I ordered several pairs from TW. I got the New Balance 696V3 in 11 and 11.5, the 806 in 11, the 1006 in 114E(not from TW), the Diadora Speed Blueshield, and the Adidas Barricade 4E(also not from TW).
My foot is a little over 10.5(not quite 11) and a 4E width. I'm also on the heavy side and have problem with my metatarsals, and I tend to run on the balls of my feet moreso than heel to toe, so cushioning and support is important to my feet, especially in the forefoot. I use a Powerstep Pinnacle Plus insole for added arch support, heel cushion, and a metatarsal pad.
My take on these shoes.
Diadora: The lacing was fixed, which I didn't like, and couldn't even fit my foot in there anyway. Way too narrow. Next...
Adidas Barricade: These were a bit tight, but not overly so. I had to really cram my insoles in there, to the point where they may not have been sitting in the shoe properly. They were made of a weird rubbery/plastic material that I did not like and it didn't look like it would be stretching out at all to accommodate any extra width. It also appeared to not be very breathable. Still, they were well cushioned with plenty of support and stiff soled. A good shoe overall, but I can't get past the material and I suspect they would never have enough give to really fit.
NB 696V3. The reviews said to order these in a 1/2 size larger than normal. I ordered 11 and 11.5. The 11.5 was too long and my heel was slipping in them(forward and vertically). Even with heel grips, this wouldn't work. The 11s were a little tight width-wise when I first put them on, but seemed to fit to my feet pretty well with a few hours of wear in my house. I had to squeeze my insoles into the shoes, but not cram, to get them to fit. My heel still slipped vertically in these, but it's because of the raised heel from my insole. The lift was minor and could definitely be resolved with a heel grip. I did not test the shoe without my insole. Even with my insole, I experienced some metatarsal pain when walking in these shoes. There just isn't enough cushioning or support in the forefoot. Otherwise a very good shoe.
NB 806: These were the roomiest shoes, width wise, of the bunch. They were a little tight when first putting them on, but felt really good on my feet after a few hours. They are nice and stiff and have much better forefoot padding than the 696. This shoe also had some heel lifting when walking, but it was minor and due to the insole and can be resolved with a heel grip. They
NB 1006: These shoes were tight width wise but they loosened up some within a few hours of indoor wear and were comfortable enough. They were very light and seemed like they would breathe nicely. The mesh material allowed my feet to move within the shoe comfortably. They did not offer the same support or cushioning as the 806 throughout the shoe, but especially in the forefoot. The tradeoff being support for weight, I guess. This might be a better choice for a lighter player, or one without any foot problems, but for me it wouldn't work.
The NB 806 shoe was a clear winner for me by a wide margin. It's a little heavier than the next closest shoe, but offered everything that is most important to me personally. I'd rank them 806, 696, 1006, Barricade.
