How should Fed play in the final?

icedevil0289

G.O.A.T.
are you sure ? how fast Is the court then ? ALL the players this year are saying this is reallyreally fast and that is why serve and volleyers are doing so well
i don't recall the players saying the courts are really really fast, just that they are faster then they have been in a while. let's not exaggerate.
 

ultradr

Legend
Federer might be tempted to use relatively conservative baseline game. because Nadal's ground game doesn't exactly look like in good form right now...
should he do that?
 

Krish872007

Talk Tennis Guru
Federer might be tempted to use relatively conservative baseline game. because Nadal's ground game doesn't exactly look like in good form right now...
should he do that?

That would be a recipe for disaster. Rafa's baseline form is still perfectly ok
 

junior74

Talk Tennis Guru
5 dirty tricks for Fed:

1) Line up the water bottles
2) Towel when Nadal is ready to serve
3) Grunt
4) Play moonballs to Nadal´s backhand
5) Shout come on! and fist pump every time Nadal makes a mistake

Strange how bizarre it seems when you turn it around, eh? :eek:

May the best man win!
 

ABCD

Hall of Fame
Federer should take advantage of Nadal's weak forehand. He should attack Nadal's forehand with his backhand as much as possible. This is a recipe for success.
 

tennisaddict

Bionic Poster
5 dirty tricks for Fed:

1) Line up the water bottles
2) Towel when Nadal is ready to serve
3) Grunt
4) Play moonballs to Nadal´s backhand
5) Shout come on! and fist pump every time Nadal makes a mistake

Strange how bizarre it seems when you turn it around, eh? :eek:

May the best man win!

6. Take 28 seconds between serves
7. Alternate picking rear and touching nose
8. Look at the coaching box for signals
9. Adjust non existing hair around both ears
10. Take MTO if down by 2 sets
11. Yell Vamos when Nadal serves a DF
j/k
 

gino

Legend
"Tactical or strategic support" is not something that I, a random 4.0 player, can offer the GOAT!

That said, I think agree with most of the posters above. The problem is that matches between these two almost always are played on Rafa's terms. He doesn't let Fed play his game, and that's why the H2H is so horribly lopsided.
Fed doesn't possess the BH to handle the Nadal forehand the way that Djokovic can.

The keys to beating Nadal:
1) Serve like a god (like Rosol did)
2) Return like a god (like Djokovic always does)
3) Demonstrate superb mental toughness (like Dimitrov admirably did in his uphill yet unsuccessful battle last night)

Fed, I fear, is really only capable of one of those against Nadal.

You don't need to be on the tour to analyze the game. A great resource to make an argument for either side:

http://www.atpworldtour.com/en/news/federer-net-attack-brain-game-basel-2015-final

https://www.nytimes.com/2014/01/25/sports/tennis/breaking-it-down-nadal-vs-federer.html?_r=0
 
Alright, armchair critics, have your say.

We all know Fed is a massive underdog vs. Rafa in a slam final at the AO. Nevertheless, what kind of tactics would give Fed the greatest chance of success come Sunday and why?
Be specific and the floor is yours.

Fed has tried to serve and volley against Nadal before. He came to the net a lot in Rome of 06 and just failed.He has tried to be agressive and Paris '11 did so but failed to win again.

To me the key is where Nadal is standing on the serve. Against Raonic and Dimitrov on their first serves he was metres behind the baseline. Surely you must serve and volley when he is that far back!
 

Terry Tibbs

Hall of Fame
Alright, armchair critics, have your say.

We all know Fed is a massive underdog vs. Rafa in a slam final at the AO. Nevertheless, what kind of tactics would give Fed the greatest chance of success come Sunday and why?
Be specific and the floor is yours.

Federer a massive underdog? The bookies have this as very close. Current odds on betfair are Nadal 1.75 Fed 2.1.
 

Chanwan

G.O.A.T.
Fed has tried to serve and volley against Nadal before. He came to the net a lot in Rome of 06 and just failed.He has tried to be agressive and Paris '11 did so but failed to win again.

To me the key is where Nadal is standing on the serve. Against Raonic and Dimitrov on their first serves he was metres behind the baseline. Surely you must serve and volley when he is that far back!
To me, the key is to come to the net whenever possible. Not behind every serve, but probably once or so every service game.
Including some chip and charge and SABR's and some of those returns he hit so well vs. Nishikori and Mischa.

Federer a massive underdog? The bookies have this as very close. Current odds on betfair are Nadal 1.75 Fed 2.1.
I'm aware of that. Can't quite explain it - fear of fatique? (rolfmao)
But there seems to be a consensus here among Fed fans, Rafa fans, Djoko fans and neutrals that Rafa is the heavy favorite.
He's up 3-0 and 9-3 in sets on this very court and beat him in straights here a mere 3 years ago. Plus there's the uncertainty of Fed's leg issue and how he moved and timed his groundies in the semi.

All in all, regardless of the bookies, I maintain that Rafa is the heavy favorite.
Feel free to disagree, of course.
 

BGod

G.O.A.T.
What I saw from Dimitrov is he didn't play aggressive enough on a consistent basis. Too content with baseline back and forth at times when he wasn't feeling the pressure. That retention is a killer because you know Nadal wins the long points. Federer's net play is fantastic, he has to use it as much as possible.
 

Terry Tibbs

Hall of Fame
The bookies don't
To me, the key is to come to the net whenever possible. Not behind every serve, but probably once or so every service game.
Including some chip and charge and SABR's and some of those returns he hit so well vs. Nishikori and Mischa.


I'm aware of that. Can't quite explain it - fear of fatique? (rolfmao)
But there seems to be a consensus here among Fed fans, Rafa fans, Djoko fans and neutrals that Rafa is the heavy favorite.
He's up 3-0 and 9-3 in sets on this very court and beat him in straights here a mere 3 years ago. Plus there's the uncertainty of Fed's leg issue and how he moved and timed his groundies in the semi.

All in all, regardless of the bookies, I maintain that Rafa is the heavy favorite.
Feel free to disagree, of course.

It doesn't really matter what the consensus on here is in terms of the real chances of both players. The bookies don't get things wrong and they have this as a close match. And in any case, judging by the match result poll on the match result thread, the predictions are very close.
 

sarmpas

Hall of Fame
I'm a fed fan but I just watched the Nad-Dimi highlights on utube and it played just like an old Nadal highlights tape. The brutality and intensity is back.
 

trenzterra

Semi-Pro
Federer has to pull the trigger more often... Yesterday Dimitrov was content to rally more often than not.

And I guess mix it up with backhand slices every now and then, especially to Nadal's backhand side?

I dunno... I think Federer's biggest problem with Nadal (and later with Djokovic) in the past, apart from the topspin BH, was that he always got to that one extra ball. In that respect, Nadal seems slower now, and is less likely to pull a loopy winner or passing shot from out of position, and doesn't seem to hold serve as comfortably as before.

Of course, given their lopsided history, I don't have high hopes for Fed... but hope he can somehow eke this one out.
 

Chanwan

G.O.A.T.
The bookies don't


It doesn't really matter what the consensus on here is in terms of the real chances of both players. The bookies don't get things wrong and they have this as a close match. And in any case, judging by the match result poll on the match result thread, the predictions are very close.
People predict with their hearts and a lot bet with their hearts as well. Bookies were completely off about both Brexit and the US election. And bookies have been wrong numerous times in earlier Fedal meetings as well.

either way, they still have to play it.
 

WhiskeyEE

G.O.A.T.
Betting odds don't mean anything. Nadal wins most of the matches with Federer when the betting odds are close.
 

tennisaddict

Bionic Poster
While Dmitrov may have better baseline game than Fed as at this time , I noticed several areas where Fed will have better success against Rafa as compared to Dmitrov - Serves, net points , closing out OH, angled BH returns , slice - Fed has so much more variety .

It is not a like for like comparison , burn Rafa showed he will be a handful at the baseline and can run around for a long time like in the past
 

mandy01

G.O.A.T.
god i hope federer keeps his tears in check
Don't think he'll cry. He knows his chances this time whereas in 2009 he lost despite winning more overall points and played really well off the ground. His first priority should be to protect his body and build on his ranking boost from hereon.
 

tata

Hall of Fame
He's gota go hard into the nadal forehand. That backhand is rock solid and won't break. Nadal forehand is what does the damage but it's also the wing that he misses more. When closing at net he needs to hit off to the side of the court rather deep in the court. Play some short balls to lure nadal in and pass him. He's got a go after that backhand return and force himself to go dtl when the opportunity arises.
 

tata

Hall of Fame
What'd also killing fed these days is his mid match concentration lapses where he forgets and doesn't know what he's doing. He was lucky to get away with it against stan.
 

PrinceMoron

Legend
If he's really going to play that final he should play for Rod Laver. And no, not the "Holy ****! Rod came to watch me again!" style. The " Yes, imma do it for you Rod." style. I mean seriously, the ol' man roots for Roger. It's a little too obvious. I think he watched nearly all of Roger's matches this tournament. And Ken Rosewall. Apparently the guy sent him a letter wishing him well for the AO at the start. Do it for those two.

Rosewall writes every AO


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Top