serena is even a worse offender if we are speaking of having any integrity... her USO incident shows the true nature of who she is.
True nature as in someone who will get angry about an absurd call at a very important moment. But people made it out like she killed and devoured the lineswoman on the court. What made the incident worse and more revealing was the blatant double standard Serena was held to because A) she is black B) she is woman. McEnroe on the other hand puts on a show of getting angry at the linespeople during exhibitions to please the crowd.

And finally what amazed me was how easily and comfortable she felt at attempting to intimidating a lines person. And how casual she was about it at the press conference like it was no big deal.
Because it wasn't a big deal. There are tennis players who have exploded on the court, destroyed racquets, and spewed profanity. Serena is not alone. People get angry and emotional outside of the tennis court, too. People in customer service probably deal with much worse on a daily basis.


Lets not forget this was not her first issue of court rage that day... the reason she got defaulted was because this was her second incident giving Clisjters a penalty point.

I guess what I am trying to say is play the game... let those that you have accepted to apply the rules do their job.

Let's not forget this was not the first time Serena has had to deal with bad calls, that she has dealt with adversity from officiating that at times reached levels of collusion or match fixing, and that the instant replay was instituted partly because of what happened to her before. She has played through all of this and dealt with it like a champion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top