Can someone be nominated for multiple categories?
Not only does Marius deserve to be in the GOAT, but also in the most helpful category.. have you ever been in the tips/instruction subforum? Sure, he posts a lot of links, and references to his collection of useful threads, but he knows his stuff!
Most helpful/informative: Gamma Tech, we should thank him for frequenting our boards and giving us some insight on the design/engineering aspects of the machines we enjoy!
As for logical and civil, i think they can be considered separate from each other. Sometimes logic is a little against the grain, as I find more and more that although Phil & Deuce (although they might not like being mentioned in the same sentence) have logical posts that I more or less agree with, but they can be a bit abrasive
I think we gotta mention our dark horse posters.
I second Dedans as our funniest poster, he's over the top, and like KK said, you've gotta read his posts a few times before you move on throughout your day, you'll pick up some gems that way
I'm sure there are many, many posters who should be mentioned in the funniest category that i'm missing. My apologies
Most wanted to return: Big guns in the gear category: Michael Ludwig, Thomas Martinez, Gaines Hillix, Grant Morgan et al. I know they do visit every once in a while, but they need to be around more often. When I had just started visiting the board, these guys were around (OK, maybe not Grant) posting very, very interesting insights on pro gear and the "behind-the-scenes" tips, tricks, thoughts etc.