PV Audio's Playtest Thread

pvaudio

Legend
Well what have we here? Two brand new 4D200Ts for $80/ea from my home town pro shop and some Prince Premier Attack? Good day all around I think :D
 

pvaudio

Legend
So is this girl, who happens to be number 1. She looks like she is ready for a picnic in the park, and then for a hit. http://hotbeautifultennisbabes.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/06/victoria_azarenka_glamour_girl.jpg
I'll see your picnic, and raise you a KSwiss advertisement:
6ab5.jpg
 

nalvarado

Semi-Pro
Alien would be interesting to hear about. I remember my alien beast hybrid to be exceptionally comfortable for a full bed poly.
 

pvaudio

Legend
Hmm... Let me think for a few minutes. Any boundaries/conditions?
Well considering I already have a ridiculous amount of strings, the only company I have zero strings from is Gamma. The one I was thinking about is Isospeed Pyramid. Heard it gives wicked slice, even more than BHBR.
 

kiteboard

Banned
I have tried both. The 16 has a different feel, but both are cut deadly on slice. I like the bhb7 as main with bhbr, and as cross with ytex quadro twist. The thinner gauge has more power and loses tension faster.
 
Saw your post about your upcoming play tests involving the strings I asked you to try. Thanks for looking out, but don't feel obligated on my behalf.

As for the strings to buy:

Pro line Evo?
Yonex Poly Pro or the 850 multi?
Do they have Ytex?
 

alidisperanza

Hall of Fame
Well considering I already have a ridiculous amount of strings, the only company I have zero strings from is Gamma. The one I was thinking about is Isospeed Pyramid. Heard it gives wicked slice, even more than BHBR.

I can save you the time on the isospeed. Pyramids is ok but the strings lose tension terribly fast, are terrible to string and if you hit with any sort of topspin, they round out in 15.
 

pvaudio

Legend
Try some Prince Premiere Attack.
Already got it covered.
img0030hb.jpg


That's why I emailed you: I added PPA to my stringing inventory :)

While I do want to show off my new sticks...:
img0029ih.jpg

...I have a challenge: first person to accurately identify what that red and white thing is chooses the playtest after the 3 I already have lined up :)

And I'm not talking about my customer's Radical lol
 

tistrapukcipeht

Professional
Already got it covered.
img0030hb.jpg


That's why I emailed you: I added PPA to my stringing inventory :)

While I do want to show off my new sticks...:
img0029ih.jpg

...I have a challenge: first person to accurately identify what that red and white thing is chooses the playtest after the 3 I already have lined up :)

And I'm not talking about my customer's Radical lol

That is the massage thing you roll on your muscles to relieve the tension for tight muscles, right?
 

tistrapukcipeht

Professional
And what would you like to see playtested? :)

I'm play testing the Yonex Poly Tour HS 1.25 on Yonex Xi 100, I had never used either before, so if you could play test the Poly Tour HS would be great.

I'm using it at 53/51 , it's been only 2 hours in the first session and I like the string for the control it provides, but i don't know if the string is a little stiffer or if it is the racquet at this point.

What do you think? Can you play test this string?
 

tistrapukcipeht

Professional
BTW, I'm using the swimming pool thick noodles for that, but I wanted to know where you bought yours, if possible.

Mark Philippousis has one of that thing on his bag check, or similar at least.

Thanks
 

mikeler

Moderator
Ooh, PPA in Black 17. Think that will be interesting. Have a feeling that one will be popular with your clients.
 

pvaudio

Legend
BTW, I'm using the swimming pool thick noodles for that, but I wanted to know where you bought yours, if possible.

Mark Philippousis has one of that thing on his bag check, or similar at least.

Thanks

http://www.amazon.com/The-Stick-TravelStick-Travel/dp/B000P7PVWU/ref=pd_sbs_sg_1

I saw it in my local running shop once, and I asked the saleswoman what it was. She's like "it's a massager stick, you roll it over your muscles and it helps recovery." I thought it was a load of BS. I went home a few weeks later and my father, who's been cycling for the past 30 years and races kids my age had one in the study. He'd gotten back from a ride and was using it. I was like, is that one of those muscle sticks? He goes "this thing is great! No more cramps blah blah blah blah". I was skeptical, so I ran 5k or so the next morning, used the thing before I got in the shower and for the first time ever, my quads weren't sore in the slightest. I swear by it now, and for ~25 bucks, it's worth not being sore after training :)
 

mikeler

Moderator
http://www.amazon.com/The-Stick-TravelStick-Travel/dp/B000P7PVWU/ref=pd_sbs_sg_1

I saw it in my local running shop once, and I asked the saleswoman what it was. She's like "it's a massager stick, you roll it over your muscles and it helps recovery." I thought it was a load of BS. I went home a few weeks later and my father, who's been cycling for the past 30 years and races kids my age had one in the study. He'd gotten back from a ride and was using it. I was like, is that one of those muscle sticks? He goes "this thing is great! No more cramps blah blah blah blah". I was skeptical, so I ran 5k or so the next morning, used the thing before I got in the shower and for the first time ever, my quads weren't sore in the slightest. I swear by it now, and for ~25 bucks, it's worth not being sore after training :)

Father knows best. When my son can read, I'm bringing him back to this post. :)
 

Hi I'm Ray

Professional
With respects to ppl's own opinions here:

Vesnina, really? I just watched her from the 2nd row, she's not bad but kinda average looking.

An opinion is just another opinion, I'm not sure why a few posters here are acting like certain reviewer(s) opinions are any more valid than others. Strings and rackets are very subjective and obviously not everyone can agree on them.

I have never used L-tec and I am not interested in them but if they can last at least twice as long as other polys I wouldn't say they are worthless or unsuitable for high level players because the playability isn't high enough. Ppl who don't have their own stringing machines need to take into accound the cost of restringing and time (driving, waiting) I think forums(not just tennis related) can mislead ppl into thinking equipment that is not "top notch" is unusable. I have met some very good players, college level, that really are not picky at all about strings. Some play with all Prince syn gut og, some use whatever their college provides for free, some don't even know whats in their frames and just let their stringer take care of everything, many play with poly till it breaks even if its been dead for 2 weeks. Some ppl are equipment sensitive, some are not.

Basically PV, Arches and KB are comparing Apples to Oranges. PV tested Pro/5S (which I haven't played) while Arches and KB played with 0S/4S (which I have played and agree with them that it has excellent playability similar to that of ALU). In my 0S/4S review I said that people who like ALU will most likely find 0S/4S a more comfortable, longer lasting version of ALU.

Also I personally will cut out 0S/4S after 6 hours because that was my observed peak performance period, although you can certainly play with it well past 10 hours with more than adequate performance. Lastly 0S/4S, like ALU and RPM, will NEVER win any price to performance awards. Those 3 premium polys are for PZero performance, not 3 year/36,000 mile guarantee performance.


Nadal - His movement and strokes are like a young BULL. He intimidates people on the court and bullies them around. His FH looks like it's going out by 10 ft but drops down 90 degrees and kicks up VIOLENTLY. Trying to return his ridiculous topspin FH is like trying to catch a cannonball with dishwashing gloves.

Ivanovic - BOOMING FH. She doesn't look like a tennis player. She looks like a supermodel showing off her Adidas clothes on the court runway.

I watched Nadal & Ivanovic at the BNP and have to agree with this. Nadal seems kinda restless like he's got too much energy and will just smack a surprisingly fast ground stroke suddenly, it looks like a freakin serve. I didn't see anyone hit groundstrokes that hard that day, not Djokovic, maybe Almagro once but not with as much control. The other team did seem intimidated. Groundstrokes look like they're going to fly out but then suddenly dives into the court near the baseline. Interesting observation of Ivanovic too, she doesn't seem like she's playing hard, her movement is girly and not very agressive but she's winning and somehow hits hard shots esp her forehand.
 
Last edited:

alidisperanza

Hall of Fame
With respects to ppl's own opinions here:

An opinion is just another opinion, I'm not sure why a few posters here are acting like certain reviewer(s) opinions are any more valid than others. Strings and rackets are very subjective and obviously not everyone can agree on them.

I have never used L-tec and I am not interested in them but if they can last at least twice as long as other polys I wouldn't say they are worthless or unsuitable for high level players because the playability isn't high enough. Ppl who don't have their own stringing machines need to take into accound the cost of restringing and time (driving, waiting) I think forums(not just tennis related) can mislead ppl into thinking equipment that is not "top notch" is unusable. I have met some very good players, college level, that really are not picky at all about strings. Some play with all Prince syn gut og, some use whatever their college provides for free, some don't even know whats in their frames and just let their stringer take care of everything, many play with poly till it breaks even if its been dead for 2 weeks. Some ppl are equipment sensitive, some are not.

.

I definitely agree with much of what you wrote but here are a few comments;

- Opinions definitely are personal but then again, there are some that are more reliable/ credible than others. If someone offers an opinion that is consistent, and credible as reviewed by other peers it may be considered more credible than someone who doesn't necessarily have that history. For example; would you take tennis tips from Roger Federer? How about some random old man with a walmart racquet that comes up to you @ the park?
Obviously, I'm exaggerating here but the point still stands; there is a measure of credibility.


As for the second part, I don't think anyone is saying that the strings are worthless but rather not quite living up to their promotion. Also, I think the communal thought and concern here is the value of the strings. Home stringers get a break when it comes to trying different things but imagine what someone without these options would have to go through? They would not only have to pay the base cost of the string but the cost of stringing. With the Jet method and the expensive training required to "properly" string frames, one would assume that the cost of stringing will subsequently increase. In the end, the consumer would be getting an average product at a premium price.

I also know several outstanding players that don't have any real preference for string etc. What I do know is that they want their frames to be strung consistently at the cheapest rate possible.
 

pvaudio

Legend
HIR, I agree with you completely. But what you're addressing isn't the issue at hand. It's that the claims made are nowhere near their true performance. Also, for those needing longevity, the German polys from Signum Pro, WeissCANNON and Genesis (in that order) will hold tension for the duration of their lifespan. I have a friend, customer and hitting partner who is using full WC Scorpion. He emailed me Wednesday and said this:
By the way, I hit with my dad tonight and that Scorpion still feels great. It's funny, it went through a little period where it wasn't feeling as good, but tonight it felt plush. Perhaps it loosened up a little more and evened out, and perhaps the warm weather here helps with feel just in general. Anyway, it's quite something that it still feels and plays so well given that it's been in there for a lot of hours of play. Great string!
I strung the racquet on January 31. For someone at his level, that's pretty good longevity. For someone at a lower level, then you wouldn't need to replace your string for months. Point is: if a 9 dollar string like Scorpion will play great for 6 weeks+, why shell out over twice that much to get something with, in my opinion, far worse playability? I'm slightly biased because I think that Scorpion is probably the best overall poly string out there. I don't know of a single player who would not benefit from it in some way. There are strings which perform better in certain areas, but as an overall package, it's nearly impossible to top for a smooth poly. The L-Tec effectively needs to blow the Scorpion out of the water for playability and last for much longer. It doesn't.

Let me put it like this, since ali above alluded to a very good point. I have customers who don't care what's in their racquet. I've got a ex-college player who wants Wilson Stamina 16 at 58/58 and that's it. Then I've got 3.0s who want natural gut mains and Luxilon crosses because Federer uses it. These players won't care about L-Tec. The ones who will are us: string junkies who like tooling with their equipment. We're the market: 3.5-4.5 level players who enjoy the technical aspect of the game. If we don't like it, then it's not a successful product. Since the target market has yet to be wowed by L-Tec's performance and its price is extreme, then it won't be a popular choice. Now, if they lowered the price to even $12/set, then they'd be competitive. At their pricing, no durability claims will make it worth the price since their target market either breaks strings often, or tries something new.
 

rdis10093

Hall of Fame
For the record, here will be the next playtests in order:

1. Isospeed Baseline Spin / Gosen OGSM 17 (Ultimate budget hybrid)

2. Luxilon Adrenaline Rough / Yonex 850 (per request by rdis10093, whom I string this for in real life and he gave me some to try)

3. Full Gosen Polylon OR Polylon / OGSM 17

right on, hope it plays as good for you as it does for my game
 

arche3

Banned
:lol: It's funny you asked me that, because the same guy, rdis10093 offered me two sets of it when I picked up the string in question. Let's just say I let him keep it :)

are you talking about the new luxilon prototype ? that roddick supposedly played? and or Nishikori supposedly plays?

I'd like a review of that string.
 

pvaudio

Legend
are you talking about the new luxilon prototype ? that roddick supposedly played? and or Nishikori supposedly plays?

I'd like a review of that string.
I already reviewed the gold lux string in that thread. It feels like a 1st gen poly, and nothing more. I did not try the green stuff, but heard it was nice. The consensus on the gold though was that was just generic feeling. I concur with that assessment.
 

arche3

Banned
I already reviewed the gold lux string in that thread. It feels like a 1st gen poly, and nothing more. I did not try the green stuff, but heard it was nice. The consensus on the gold though was that was just generic feeling. I concur with that assessment.

hmm.. .too bad. Luxilon needs a new string.
 

pvaudio

Legend
hmm.. .too bad. Luxilon needs a new string.
Honestly, I don't think that they do. I almost liken Luxilon to BMW. ALU is the M5, the BB derivatives (Original, TiMo, Fluoro, Ace) are the M3. You choose which one you want depending on your tastes, but all are top tier. Then you have Savage and Adrenaline which are the 535i and 325i depending on which one you want to take which spot. Point being, while they still hold the name, the only reason you're buying them is because ALU and Big Banger strings have such a reputation. In other words, while you know you're getting a high quality product, it's only because of the quality of the flagship marques that they'll even sell. While I haven't tried Adrenaline Rough (but obviously will momentarily), Savage and Adrenaline are just good strings with the Lux name on them. I do not think that they're bad at all, honestly. While Adrenaline is not, I do however strongly feel that Savage is overpriced. However, unlike with many other string brands (or hell even BMW) where even across the models, you can tell that it's made by the same people because of a certain trait, Adrenaline and Savage do not remind me of ALU or the BB strings in any way shape or form. ALU and the BB guys give the "Luxilon" feel. Adrenaline and Savage don't have that.

So just to make sure people aren't misunderstanding what I'm saying: I do NOT dislike Luxilon. I don't think their strings are crap at all. I DO think that Savage and Adrenaline were created for people who cannot afford to play with ALU or BB but still wanted to play with Luxilon string (brand loyalty, whatever you wish to call it). It's there though that I DO think that neither feels remotely similar to any other Luxilon offerings. And it's for that reason that if someone sees that I carry Adrenaline (which I do) and would like it because it's Lux, I would steer them towards an alternative. The strings themselves though, are fine, and Adrenaline is not an overpriced poly. It just bears no relation to its name.
 
Top