Well in the end, what the initial concept parameters were doesn't really matter, other than being right. The Stycon is here, so all that is moot.
The quotes are from the video with the designer of the shoe. He clearly stated that their purpose was to provide the said stability and low to the ground position as their primary goal....
Speaking of one of the main design elements, I can't believe there's still harping on laces. No one is telling anyone to buy this shoe if they don't like it. I am here to discuss the merits and issues of the Stycon. I've broken laces in my lifetime as a player, more than 4 times in competition, including last year on clay. That's nothing like academy trained kids nowadays. The college players I hit with a couple of times a month have shredded laces, and they wanted to try the Stycon but they can't cos their colleges are sponsored Nike and NB. LOL.
Still don't believe broken laces is an issue? For further proof of the issue, look no further than the Nike Vapor Cage 4. The inside vamp is higher to protect the laces from being shredded. Would 2 major brands have designed into their top tier shoes ways to protect the shoes laces from a "non-existent" problem?!? Shoelaces tearing from sliding is real, but obviously not everyone suffers from them. Shoelaces shifting is also a real thing, especially with waxed laces and hook eyelets.
All that said, the Stycon is a great shoe for only for some foot types, and there are issues that need to be addressed to broaden the shoe's appeal. First off, there is obviously a need for a 'Stycon Plus', for those who can't handle the elastic band pressure on the arches. Building in an extra few mm more elastic should help wider or more sensitive feet. The sock liner in the upper definitely needs to be more vented/breathable for higher than low 70s°F and 70% humidity. The pointy toe box shape precludes certain foot shapes, unless you size up, which may also help with the band issue.
The positives of the Stycon? Stability! All highly stable shoes have a cradle for support, and the Stycon has one of the highest, if not the highest, sidewalls of all tennis shoes. It's the most stable shoe out there, but those who are feedback oriented will feel insecure because it doesn't feel like a conventional shoe. The physics is sound, and only if your foot slips out of the deep cradle, can there be instability. Those elastic bands will keep your feet in the cradle. And that brings me to support. The sockliner/elastic band supports the foot well (too well for some!) so if you are on your forefoot a lot, you'll feel no hindrance on footwork. In fact, that midsole acts like the Air Zoom Zero, in that it slight leans you forward on your forefoot, which is good for proper footwork.
Low to the ground, court feel are also strong points. For me, cushioning is good, a firm but comfortable ride. I have triedthe Superfeet Carbon insole for a bit more arch support, and there is little drop in comfort from the bands, just a bit more pressure. Jumping on the heel with the insole makes it more cushy, but not something I need. Ankle support is also good, something lacking in other low profile shoes.
Durability of the outsole is as good as the SCB. I've played a lot and it's holding up well. The upper is tougher than it looks, taking some scraping from my foot drags on my backfoot.
As I've mentioned before, I do use the clay black Stycon on hard courts. The wear is the same so it's the same Adiwear rubber. There isn't a torsion bar cutout in the outsole, so I can't say if it's left out of the clay shoe. I don't feel any discernible difference in stability with either models on hard court. I've played twice on red clay, and the mid cut does keep clay out of the shoes. Funnily I did find temporary shrinkage of the elastic band on the right shoe after washing off the clay with water. The left shoe was also wet but didn't feel tighter. I had the same with my N3xt L3v3ls.
Any other questions, please ask here. After all, we are here to share information about gear, the good and the bad. Otherwise, I think I've said all I can about the Stycon. Enjoy it or hate it, but don't lose too much sleep over it!