You must experiment enough before you can determine what's best. More importantly, just make sure you get your 2nd serve in without worrying about velocity.I am a 3.5 player, a play only once a week. I always have toss problems, I am glad if my toss is consistent.
Schould I have different toss for first and second serve? I feel this would mess up my tosses.
Thank your answer
Toth
When learning your different serves, absolutely toss differently (locations over your head) for flat, slice, top/kick... once you master it that way, you can refine your toss and body mechanics to try hitting all three with the same toss... but honestly by the time you get to that point, you'll be a 5.0+, and will be able to distinguish if you need to or not.I am a 3.5 player, a play only once a week. I always have toss problems, I am glad if my toss is consistent.
Schould I have different toss for first and second serve? I feel this would mess up my tosses.
Thank your answer
Toth
I am a 3.5 player, a play only once a week. I always have toss problems, I am glad if my toss is consistent.
Schould I have different toss for first and second serve? I feel this would mess up my tosses.
Thank your answer
Toth
Becouse i know different tosses would be correct but I have difficulties with it.Honestly I think the answer depends on how you serve (or how you're trying to serve).
Why are you asking about different tosses? Is it because you're trying for different types of serves, have you heard conflicting advice, or something else?
Big difficulties.Becouse i know different tosses would be correct but I have difficulties with it.
probably ok with topspin (agree, avoid the kicker - but then again if you can hit top, the kicker is a few inches away)...Ideally, a high-level player wants one toss for flat first serves hard to the right hand side of the box, body serves, and slice first serves to the left hand side of the box. Then one different toss for all second serves -- where it goes would depend on what kind of second serve you hit. So two tosses in total. I recommend avoiding kick serves entirely and focusing on slices, but at least avoid kickers until about 4.5. If you don't have really dialed in serve mechanics, a kick serve is worse than useless, just giving your opponent a sitter to start the point off.
Becouse i know different tosses would be correct but I have difficulties with it.
note about practicing your toss at home...I often encourage the kids I work with (adults, too) to practice and experiment with their toss at home -
shouldn't be too big a deal. mainly its just about tossing it a bit more in front if you want to go big or just a few inches back for a kicker. Most serves should just be your std topslice with a very std toss.Becouse i know different tosses would be correct but I have difficulties with it.
I am a 3.5 player, a play only once a week. I always have toss problems, I am glad if my toss is consistent.
Schould I have different toss for first and second serve? I feel this would mess up my tosses.
Thank your answer
Toth
... In general, you want to release the ball around the shoulder height. Want to avoid "palming" the ball. Personally, I find it helpful to keep my head up and look at the spot I want to place the ball in the air. Some people like to trace the ball with their eyes...
Minor toss adjustment: about 10 cm?I tend to believe that it's best to make your toss diferences in a minor way rather than a huge difference. I don't think making a large change from a flat to say a slice all that necessary because your main objective is to have a reliable serve. Even with the kick, if you change it too much you will get to the point where it won't be effective anyway. Think about it this way, say you want to do a kicker and you decide to put the ball way over your left and behind you then sure you will get more kick, but it will be slower and your body will be stressed more and possibly cause problems. Lot of people misunderstand matters with the kick serve. A slow but lateral moving kick serve will be easy meet for your opponent. A tougher kick serve to return is one that moves less laterally but fizzes more and rises quickly up at your opponent and you don't need to alter your ball toss as much to achieve this result, just a little bit of an adjustment is sufficient.
Minor toss adjustment: about 10 cm?I tend to believe that it's best to make your toss diferences in a minor way rather than a huge difference. I don't think making a large change from a flat to say a slice all that necessary because your main objective is to have a reliable serve. Even with the kick, if you change it too much you will get to the point where it won't be effective anyway. Think about it this way, say you want to do a kicker and you decide to put the ball way over your left and behind you then sure you will get more kick, but it will be slower and your body will be stressed more and possibly cause problems. Lot of people misunderstand matters with the kick serve. A slow but lateral moving kick serve will be easy meet for your opponent. A tougher kick serve to return is one that moves less laterally but fizzes more and rises quickly up at your opponent and you don't need to alter your ball toss as much to achieve this result, just a little bit of an adjustment is sufficient.
Depends how tall you are and arm span, but the less you need to vary it the better, so I'll go 10cm. You will also have the benefit of being able to hide your intentions better giving your opponents less of a chance to read your serve.Minor toss adjustment: about 10 cm?
Or 20?
Of course first serve
Minor toss adjustment: about 10 cm?
More?
Less?
Here's my thought: At 3.5 with admittedly big issues with your toss, it's good to understand that over time, adjusting your tosses for different serves will be a good addition.
Sounds to me like right now, you should focus on toss mechanics to get one consistent toss. When you get to a point that you feel your toss is something you can count on most of the time and are comfortable with it, then consider changing your toss for different serves. If you feel your toss is wildly inconsistent and you can't trust it for either serve, I don't think working on a few different tosses will do you any good, it may only delay you putting the basics in place to be able to count on your toss. No need to get ahead of yourself. Master one skill then add on to it after.
I can see your point and an in person assessment would really help dictate the first steps a player needs to take. Maybe that would have been a better response. Op - if you have the means and option for a lesson from a teaching pro. It may be worth your time to get an in person diagnosis and tips.Note that many 3.0 and 3.5 players do not have particularly good control of their toss. Have even seen this with some 4.0 players. Some of these players will hit different types of of serves -- dictated by their erratic or unpredictable toss placement. Not an ideal situation. Better to have the toss placement dictated by the type of serve you wish to hit instead.
Good idea to work on developing 1 or 2 consistent toss placements. However, I have no problem with hitting different types of serve, within reason, for a variable/unpredictable toss placement. But the server should identify a range of suitable toss placements. If the toss is wild and outside of this "suitable" range, they should not attempt to hit the toss.
I can see your point and an in person assessment would really help dictate the first steps a player needs to take. Maybe that would have been a better response. Op - if you have the means and option for a lesson from a teaching pro. It may be worth your time to get an in person diagnosis and tips.
I still ride the philosophy that you work on one serve and toss until there is a reasonable consistency. Chasing bad tosses is a surefire way to injury and Imo can be exacerbated by trying to determine serve type on the fly based on where the toss ends up.
I recall some ball toss data from late in 2015 in a match between Federer and Djokovic. This data, along with some (HawkEye?) graphics, was shown during one or more of their meetings that year. I believe that I saw it for either their Cincinnati meeting or their subsequent meeting at the US Open. @WildVolley also recalls seeing it at one of their 2 WTF meetings that year.
That data/graphic showed quite a bit more than variation than 10 cm. I believe that this data was for 1st serves only. It revealed a toss variation for Federer of 19 or 20 cm (I don't recall which). The toss variation for Djokovic was nearly the same -- 18 or 19 cm. I'm not certain if this much variation was intentional or if it was a natural variation. The point is that, if these guys vary their 1st serve toss by nearly 20 cm, is it reasonable to believe that our own variation would be less than 10 cm?
You are standing sideways so behind your head describes tossing the ball to your left and into the court which is correct. For someone just learning a top spin serve the ball should drop on your head or a little bit to the left of your head. As the student advances the toss goes further into the court.
The motion does not determine anything. The toss is a part of the motion. The intended serve determines the motion.
The instruction to "Toss the ball back over you head" is misleading for a high level kick serve.
How should it be worded so that your additional explanation paragraph isn't necessary for the average player?
@drdoctormd
Chas, you need to keep in mind that the head is not in the same place when you start the serve (and as you release the ball) as when you make contact with the ball. "Toss the ball behind or over your head" is a bit confusing, perhaps even misleading. Does behind your head mean back toward the the back fence or does it mean to the left of your body wrt your position on the baseline? I prefer to indicate that the ball is tossed/lifted to the left using the court as a reference rather than using the orientation of the body as a reference.
The ball is tossed to the left (for a righty) of the original position of the head. However, the head/upper body also moves to the left (and slightly forward) to facilitate the hitting shoulder coming over the top -- for the shoulder over shoulder cartwheel action. At contact, the head of the server is pretty much under the ball.
@drdoctormd
.................... However, the head/upper body also moves to the left (and slightly forward) to facilitate the hitting shoulder coming over the top -- for the shoulder over shoulder cartwheel action. At contact, the head of the server is pretty much under the ball.
The head and upper body move to the right relative to the court in the picture. You meant 'to the right' I guess..
....
In my opinion for strokes, using the ball's trajectory is a better reference for direction than the court lines or the rotating body's right-left.
this tip took me 15y to "discover"@junbumkim
I generally find it better to get my eyes to the expected toss/contact location even before the ball is release. Do not recommend following or tracking the ball trajectory up and down with your eyes. It might work for some but, I believe, that it is better that the head and eyes are a "quiet" was possible when the ball (toss) is released.
No, I mean't to the left. What picture are you referring to? I am using left and right relative to the server's perspective (particularly at contact). This is the same reference used by the following article that discusses differences between 1st and 2nd serve tosses:
http://tennis.about.com/od/serve/ss/same-serve-toss-different-spins.htm
Don't understand. The ball's trajectory with reference to what???
..........................
It is the correct instruction. You always want to make contact as high as you can because you are essentially making yourself taller. The higher you can get the more net clearance and the better the angle to get the ball in. There is zero benefit in letting the ball drop.
Wow. Can't believe I've never seen that article. Gotta be one of the best I've ever seen on the serve. Time to work on my "lean".Are you still referring to the difference between the 1st serve and the 2nd serves tosses? There will be considerably more variation than this as seen in the link in post #5. According to that article, the difference for Sampras was 60+ cm. For Federer, the diff from 1st serve to 2nd serve was more like 90 cm. Similar toss variations are noted with other servers in that article a well.
@Chas Tennis
You still haven't said which picture you are talking about. You seem to be making this more complicated than it needs to be. When I read Jeff Cooper's article (Tennis.About.com), his left-right designation made perfect sense to me (particularly in context). OTOH, your description did not.
Kick serve picture. Head movement and rotation.
I believe that may be the instructor with an excellent kick serve that does not move forward very much for impact. ?
Ideally, a high-level player wants one toss for flat first serves hard to the right hand side of the box, body serves, and slice first serves to the left hand side of the box. Then one different toss for all second serves -- where it goes would depend on what kind of second serve you hit. So two tosses in total. I recommend avoiding kick serves entirely and focusing on slices, but at least avoid kickers until about 4.5. If you don't have really dialed in serve mechanics, a kick serve is worse than useless, just giving your opponent a sitter to start the point off.
From those pics, looks like maybe a generalization could be made that the toss moves to the left and the head moves forward and to the right.Not sure what your last statement/question is trying to say. Who said that elite kick servers do not move forward for a kick serve?
With this view of the server, as well as a rear view of the server, it still makes sense to me to say that the toss moves forward and from the right to the left. Right side of the picture to the left side of the picture. Or the right side of the server's overall position to the left side of the server's position.
As I indicated previously, the server gets his head underneath the toss at impact.
Nothing about that particularly interested me. Just hoping to maybe help clear up what seemed to be a misunderstanding. Seemed one guy was talking about the ball and one about the head, and maybe one talking about looking from the front and one from the back. I'm all about harmony and stuff.What is it about the head that you find so interesting? The head has nothing to do with anything. This is what happens when people over analyze pictures and video. Forget about the head.
You may well be right, but have you looked at this article? http://tennis.about.com/od/serve/ss/same-serve-toss-different-spins.htm#step2I just watched a couple first serves by Pete to see what you mean and his toss is right over the shoulder like everyone else. Who told you that he tosses to the left? There is no advantage to toss more to the left on a flat or slice serve .. It would actually have an adverse effect. For top spin, it's a different story. You have more options you can toss over your head or even over your left shoulder.