If you read Bill Scanlon's book, he says that McEnroe does the tantrum thing not out of any genuine emotion, but rather he uses it just like he does his serve, to throw his opponents off. McEnroe never seems to throw a temper tantrum when he's winning...
Just food for thought.
Food for thought,
That reminds me of a true story. When I lived in the city, the guy in the condo across from me ( we shared a back terrace ) was the maitre d in the restaurant at a very small, posh private tennis club on the lake. One morning, my neighbor, upon seeing my yellow volkl bag slug over my shoulder made the comment, "I have one of those" which struck me as odd because the guy is an infrequent tennis player and volkl is not a brand you'd find at the local sportmart. When I mentioned my puzlement, he recounted an event that I think is quite revealing.
Johnny Mac was dining in the club lounge, as he was there doing a kids tennis clinic. Apparently the caesar salad Mac ordered was not to his liking. As my Maitre d freind walked by J Mac's table, Mac threw the salad right in his face, with quite a few F bombs as accompanying garnish. The entire dining room fell silent with disbelief, and there is my freind standing in his italian suit, ceaser dressing dripping from his nose, and romaine in his hair, getting cursed at. Mac later sincerely apologized, and part of the apology was the gift of an assortment of volkl bags. When I asked how the kids clinic went, my neighbor said that he is really great with the kids, but management is wise to limit his interaction with adults as much as possible.
I think Mac is one of those players who performs better when he is a little angry. I spent a few years behind a stove in french restaurants, and know there are chefs who really don't get it in gear and start to roll until soemthing happens to pss them off. The emotion is genuine, but the emotion is channeled into elevating performance level. For some people it is what they lean on in times of stress, when the chips are down, when backed into a corner. I think he is somebody who has anger as an element of internal motivation AND somedody who clearly has off the court emotional issues. I think he has both of those things. And I think he knows it, cannot overcome it, and is trying his best to deal with who he is. lord knows that must be a difficult task.
He never, ever, lost his temper when playing Borg, win, lose or draw. Just one more notable piece of the puzzle to the mystery.
-Jack