edberg505 said:
Well not according to the rankings! No he is not much better.
If you compare both pros, noting that Goldstein has 1-2 years more on tour, I would def take The cash and wins and overall career for sure.
Note: Most of Mahut's cash has come from doubles
Nicolas Mahut and Goldstein are def play at the top of thier games right now, but the edge certainly goes to the scientist
Mahut
Singles Record:
17 - 37
Goldstein
Singles Record:
73 - 95
The facts
http://wwo.atptennis.com/3/en/players/headtohead/?player1=Goldstein,+Paul&player2=mahut
Mahut
CAREER HIGHLIGHTS
1999 - Earned first ATP point at France F5…Reached QF at France F8…Teamed with Julien Cassaigne to win title at France F8…2000 - Reached main draw at Roland Garros as wild card, losing to Hipfl in straight sets…Also received wild card into ATP circuit event in Toulouse, but lost to Tillstrom in three sets in 1st RD…Reached QF at Cherbourg Challenger…Improved year-end ranking 673 positions over previous year…Reached final in doubles at Cherbourg Challenger (w/Benneteau)…2001 - Made debut at Australian Open, losing to Medvedev in five sets…Won titles at Futures level in Luxembourg F1 and France F15…Defeated Godwin in Marseille for first ATP level victory, but lost to Kafelnikov in next round…Played at Roland Garros for second straight year, but dropped to Michael Russell in 1st RD…Made TMS debut in Paris, losing to Philippoussis is straight sets…2002 - Played qualifying at ATP level four times, but was unsuccessful in each effort…Won title at France F17 and reached final in France F21…Played only tour level event at Marseille, losing in 1st RD to Gicquel.
Goldstein
CAREER HIGHLIGHTS
1994-Received wild card into US Open draw and lost to Agenor in 1st RD...1995-Lost in 1st RD at Washington ATP event and Binghamton Challenger...1996-Reached first Challenger SF at Urbana...1997-Reached 2nd RD at San Antonio Challenger and first Challenger doubles final in Las Vegas (w/Thomas) ...1998-In August, won first Challenger title in Lexington (d. H. Lee)...Reached SF in Dallas and San Antonio followed by final in San Diego (l. to Liukko)...Won first Challenger doubles title in San Diego (w/Peterson) ...Also reached doubles final at Lexington Challenger (w/Thomas)...1999-Qualified at Australian Open and upset No. 8 Rusedski en route to Grand Slam-best 3rd RD (l. to Pavel in five sets)...Advanced to 3rd RD at Wimbledon...Became first American to win singles gold medal at Pan American Games in Winnipeg since Greg Homes in 1983 (d. Mamiit)...Advanced to first ATP QF in Washington (d. No. 8 Corretja)…2000--Won career-best 20 ATP matches...Won Challenger title at Waikoloa (d. Sa)...Reached first ATP SF in Delray Beach defeating Rafter in QF... Advanced to 3rd RD at Wimbledon (l. to Gambill)...Back-to-back QFs in Newport and Los Angeles...In doubles, reached first ATP final at Brighton (w/ Thomas...Earned career-high $258,043…2001 – Won at least one match at each of first four ATP events…Won only one match the rest of the year…Won Lexington Challenger (d. Brasington)…Claimed Futures title in Malibu (d. Boeker)…Was 16-7 in Challengers…Won doubles titles at Challengers at Waikoloa (w/Thomas) and Bermuda (w/Roddick)…Was 3-13 in ATP doubles and 11-5 in Challengers…2002 – Played three ATP events, reaching 2nd RD at Memphis (d. Arthrus, l. to Gambill)…Challenger winner in Tyler (d. Fish) and runner-up in Lexington (l. to Draper)…Compiled a 15-15 Challenger record…Won doubles title at Binghampton Challenger (w/Humphries)…Finalist at Calabasas (w/Gimelstob)…Went 11-10 in Challengers…2003 – Reached 2nd RD at four of five ATP events he played…In June, claimed Tallahassee Challenger (d. A. Kim)…Closed year by reaching three straight Challenger finals…Runner-up at Waco (l. to G. Lapentti)…Won back-to-back titles in Austin (d. Kendrick) and Champaign (d. Vahaly)…Was 36-14 in Challengers…Reached ATP doubles final at San Jose w/Kendrick (l. to Lee-Voltchkov)…Also w/Kendrick, reached SF at Delray Beach…5-4 in ATP doubles…Reached at least the SF in nine events going 21-13 in Challenger doubles…Won title in San Antonio (w/Morrison)…Reached three other finals…2004 – Reached 2nd RD at four of the six ATP events he played, including as a qualifier at US Open…Won Covington Challenger (d. Sa)…Was 16-11 in Challengers…Won back-to-back Challenger doubles titles in Covington (w/Hippensteel) and College Station (w/Vahaly)…Was 11-4 in Challenger doubles.