Kana Himezaki said:The eastern backhand does NOT promote flatness, period. That has definitely been proven. If it did promote flatness, would you use it on serves for spin? People move their grips up from continental on different levels for more extreme grips, which mean more spin and raised contact zones. EB is no exception.
Kana, please. What works for some people may not work for others. So you like the continental slice backhand? Well, I like the eastern. So what? Some people do it your way and some people do it my way, but that doesn't mean you're right about the eastern backhand grip being a bad grip to learn slices with. Eastern backhand works just fine and until it's proven that it's the wrong grip for slices, I'll keep doing it.Kana Himezaki said:You didn't read. This is not about topspin. I also said that it can easily be used for slice backhands. But as said in the original post, it's not the best grip for learning the swing path. More extreme grips naturally come with more brushing around, and people get caught up in the spin they see and eventually forget about driving through altogether.
Kana Himezaki said:You didn't read. This is not about topspin. I also said that it can easily be used for slice backhands. But as said in the original post, it's not the best grip for learning the swing path.
More extreme grips naturally come with more brushing around, and people get caught up in the spin they see and eventually forget about driving through altogether.
Kana Himezaki said:TwistServe, or "TS" as you prefer, hush yourself. The eastern backhand, no question, promotes more spin in general. It also promotes less drive.
It would not work on your forehand. Because when used there...it's not an extreme grip. You'd have to move up to an eastern forehand grip. More spin than your continental, right?
Come on? Please, the eastern backhand produces a ball much less "flat".
Kana Himezaki said:The eastern backhand...promotes less drive.
Come on? Please, the eastern backhand produces a ball much less "flat".
Bungalo Bill said:BING BING BING! NOT TRUE! Racquet face is FLATTER to the ball and with a straighter swing path it produces....drum roll please....A FLATTER BALL!!!!!!!
Kana Himezaki said:Bill, whatever. I see no point in continuing this argument, and you can check for yourself on whatever later. I'm not about to give up my position, and I'm sure you aren't either.
Kana Himezaki said:You think the ball is flatter on slices? Don't kid me. I'm sure even BB, where it's already been shown I disagree with on this issue, can point this out here.
More extreme grips, defined as how slanted the racquet is, enable more spin, whether on the backhand or forehand side.
TwistServe said:Wow really BB!! Someone sure thinks the eastern grip promotes more underspin.. HAHAH how can this be.. does the laws of physics lie??? it can.. no no it cant lie
Becky said:I agree with you on your points, but it's pretty strange to "laugh" so hard because someone said a grip does something different.
It seems like everyone is intent on making the end of this argument as ugly as possible. God, do it with grace, at least. Otherwise you're opening yourself up to more attacks as well. In Kana's hostile (or supposedly and seemingly unintentional) arguments, everybody has taken it upon themselves to become just as.
Kana, you're wrong. BB, I thought you sounded fine, professional, and correct up until near the end. :/
Kana Himezaki said:And by the way, I was going to edit the last post, but TwistServe, it's awfully hard to tell someone they're embarassing themselves when you can't back up what you're saying without someone else, and try to add in random facts to appear as a knowledgeable poster.
Kaptain Karl said:If you ever see some clips of Goolagong's Slice BH, you'll see poetry in motion. I know what you mean about beauty....
On my own Slice BH drive, my shoulder turn is so extreme I almost have my back to my target ... then (my playing partners tell me) my follow through is spread-eagled. (They say I look like I'm "playing airplane" on my follow through. Hopefully, they are being honest when the tell me "No. It doesn't help us to know a Drive Slice is coming." Apparently they cannot decipher direction or depth ... until it's too late. ...At least, that's what they *tell me.*)
But I'm not sure you and I spread-eagle at the same parts of our strokes...?
- KK
TwistServe said:Because I've been through arguments with kana so many times.. she never budges its funny.. i think she actually thinks shes right.. being self taught and all she must have a great perspective on the game.. otherwise she wouldnt be able to make statements just because from her personal experience it didnt work out..
The laws of physics do not lie.
Return_Ace said:uhhh...........what she said, she got across what i was trying to say............using more words albeit but i'm sure you understand her better.
and being self-taught makes you work out problems on your own, it makes you think.
yep. twistserve IS the reason she left. twistserve makes degrading comments everytime he corrects someone.Becky said:edit- TwistServe, as of the last post, you should probably just be quiet. As I said, it seems you're just searching for anything, anything at all to incriminate Kana. You're right. Leave. What's the point of rubbing it in so much, you're not getting anything at all from it.
The more things change, the more they stay the same.Bungalo Bill said:I no longer want to destroy people with personal attacks. I saw the ugliness of the thread and it goes nowhere and is so meaningless that it is something I no longer want to participate in. I think it is useless, highly unprofessional, and I apoligize to you for any rude and personal remarks I made to you. I want to change and I am going to. It is time for me to grow-up in this area as I am realizing I might be back out on the courts again teaching and want people to believe I have an honest character and try hard ot help someone.
There is already much hate and anger in this world that I no longer want to be a part of it. I am going back to church and realizing the stupid things I did in the past and think it is trash. It is not good for me nor my family and I want to teach my children to be good people. But I have to set the example in all that I do.
nViATi said:yep. twistserve IS the reason she left. twistserve makes degrading comments everytime he corrects someone.
Valid criticism. No one can claim to be perfect in their tennis knowledge. However, I don't think this thread should have gone the route of personal attacks.Bungalo Bill said:Kana, you are not "wrong" in posting this article. What I didnt care for was the slight "racial" comments and your opening statements which made the article "trashy". You had good information in there but you made it sound liike it was written law. That is where I had the problems. I know others have posted their concerns and you should listen to that.
Like I said before, I admire your attempt and some of the information was very good. The article had a lot of holes in it.
You are so foul! Oh well, that's my boy, TwistServe.TwistServe said:Not true.. only to kana
Rickson said:You are so foul! Oh well, that's my boy, TwistServe.
patheticTwistServe said:You are right. I am a foul... I missed kana's post so much that when she finally posted again, I jumped the gun and got personal very fast.. oh the memories ;(
Phil said:Twist Serve - Granted, after admittedly having just three years of tennis playing experience, Kana's "articles" sometimes lack that necessary expereience factor, I'm not sure this is the reason you refuse to leave her alone. You aren't exactly a font of tennis knowledge yourself-but you're great at chiming in where BB diplomatically corrects Kana's misinformation (and though I'm not exactly BB's buddy, it's clear to me that he WAS trying to be diplomatic and helpful, as much as he could until he lost patience). Are you stalking her? Really, what is your agenda here? Is it because, failing to come up with anything negative to say about Federer, having been proved so wrong on everything you ever wrote about him, you need a "subsititute" demon to bait? I mean, WTF is it with you, spanky?
TwistServe said:Actually Phil, I argue with anything that lacks the "necessary expereience(sic) factor".. you've probably seen me argue with PhilD, Meat, and others.. Kana comes up with inconsistent statements and incorrect tips too often and as a result it may seem like I dish out too much to her.. Review my other debates.. i've argued with many other posters when I feel they need to be corrected.. other people dont make it personal, and so i dont .. when it gets ugly it gets ugly..
Phil said:So, why not cut some people a little slack-even I do THAT.
TwistServe said:I was wondering why you were cutting me some slack before.. guessed you were just a nice guy..
mucat said:kana, I read most of your posts and they are mostly correct. But this time, you have to listen to BB. Eastern BH does NOT produce more spin than continental BH grip in general. If you try to swing around with both grips and you will know the answer. Eastern BH only produce more spin on serve compare to continental. I would know because I used to hit with continental slice exclusively on my BH but now I change to eastern bh for slice, flat and topspin.
Phil said:But you seem to hold your own, for better or worse. Lucky for me and you that you're such a popular guy.
akj27 said:at this point, it's obvious that becky is kana, just read her posts in this thread, especially the one when she talks about reading tennisplayers.net and about how kana is right LOL.
Becky said:I know I said I was leaving in the other thread, and plan on doing the same thing.
But really, I still don't understand. Because I'm a similar age, and agreed with some of the same information, I'm incriminated. Everyone in this thread agreed with most of the information. BB did. Even TwistServe is. The point is, some of the last things she said were wrong, which I agreed on.
What's the problem?