You know this new rule about it being loss of point if you reverse your call?
It stinks.
It is bad.
It should be changed to the way it used to be.
It came up again in my 8.0 mixed match tonight. My partner was a delightful 4.5 guy. Scrupulously fair and honest in all things. Calls lines generously.
Opponents were two 4.0s. Male is a kick in the pants. Everybody loves him. Female I hadn't met before, but also seemed nice.
We were having a very close and difficult (but enjoyable and friendly) match. My partner served to the guy in the first set. His partner called it long. He looked at her and said he thought it was probably in. He then turned to us and said, "Take two."
My partner looked at me and didn't say anything. I kept quiet. After he held serve, I said, "Hey, you know the rule was changed for 2011 and that should have been loss of point when they changed their call." He said, "Yeah, I know." And he hesitated. And I said, "I decided not to call them on it because it just felt like a real jerk move." He looked relieved and said, "I agree. It's just not right to take the point. Better to play a let."
There were two other occasions when they called first serves out and the man reversed the woman. They said "Take two," and we did.
I dunno. My 8.0 mixed matches have been so collegial, so friendly, with everyone giving benefit of the doubt and not squabbling over line calls. I think this new rule isn't necessary and would introduce ill will into things.
Also problematic is that my 4.5 partner tonight is the first partner or opponent I have had who has even heard of this new rule. It really seems unfair to spring it on opponents when USTA hasn't done much to alert everyone to it.
I think I will just start operating under the old rule and playing a let. If i am the one who makes a mistake and reverses myself, I will award the point if the opponents ask for it.