Phoenix1983
G.O.A.T.
I didn't say his claim to be GOAT. I said his claim to be "undisputed" GOAT. That is, there was a time when the received wisdom was that he was miles ahead of anyone else. I don't think that that claim can seriously be made today absent all the discrediting of Nadal and Djokovic's achievements. Federer is indeed still slightly ahead in those three categories, but the difference is only slight in all three and not large in any of them. Federer is one Slam title ahead, 30 weeks ahead (but his lead is going to go down to 28 and very likely to continue going down), and one YEC ahead. I think he still has a decent chance of holding on to the YEC record, but that's probably the least important of the three you listed. As for the first two, it's almost certain that Nadal will end up at least tying the Slam record, and Djokovic has a very good chance of breaking the weeks at #1 record. And even if they don't break those records, they have already rendered Federer's lead so small that he can't be considered far ahead, as he used to be. In this sense, my previous post was along the lines of some posts that @GabeT has posted before.
Reasonable post.