@mike danny
2004 vs 2015
2004 AO vs 2015 AO : Safin, Federer, Agassi,Hewitt, Nalbandian, Roddick,Ferrero >> Djokovic, Murray, Wawrinka, Berdych
2004 FO vs 2015 FO : Gaudio, Coria, Nalbandian, Kuerten, Moya, Henman, Federer somewhere b/w < and << Wawrinka, Djokovic, Murray, Tsonga, Federer,Nadal, Nishi
both with good depth atleast, final obviously clearly swings it in favour of 2015 FO
2004 Wim vs 2015 Wim: Federer, Roddick, Ancic, Hewitt, Henman, Grosjean > Djokovic, Federer, Murray, Anderson, Cilic, Gasquet
2004 Fed > 2015 Djokovic
2004 Roddick > 2015 Fed
Hewitt ~ Murray (below par 3rd set from hewitt, but played an exceptional TB to get the 2nd set)
Ancic ~ Anderson (maybe being a bit generous here)
Grosjean ~ Gasquet
Henman ~ Cilic
For Gasquet-Stan in Wim 15, you had Hewitt Moya in Wim 04.
2004 USO vs 2015 USO: Federer, Agassi, Hewitt, Henman, Roddick, Johansson >> Djokovic, Federer, Stan, Cilic, Lopez, Tsonga
2004 Fed > 2015 Djokovic
2004 Agassi > 2015 Fed
2004 Hewitt > 2015 Stan
2004 Roddick > 2015 Lopez
2004 Johansson > 2015 Cilic (thanks to Cilic injury)
2004 Henman < 2015 Tsonga (Edited: Henman played fine in the semi, but struggled in the earlier rounds more than Tsonga did clearly)
So 2 slams in 2004 considerably better than in 2015, one better in 2004 and one significantly better in 2015
2004 YEC vs 2015 YEC : Federer, Hewitt, Safin, Roddick > Djokovic, Federer, Stan, Nadal
Federer > Djokovic
Hewitt ~ Federer
Safin > Stan
Roddick ~ Nadal
--------------
early HC season minus AO : about even
IW 04 had fed, agassi, henman, roddick
IW 15 had djoko, fed, , raonic, murray
fed-agassi in 04 > djokovic-fed in 15 (individually as well)
Henman/Roddick > Raonic in IW 15 and >> 15 Murray
IW 04 somewhere b/w > and >> IW 15
Miami 04 : Roddick beat Moya in QF, Coria beat Gonzo in SF.
Miami 15 : djokovic struggled earlier, barely escaping vs dolgo, then played well in the later matches.
murray played better than in IW clearly, but still nothing great.
nothing else noteworthy
Miami 15 somewhere b/w > and >> Miami 04
Clay season minus RG: 15 better
Monte Carlo 2004 < Monte Carlo 2015: Coria, Safin, Nalby, Moya in 2004 < Djokovic, Berdych, nadal, Ferrer
Rome 2004 << Rome 2015: Moya, nalby, Costa in 2004 << Djokovic,Federer, Stan, Ferrer (crap final from nalby)
Hamburg 2004 >> Madrid 2015
Federer came through a draw of Gaudio, Gonzalez, Moya, Hewitt to get to the final. Final was a good one unlike 15 where Nadal was cra*p.
North America HC season minus USO : 2004 ~ 2015
Canada 04 > Canada 15
djokovic barely escaped vs gulbis, got beat by murray playing well
Roddick came through to the final easily and Fed beat him convincingly.
Fed had 2 Tbs vs Mirnyi (big server) and an entertaining shotmaking match vs arazi in 1st round, lost 1st set vs Johansson
fed of canada 04 > murray of canada 15
roddick of canada 04 ~ djoko of canada 04
Cincy 05 < Cincy 15
Agassi of Cincy 04 < fed of cincy 15
roddick, hewitt in 05; djokovic murray in 05
Indoor season minus YEC : about even
madrid 04 had safin in peak form only slightly lesser than djokovic in shanghai 15
also had agassi clearly better than anyone Djokovic faced in shanghai 15.
paris 04 safin ~ paris 15 djokovic
hewitt in paris 04 ~ Stan in Paris 15
So to sum it up , IMO :
2004 AO >> 2015 AO
2004 RG b/w < and << 2015 RG
2004 Wim > 2015 Wim
2004 USO >> 2015 USO
2004 YEC > 2015 YEC
early HC season minus AO : 2004 ~ 2015
clay season minus RG : 2004 < 2015
North America HC season minus USO : 2004 ~ 2015
Indoor season minus YEC : 2004 ~ 2015
2004 significantly better in slams
2004 better at the YEC
the non major events in 15 is a little better than 2004 (thanks to clay season)