Does Nadal really warrant THAT much hate?

Does Nadal warrant that much hate?

  • Yes he's the most despicable human on earth

    Votes: 22 14.3%
  • Yes his antics bother me

    Votes: 60 39.0%
  • No he has done a lot for the sport

    Votes: 61 39.6%
  • Neutral

    Votes: 11 7.1%

  • Total voters
    154
D

Deleted member 21996

Guest
I like watching clay matches and enjoyed Nadal's game very much. While I do have some issues with some of his antics (time wasting, injury timeouts), I nevertheless appreciate his game and his achievements.

However, the hate around here directed towards this guy lately is unbelievable. Say one word in defense and you get labelled a "*******". Is he such a despicable human being that he shouldn't exist on the face on earth? Discuss:)

completely agree with OP.

i mean:


  • he wastes time on court
    makes suspicious medical time outs
    is suspected to use PEDs
    has a ugly game
    grunts like a pig
    complaints about the schedule while playing extra exos and doubles
    wears cheesy clothes
    only respects his opponents when he wins.
    makes unecessary fist pumps and celebrations
    whines about the courts colors... ffs
    whines about the advantages of hc to other players
    gives death glares across the net when he gets owned
    never aplauds a great point by the oponent
    has some serious nasty OCD behaviours
    has a whole armada of nationals bending for him
    has some of the most whiny beetchee fans. for evidence see op and my sig.
    ....

i cannot understand why so much hate... all in all he seem a pretty likeable guy. i mean... just because he has a positive h2h towards a fruity lady bag user? makes no sense!!!
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Bobby Jr

G.O.A.T.
For all his tennis talent, Nadal comes across like that kid you knew at school who always wanted their own way, would always complain about anything which didn't satisfy their wishes and had a general myopia with regards to the other's wants and needs. Most people's self-awareness sharpens up as they get into their late teens but, for some reason, his hasn't.

Nadal generally says all the right things when talking about his opponent's tennis but the way he acts when playing says otherwise. He is probably the most disrespectful player towards his opponent of all time - and people should call him up on it so he stops imo. I worry that in the future he will looked back upon with a fair amount of disdain relative to his peers because of the poor sportsmanship he's shown so often during matches (time-wasting, medical time-outs etc).
 
Last edited:
M

monfed

Guest
For all his tennis talent, Nadal comes across like that kid you knew at school who always wanted their own way, would always complain about anything which didn't satisfy their wishes and had a general myopia with regards to the other's wants and needs. Most people's self-awareness sharpens up as they get into their late teens but, for some reason, his hasn't.

Nadal generally says all the right things when talking about his opponent's tennis but the way he acts when playing says otherwise. He is probably the most disrespectful player towards his opponent of all time - and people should call him up on it so he stops imo.


He wants to win at any cost.
 

Bartelby

Bionic Poster
so its never occurred to anyone that they've got the problem - i mean all you know about the guy is next to nothing
 
People hate nadal because of the way in which he takes a defeat..he hints at his existing(or non-existing) injury after he loses a match too often..that's the main reason he is hated by many..
Yes,he is a great player but he has to learn and accept a loss gracefully and not take the credit away from the opponent citing an injury..also he should move on when things don't always go to his liking(like madrid blue clay) and stop whining about every such thing..
 
A

aprilfool

Guest
I wouldn't worry about it. He has a Public Relations firm, yes?

I should think that a lot of it is directed at some of his fans here; the savage attacks on Fed and his then-girlfriend back in 08-09 will not be easily forgotten for some.
 

Magnus

Legend
Good point.

Nadal has 10,464,913.
Federer has 10,487,125.

But don't be too disappointed, Nadal is about to pass him.

Tiesto beats Armin van Buuren on the amount of FB fans by a few good millions, yet its Armin that passes him every year on top DJ list of DJ Mag (where the fans vote). FB means nothing.
 
D

Deleted member 21996

Guest
so its never occurred to anyone that they've got the problem - i mean all you know about the guy is next to nothing

yes. they are all lunatics and Nadal and his erratic behaviours is the sane one among!
 

ledwix

Hall of Fame
The last time I rooted for Nadal in a tennis match was in 2005 vs Puerta in the RG final. His strategy, ugly playing style, pre-serve ritual, facial expressions and pre-pubescent grunt (although it sounds less bad in person) have always rubbed me the wrong way.
 
Last edited:
tumblr_lvm437bgp71r75coao1_500.gif
 

Homeboy Hotel

Hall of Fame
Irony when Nadal is the most talked about on this forum. Check the top 4 recent threads, they're all Nadal related.

Everyone is blatant closet Nadal fans.
 
I think its safe to say this forum is mostly Federer fans, so there is no surprise regarding Nadal hate. Nobody has hurt Federer's fan base more than Nadal has. And he's only just beginning. 16 is not enough.
 

sbengte

G.O.A.T.
I think its safe to say this forum is mostly Federer fans, so there is no surprise regarding Nadal hate.

Not necessarily. What the Nadal fans lack in strength of numbers, they make up for in the quality and quantity of poasting, so it all evens out.
 
Last edited:

vive le beau jeu !

Talk Tennis Guru
I have a question. Why do so many *********s think that the only reason people dislike Nadal's game is because of his victories over Federer? That's a strawman argument.
blame it on the glasses which keep them from seeing all this:
completely agree with OP.

i mean:


  • he wastes time on court
    makes suspicious medical time outs
    is suspected to use PEDs
    has a ugly game
    grunts like a pig
    complaints about the schedule while playing extra exos and doubles
    wears cheesy clothes
    only respects his opponents when he wins.
    makes unecessary fist pumps and celebrations
    whines about the courts colors... ffs
    whines about the advantages of hc to other players
    gives death glares across the net when he gets owned
    never aplauds a great point by the oponent
    has some serious nasty OCD behaviours
    has a whole armada of nationals bending for him
    has some of the most whiny beetchee fans. for evidence see op and my sig.
    ....

i cannot understand why so much hate... all in all he seem a pretty likeable guy. i mean... just because he has a positive h2h towards a fruity lady bag user? makes no sense!!!
without ******* glasses:
tumblr_ljyjpjn4Ed1qgeyd8o1_500.gif


with ******* glasses:
montagne-feu.jpg
 
completely agree with OP.

i mean:


  • he wastes time on court
    makes suspicious medical time outs
    is suspected to use PEDs
    has a ugly game
    grunts like a pig
    complaints about the schedule while playing extra exos and doubles
    wears cheesy clothes
    only respects his opponents when he wins.
    makes unecessary fist pumps and celebrations
    whines about the courts colors... ffs
    whines about the advantages of hc to other players
    gives death glares across the net when he gets owned
    never aplauds a great point by the oponent
    has some serious nasty OCD behaviours
    has a whole armada of nationals bending for him
    has some of the most whiny beetchee fans. for evidence see op and my sig.
    ....

i cannot understand why so much hate... all in all he seem a pretty likeable guy. i mean... just because he has a positive h2h towards a fruity lady bag user? makes no sense!!!

You forgot:

Illegal coaching
Favourable draws
Preemptive excuses
Mind games
 

Magnus

Legend
Irony when Nadal is the most talked about on this forum. Check the top 4 recent threads, they're all Nadal related.

Everyone is blatant closet Nadal fans.

Right, we all really love Nadal, but are afraid to say it, so we pretend to hate him instead. That makes a lot of sense.
 

Sentinel

Bionic Poster
I think its safe to say this forum is mostly Federer fans, so there is no surprise regarding Nadal hate. Nobody has hurt Federer's fan base more than Nadal has. And he's only just beginning. 16 is not enough.
Oh, come on. If that were true, the 3rd option would not be leading. I've also voted for the 3rd.

It is unfortunate how some discussion and debate can be taken for hatred. I can't speak for others but I totally love Nadal and my Nadal fan brothers and sisters.

Vamos !
 
S

srinrajesh

Guest
It is okay for him to celebrate in every way he wants without offending the opponent. That celebration isn't suitable for a set or match point, nor going to deuce.

The key is not offending the opponent .. Rafa has celebrated with fist pumping number of times so his opponents expect that..

But the djokovic celebration after AO win is downright insulting and disgusting to look at.. After a six hour win, you would expect him to show more respect for opponent .. and please recall Nadal's consoling Federer at the presentation in 2009.

http://www.novafm.com.au/video/nova...elebration-after-winning-2012-australian-open
 
S

srinrajesh

Guest
Also posting link of Nadal consoling Federer after AO

I cant recall any better show of humane behaviour and sportsmanship than this. Remember Nadal was 22 and had just won his first slam on HC and he was in control enough to avoid any major celebration like djokovic and
instead consoled his opponent

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0hnJlFdVXW8
 

Clarky21

Banned
Making fun of someone's illness , Clarky ? Not cool. I see Nadal tends to do this too as he referred to Novak's breathing issues at the AO as "funny".
http://tt.tennis-warehouse.com/showthread.php?t=411285


Well,which illness was it that caused him to miss his presser? He did have several different excuses,but I chose the heartburn because it was the most ridiculous. According to him and his "team" he also had "low blood pressure",and "too much acid in his stomach". Shady doesn't even begin to describe this guy and his "team".
 

Numenor

Rookie
That is often where the least of the vitriol is directed....

of course fans of "attacking" players hate his game and others cannot stand his "antics" but the bitterness and schadendfreude most exhibit is rooted in deep resentment of his achievements over Federer.

That has PLENTY to do with it and its more then obvious when you look at who is throwing the most hate out. The sane Federer fans like Sid Vicious are awesome. The mental ones like ****forthewin are the examples. Nadal's success is why they hate him.

Fair points. It is also important to recognize that player hate can go both ways - I've seen Nadal "fans" like MariaRafael throw racist and murderous retorts against Djoker, even threatening to push him off a building. I've also been lurking here since 2008/2009, and I remember the vitriol and hate directed towards Federer - especially after AO2009 (one vile poster comes to mind). Heck, I remember when a ********* posted insults against Fed's kids. Obviously there are more Federer fans here, but it shouldn't excuse anyone from hating a player so much.
 

Slice&Smash

Rookie
Plus Nadal is a more humble and likeable personality than Federer. And Nadal didn't use facebook to lobby for the most popular player 'award'.

Yes. We all know Facebook has been used by neanderthal females to verify the humbleness and likability of their potential mating partners.
 

Lsmkenpo

Hall of Fame
My Dear Friends,

I don't believe Nadal receives enough pure hatred, a large majority of the pure hatred he should receive is diminished by the phoney propaganda stories big businesses use to build Nadal's image as the nicest young man the world has ever known.
 

Tony48

Legend
Nadal's whole "underdog" persona is really aggravating. That's why I'm glad Novak rose to the occasion and put Nadal right where the underdog belongs: somewhere other than No. 1.
 

rafan

Hall of Fame
Oh of course he is a a candidate for hate: he is rich, successful, very attractive, worshipped the world over and a hell of a nice guy. I mean what more do you want!
 
N

NadalAgassi

Guest
Nadal's whole "underdog" persona is really aggravating. That's why I'm glad Novak rose to the occasion and put Nadal right where the underdog belongs: somewhere other than No. 1.

Compare the # of weeks he has spent ranked #2 since 2005 to spent at #1. Probably about triple. I would venture to guess he must hold the all time record for time spent at #2 by a landslide now, perhaps the most time anyone will be ranked at #2 for decades to come. So his long standing underdog complex which persists to this day makes perfect sense when you look at it that way.
 
Also posting link of Nadal consoling Federer after AO

I cant recall any better show of humane behaviour and sportsmanship than this. Remember Nadal was 22 and had just won his first slam on HC and he was in control enough to avoid any major celebration like djokovic and
instead consoled his opponent

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0hnJlFdVXW8

Exactly, Nadal's reaction to winning AO 2009 compared with Djokovic's celebration at AO 2012, is like night and day. Especially considering that it was a 6 hour match. Utterly disgraceful shirt-rip. I know Nadal will never lower himself to Djokovic's behavior, but I'd like to see the look in Djokovic's face if Nadal shirt-ripped after beating Djokovic at Wimbledon this year.
 

Gangsta

Rookie
I have not been on this forum for too long, but even I can see there is plenty of Nadal hate here. A lot of my friends hate Nadal too, with at least half of them annoyed at him for beating Federer basically. The rest just say they only like aggressive players from Federer, which is weird in itself because Nadal is so NOT a defensive player. He just likes to play high-percentage tennis, but when the time comes to put a ball away, he is almost always there and almost always does put it away easily. How can anyone not like a sportsman that constantly keeps punching above his weight?
 

Tony48

Legend
Compare the # of weeks he has spent ranked #2 since 2005 to spent at #1. Probably about triple. I would venture to guess he must hold the all time record for time spent at #2 by a landslide now, perhaps the most time anyone will be ranked at #2 for decades to come. So his long standing underdog complex which persists to this day makes perfect sense when you look at it that way.

I'm talking about when he's up against a complete nobody (or someone who has never won a set off of him) and he implies that there is no way he can win.

Considering the thing he does with his water bottles, it's obviously an attempt at anti-jinxing ("If I say I will win, I will lose, no? So....I say I will lose."). I find that incredibly annoying. Of course it's going to be tough but to give the distinct impression that you're going to lose? If he feels that way then it's time to stand aside and let someone else take over.
 
I have not been on this forum for too long, but even I can see there is plenty of Nadal hate here. A lot of my friends hate Nadal too, with at least half of them annoyed at him for beating Federer basically. The rest just say they only like aggressive players from Federer, which is weird in itself because Nadal is so NOT a defensive player. He just likes to play high-percentage tennis, but when the time comes to put a ball away, he is almost always there and almost always does put it away easily. How can anyone not like a sportsman that constantly keeps punching above his weight?

Very perfectly described, agree.
 

Evan77

Banned
I have not been on this forum for too long, but even I can see there is plenty of Nadal hate here. A lot of my friends hate Nadal too, with at least half of them annoyed at him for beating Federer basically. The rest just say they only like aggressive players from Federer, which is weird in itself because Nadal is so NOT a defensive player. He just likes to play high-percentage tennis, but when the time comes to put a ball away, he is almost always there and almost always does put it away easily. How can anyone not like a sportsman that constantly keeps punching above his weight?
lol, sorry but but Rafa IS and always been a very defensive player. sure, he does hit some winners, but overall, Nadal is the biggest pusher/grinder in tennis history. now, there are too many posts here regarding 'why people hate Nadal'. I think the hate word is too strong. I simply don't like his style of play, I do not like his buttpicking, he is abusing almost every single ATP rule and getting away with it ...
 

Bender

G.O.A.T.
completely agree with OP.

i mean:

  • he wastes time on court - as does Djokovic, but I don't see his name thrown around ever in this regard
  • makes suspicious medical time outs - again, as does Djokovic and to a lesser extent, Del Potro. Besides, I never quite understood *******s' incessant statements that Rafa would burn out or retire early due to his style of play, then almost simultaneously and unanimously state that he is faking whenever he does succumb to those same injuries *******s predicted he would get
  • is suspected to use PEDs - as is everybody else. I don't see *******s accuse Djokovic of PEDing even though he's outNadal-ing Nadal
  • has a ugly game - that's a matter of taste, not a fact, but you're genuinely welcome to feel that way if you want for that very reason. However, on a related note, I would like to point out that the argument that Rafa does not play proper tennis is absolutely laughable, since it's suggesting not only that Federer is losing to a guy who isn't even playing the game properly, but also that the conditions that allow Rafa to excel are not that of tennis. Since when did tennis stop being tennis?
  • grunts like a pig - if Rafa's grunts sound like that of a pig's then you clearly have no idea what a pig sounds like. At any rate, Djokovic grunts loudly too, as does Murray, and he sounds sounds like a strangled cow
    complaints about the schedule while playing extra exos and doubles - exhibitions and doubles both require far less concentration/effort and/or running respectively, but this is a fair enough point
  • wears cheesy clothes - yeah, because Rafa design his own clothes and chooses his own wardrobe, while Nike is paid to let him use their logo
  • only respects his opponents when he wins - I don't recall him ever try take away from his opponent when he loses. Where he's injured, he insists that his injury isn't why he lost, but rather because his opponent played incredibly. If you want a player who doesn't respect the opponent after a loss, refer to Serena Williams.
  • makes unecessary fist pumps and celebrations - what constitutes unnecessary? Almost everyone on tour does these. Plus, a celebration after an opponent's UE isn't a de facto situation of un-necessity. Sometimes, especially when you start to have doubts about a particular point, while you are playing that said point, an opponent's UE will feel like a godsend.
  • whines about the courts colors... ffs - coming from a member of a board that nitpicks over whether the latest BLX paintjob is nice or not, this is rich. Anyway, his complaints were pretty specific, and not simply over the fact that it's blue.
  • whines about the advantages of hc to other players - I think he only "whines" about the wear and tear HC does to players' knees, which is true. Doctors even recommend normal people like us to avoid even jogging on cement, so I can't imagine the amount of damage HC does to players' knees. Plus, it is true that HC is overrepresented amongst the surfaces, at least to my knowledge. Bring more grass.
  • gives death glares across the net when he gets owned - I don't think they're death glares, because he always has a serious look throughout proper matches. However since it's not like I asked Rafa about said 'death glares' but neither have you, I think we ought to agree to disagree on this point.[/B]
  • never aplauds a great point by the oponent - and Federer does? Amongst the top four, only Djokovic applauds his opponents, which is why I think he's by far the most gracious loser in the top 4. Berdych at the AO against Rafa was a bit like this too at one point.
  • has some serious nasty OCD behaviours - actually, all of them do, though Rafa seems to have more, er, 'creativity' in this department than does anybody else. Plus, casual labelling of 'OCD' is not a black/white affair. My friends still think I'm OCD because I add lead tape to my racquet, and want a second racquet with the exact same specs.
  • has a whole armada of nationals bending for him - and what, Djokovic has only his neighbourhood block in Serbia supporting him? Last time I checked, the guy may as well become head of state after he retires. Besides, if you find this aspect annoying, you ought to really hate Murray, since at least Rafa lives up to his hype in terms of results.
  • has some of the most whiny beetchee fans. for evidence see op and my sig. - b_tching = complaining continuously, spitefully. Guess which group happens to do just this the most?
    ....

i cannot understand why so much hate... all in all he seem a pretty likeable guy. i mean... just because he has a positive h2h towards a fruity lady bag user? makes no sense!!!
As much as I hate your average ******* like the rest of everyone else on these forums, this is just a prime example of double standards (assuming you're being serious and not just taking the p_ss).

The fact that the aforementioned criticisms apply to plenty of other players (Djokovic in particular), the fact that they are not mentioned while Rafa gets burnt alive tells you something. Expanding on this;

  1. Djokovic shares many of the criticisms you have mentioned, yet it's only Rafa who gets hated for them.
  2. Rafa leads the H2H with Federer, beating Federer summarily; has denied Federer numerous slams, almost all of them in finals
  3. Djokovic trails the H2H with Federer
  4. Djokovic has been summarily beating Rafa in the past year, but has major trouble beating, or gets beaten by Federer
  5. *******s gleefully rub in Rafa's losses to Djokovic, making statements along the lines of "now you know what it feels like"
  6. The above said commonly-shared experience is the experience of a favourite player being defeated routinely at finals, denying said favourite player of the title
  7. Given the aforementioned, it seems highly unlikely that the unequal treatment of these two players is purely bad luck or coincidence, but rather due to the fact that Djokovic is like Federer's vengeance personified; the fact that Djokovic also scrapes wins over Federer gives *******s hope, unlike Rafa who as far as *******s are concerned is a foregone conclusion
  8. Since it appears that *******s and/or Fed fans (who I believe to make up a large part if not the majority of this forum's members) hate Rafa primarily, if not solely, on the basis that Rafa defeats Federer convincingly (and therefore without even a shred of hope that Fed can prevail in the future), I think lists like the above are in fact an afterthought, compiled only to convince themselves and others that their hatred of the "topspin monkey" is in fact rational.
  9. However, it is clear from the poor, if not nonexistent application of such reasons (i.e. players who share many or most of the complaints ought to be similarly-hated, yet are not, especially if they appear to beat Rafa convincingly with regularity), that these complaints as justifications for the Rafa hate does not actually hold water.
  10. Therefore, the general hatred of Rafa on this forum is simple: because a) he has a leading H2H against Federer, which were b) amassed at crucial meetings, i.e. at slam finals, thereby denying Federer any more slams.
  11. That said, it is not wrong to hate Rafa, nor is it unusual. Finding his game ugly or boring is a matter of taste, and since a player's game is unique to that player, this does allow for people to hate or dislike on a specific player and not others. What I am saying however is that these self-proclaimed 'rational' Fed fans who hate Rafa are anything but rational, let alone unbiased. Rational people don't bring up every possible criticism at any opportunity or mention of that person. Rational people are consistent and do make reasonable concessions, but aside from a few exceptions, most people who hate Rafa are anything but so in their application of the numerous, shared and common factors that, apparently, cause them to hate Rafa only.
Now I'm going to test my own patience by not responding to the inevitable drivel labelled as counterarguments by some of the biggest idiots on this board, and responding only to those ones that actually make valid points.
 
N

NadalAgassi

Guest
I'm talking about when he's up against a complete nobody (or someone who has never won a set off of him) and he implies that there is no way he can win.

Considering the thing he does with his water bottles, it's obviously an attempt at anti-jinxing ("If I say I will win, I will lose, no? So....I say I will lose."). I find that incredibly annoying. Of course it's going to be tough but to give the distinct impression that you're going to lose? If he feels that way then it's time to stand aside and let someone else take over.

I guess I havent noticed that as much, I heard those quotes mostly when playing Federer in the early years, and playing Djokovic lately. You could be right though, I dont may much attention to what players say in early rounds. Although I guess when one thinks about it, he should have seen himself as the favorite:

-vs anyone (Federer included) for every tournament from Monte Carlo 2008 to Wimbledon 2009, with Wimbledon 2008 being the only possible exception.

-vs anyone (Federer included) for every tournament from Monte Carlo 2010 to Wimbledon 2011, with Roland Garros 2011 the only possible exception after 4 straight losses to Djokovic coming in, including 2 on clay.

-vs anyone for virtually every clay tournament he was in from 2005-today

-vs anyone else except Federer from 2005-2007 and Djokovic from spring 2011 to today

So yeah the underdog tag should be a rarity if he is being honest and not either false modesty or mind games of some sort.
 
D

Deleted member 21996

Guest
i'll teach you to properly reply to my post, both in terms of organization and content

as does Djokovic, but I don't see his name thrown around ever in this regard

then you need a reality check as i have seen him caled out in that bs many times. MANY

again, as does Djokovic and to a lesser extent, Del Potro. Besides, I never quite understood *******s' incessant statements that Rafa would burn out or retire early due to his style of play, then almost simultaneously and unanimously state that he is faking whenever he does succumb to those same injuries *******s predicted he would get

Good luck in finding me making such statements. i could care less what the Federetes say!!

- as is everybody else. I don't see *******s accuse Djokovic of PEDing even though he's outNadal-ing Nadal

does he (ND) look roided up?

that's a matter of taste, not a fact, but you're genuinely welcome to feel that way if you want for that very reason

never said it was!

if Rafa's grunts sound like that of a pig's then you clearly have no idea what a pig sounds like. At any rate, Djokovic grunts loudly too, as does Murray, and he sounds sounds like a strangled cow

says the farmer to the boy...


- exhibitions and doubles both require far less concentration/effort and/or running respectively, but this is a fair enough point

pick the finger so i can scratch my armpit...

wears cheesy clothes - yeah, because Rafa design his own clothes and chooses his own wardrobe, while Nike is paid to let him use their logo

you telling me he as no saying in that? keep dreaming baby!

- I don't recall him ever try take away from his opponent when he loses. Where he's injured, he insists that his injury isn't why he lost, but rather because his opponent played incredibly. If you want a player who doesn't respect the opponent after a loss, refer to Serena Williams.

Nadal's atitude towards Nole before and after. nuff said!

- - what constitutes unnecessary? Almost everyone on tour does these. Plus, a celebration after an opponent's UE isn't a de facto situation of un-necessity. Sometimes, especially when you start to have doubts about a particular point, while you are playing that said point, an opponent's UE will feel like a godsend.

so you think fistpumpimg like a pig in a second game of first set of a masters series
is understandable

from a member of a board that nitpicks over whether the latest BLX paintjob is nice or not, this is rich.

huh?


Anyway, his complaints were pretty specific, and not simply over the fact that it's blue.

specific in the matter that "it favours the other and is not good to me". very nice gesture... the best guy on tour!!!

- I think he only "whines" about the wear and tear HC does to players' knees, which is true. Doctors even recommend normal people like us to avoid even jogging on cement, so I can't imagine the amount of damage HC does to players' knees.

as does the clay to the ankles. i dont see you nadatards say anything about it! tit for tat

Plus, it is true that HC is overrepresented amongst the surfaces, at least to my knowledge. Bring more grass.

agree.

gives death glares across the net when he gets owned - I don't think they're death glares, because he always has a serious look throughout proper matches. However since it's not like I asked Rafa about said 'death glares' but neither have you, I think we ought to agree to disagree on this point.[/b]

ok

- and Federer does?

stick to the topic.


- actually, all of them do, though Rafa seems to have more, er, 'creativity' in this department than does anybody else. Plus, casual labelling of 'OCD' is not a black/white affair. My friends still think I'm OCD because I add lead tape to my racquet, and want a second racquet with the exact same specs.

your friend thinks you have ocd for having matching gear? he nees to study about psychology.

- - and what, Djokovic has only his neighbourhood block in Serbia supporting him? Last time I checked, the guy may as well become head of state after he retires. Besides, if you find this aspect annoying, you ought to really hate Murray, since at least Rafa lives up to his hype in terms of results.

wake me up when you have chokers to the caliber of Dasco and Gordo....

-. for evidence see op and my sig. - b_tching = complaining continuously, spitefully. Guess which group happens to do just this the most?
....

yes. that is why there are two threads with nadal fans requesting a "little more love for my poster boy"

-.
  1. Djokovic shares many of the criticisms you have mentioned, yet it's only Rafa who gets hated for them.
  2. Rafa leads the H2H with Federer, beating Federer summarily; has denied Federer numerous slams, almost all of them in finals
  3. Djokovic trails the H2H with Federer
  4. Djokovic has been summarily beating Rafa in the past year, but has major trouble beating, or gets beaten by Federer
  5. *******s gleefully rub in Rafa's losses to Djokovic, making statements along the lines of "now you know what it feels like"
  6. The above said commonly-shared experience is the experience of a favourite player being defeated routinely at finals, denying said favourite player of the title
  7. Given the aforementioned, it seems highly unlikely that the unequal treatment of these two players is purely bad luck or coincidence, but rather due to the fact that Djokovic is like Federer's vengeance personified; the fact that Djokovic also scrapes wins over Federer gives *******s hope, unlike Rafa who as far as *******s are concerned is a foregone conclusion
  8. Since it appears that *******s and/or Fed fans (who I believe to make up a large part if not the majority of this forum's members) hate Rafa primarily, if not solely, on the basis that Rafa defeats Federer convincingly (and therefore without even a shred of hope that Fed can prevail in the future), I think lists like the above are in fact an afterthought, compiled only to convince themselves and others that their hatred of the "topspin monkey" is in fact rational.
  9. However, it is clear from the application of such reasons (i.e. players who share many or most of the complaints ought to be similarly-hated, yet are not, especially if they appear to beat Rafa convincingly with regularity), that these complaints as justifications for the Rafa hate does not actually hold water.
  10. Therefore, the general hatred of Rafa on this forum is simple: because a) he has a leading H2H against Federer, which were b) amassed at crucial meetings, i.e. at slam finals, thereby denying Federer any more slams.
  11. That said, it is not wrong to hate Rafa, nor is it unusual. All I am saying is that these self-proclaimed 'rational' Fed fans who hate Rafa are anything but rational, let alone unbiased. Rational people are consistent, but aside a few exceptions, most of them are anything but so in their application of the numerous, shared and common factors that, apparently, cause them to hate only Rafa.

with that said, i am not a Federer Fan and Djokovic is not even my favourite!!! so there goes your theory!!! most of my favouritie playes are not even top 10!
 

Crisstti

Legend
I'm talking about when he's up against a complete nobody (or someone who has never won a set off of him) and he implies that there is no way he can win.

Considering the thing he does with his water bottles, it's obviously an attempt at anti-jinxing ("If I say I will win, I will lose, no? So....I say I will lose."). I find that incredibly annoying. Of course it's going to be tough but to give the distinct impression that you're going to lose? If he feels that way then it's time to stand aside and let someone else take over.

You're wellcome to post quotes. He says things like "I have to play my best to have chances", which isn't implying there's no way he can win. He never calls such players the favourites either. I don't think he does that for anyone other than Fed or Novak.

Oh of course he is a a candidate for hate: he is rich, successful, very attractive, worshipped the world over and a hell of a nice guy. I mean what more do you want!

Yeah, that too.

The fact that the aforementioned criticisms apply to plenty of other players (Djokovic in particular), the fact that they are not mentioned while Rafa gets burnt alive tells you something. Expanding on this;

  1. Djokovic shares many of the criticisms you have mentioned, yet it's only Rafa who gets hated for them.
  2. Rafa leads the H2H with Federer, beating Federer summarily; has denied Federer numerous slams, almost all of them in finals
  3. Djokovic trails the H2H with Federer
  4. Djokovic has been summarily beating Rafa in the past year, but has major trouble beating, or gets beaten by Federer
  5. *******s gleefully rub in Rafa's losses to Djokovic, making statements along the lines of "now you know what it feels like"
  6. The above said commonly-shared experience is the experience of a favourite player being defeated routinely at finals, denying said favourite player of the title
  7. Given the aforementioned, it seems highly unlikely that the unequal treatment of these two players is purely bad luck or coincidence, but rather due to the fact that Djokovic is like Federer's vengeance personified; the fact that Djokovic also scrapes wins over Federer gives *******s hope, unlike Rafa who as far as *******s are concerned is a foregone conclusion
  8. Since it appears that *******s and/or Fed fans (who I believe to make up a large part if not the majority of this forum's members) hate Rafa primarily, if not solely, on the basis that Rafa defeats Federer convincingly (and therefore without even a shred of hope that Fed can prevail in the future), I think lists like the above are in fact an afterthought, compiled only to convince themselves and others that their hatred of the "topspin monkey" is in fact rational.
  9. However, it is clear from the poor, if not nonexistent application of such reasons (i.e. players who share many or most of the complaints ought to be similarly-hated, yet are not, especially if they appear to beat Rafa convincingly with regularity), that these complaints as justifications for the Rafa hate does not actually hold water.
  10. Therefore, the general hatred of Rafa on this forum is simple: because a) he has a leading H2H against Federer, which were b) amassed at crucial meetings, i.e. at slam finals, thereby denying Federer any more slams.
  11. That said, it is not wrong to hate Rafa, nor is it unusual. Finding his game ugly or boring is a matter of taste, and since a player's game is unique to that player, this does allow for people to hate or dislike on a specific player and not others. What I am saying however is that these self-proclaimed 'rational' Fed fans who hate Rafa are anything but rational, let alone unbiased. Rational people don't bring up every possible criticism at any opportunity or mention of that person. Rational people are consistent and do make reasonable concessions, but aside from a few exceptions, most people who hate Rafa are anything but so in their application of the numerous, shared and common factors that, apparently, cause them to hate Rafa only.
Now I'm going to test my own patience by not responding to the inevitable drivel labelled as counterarguments by some of the biggest idiots on this board, and responding only to those ones that actually make valid points.

I commend you for having the patience to go though that in such detail :). I don't think I can be bothered any more.
 
Top