SystemicAnomaly
Bionic Poster
Mary Carillo and P Mac are 2 of my favorites. Are there any voters over the age of 17 that voted for Mary as the worst?
Mary Carillo and P Mac are 2 of my favorites. Are there any voters over the age of 17 that voted for Mary as the worst?
Please move Gimelstob to the top of the list. Loves to hear himself talk and tries to make himself seem like the smartest person in the world.
Oh and who can forget the fact that he has to polish Roddick's knob every chance he can get, even when he's getting beat down.
How about pam shriver? I can't stand that bich. Its funny when she's on with chris evert, they seem like they hate each other
This thread is 8 years old, it needs to be closed and then someone can do a new poll with all the current commentators like Harry Cicma, Brett Haber, Jimmy Arias, both Macs, Shriver, McAtee, Evert, Martina, Mary Jo, Mary C., Justin, Courier, Gilbert, Fowler, Cahill, Koenig, Goodall, Robinson, etc.
All those names, and you left out probably the actual worst one, Andrew Castle.
I rarely hear him since he doesn't work in the US. I know others hear him on streams and such.
I'm not impressed with Cicma, I'll leave it at that. I understand why people dislike Justin, but I guess I'm just used to him since that's pretty much the was he is off camera too (and he's so much better now than when he started in 2007).
JMac drives me crazy because he talks way too much, talks during points, and can turn any match into a story about his matches 3 decades ago. Pat Mac also talks too much.
Gilbert's nicknames are annoying and disrespectful, in my opinion. I like Fowler and Robinson because I think they ask good questions to get the more knowledgeable commentators to add insights. I love Darren Cahill, but its awkward when he calls matches with the players that he works with.
I think Martina is good but she talks over points too much. McAtee does decent interviews, but should not do matches. I like Mary C. and I really like when she works with Justin, they balance each other pretty well.
I love Justin and Leif Shiras together but sometimes they forget they are watching a match and act like brothers joking around in front of the TV. They're pretty close, it shows when they work together.
Who's "winning" this poll so far, surprised J Mac isn't even listed in the poll, he should be the pick here.
Yeah, Brad Gilbert is annoying with the names. It's almost like he's trying to be a cheap impersonator of Chris Berman, but Berman is better at it.
I don't like Leif Shiras very much, and I don't know why.
The problem I have with John McEnroe and Martina and Pam Shriver is that anytime there is a situation dealing with a rule (not a line call), but a rule like medical timeouts, or foot fault rules, or toilet breaks, etc., they just automatically assume that the umpire is wrong (sometimes they are, but usually not), and then they will just give out wrong information, instead of actually checking to see what the rule is first. Half of the time only they correct themselves, and then 14 threads start on here about an incorrect ruling when it was actually correct.
JMac drives me crazy because he talks way too much, talks during points, and can turn any match into a story about his matches 3 decades ago. Pat Mac also talks too much
anytime there is a situation dealing with a rule (not a line call), but a rule like medical timeouts, or foot fault rules, or toilet breaks, etc., they just automatically assume that the umpire is wrong (sometimes they are, but usually not), and then they will just give out wrong information, instead of actually checking to see what the rule is first.
YES! I've nearly broken my TV because of Mac's complete lack of research and understanding about the current rules of the game. And they can get copies of the rulebooks for FREE! They aren't that hard to read, and not really time consuming either.
All those names, and you left out probably the actual worst one, Andrew Castle.
Say what you will about Mary Carillo. She earned my unending respect for standing up to Pam Shriver and Mary Jo Fernandez when both them were whining about unfairly Serena was treated after her US Open tirade, and how they felt so sorry for her. It basically cost Carillo her job at ESPN. I believe this was during the 2010 Australian Open.
Say what you will about Mary Carillo. She earned my unending respect for standing up to Pam Shriver and Mary Jo Fernandez when both them were whining about unfairly Serena was treated after her US Open tirade, and how they felt so sorry for her. It basically cost Carillo her job at ESPN. I believe this was during the 2010 Australian Open.
We can settle this once and for all. Sorry if who you hate isnt on this list but you can write them in. Pesonally I have to say Mal Washington right now because, although he doesnt annoy me as much outright like Carillo or P Mac but he does it more passive-aggressively, by NEVER saying anything interesting or useful, and pointing out only the most painfully obviously things. He wont say anything at all until 45 minutes into the match then its "...break point, Roddick..." and then you dont hear him again until someone misses a short ball from 3 feet behind the net, and then with his amazing insight he will add "...you GOTTA make that..."
Mackay is on there because while sometimes he makes interesting comments, his voice annoys me to death for some reason.
Courier I putting in both polls (best and worst) because he says interesting things and has good insight, but serenading Roddick just doesnt sit well with me.
LOL at Wikipedia on Pam Shriver:
"Shriver has a reputation as one of the worst tennis broadcasters; she has been providing coverage of various events since her 1996 retirement. During Wimbledon 2010, James Blake admonished Shriver for disrupting play with her overly-loud commentary from the box situated above the court behind him. This led to a verbal exchange between the two during the match. USA Today characterized this as an embarrassing and unprofessional performance by Shriver..... She is known for openly criticizing players, her irritating voice, failed attempts at humor, and is personally responsible for ESPN2's drop in ratings during the 2013 Emirates US Open Series."