Did Nadal have a chance to beat Djokovic here ?

MugOpponent

Hall of Fame
Highly unlikely but it's always possible Djokovic loses earlier in the tournament. He's actually been shakier earlier in these slams as of late.
 

The Blond Blur

G.O.A.T.
We’ll never know since it was Joker’s fault for going full Amor y Paz. Never go full Amor y Paz.

Novak-and-Boris-4.jpg
 

roysid

Hall of Fame
Djokovic doesnt lose to AO against a top 100 player. Period

No dehydration, muscle tear can stop him
 
Its all about matchups so probably not. Nadal is just a bad matchup for Med period. While Djoker is a nightmare for Rafa here... especially if nadal is serving like he did today
 

Open Stance

Professional
Medvedev blew Novak off the court and put him in tears the last time they met in a grand slam. Rafa just slapped Med. Therefore, and based on hardened transferable evidence, Rafa would beat Novak.
Not sure if the transitive property applies though. It's often about the match ups. If you look at the current "Big 3" of Djokovic, Medvedev and Nadal, Djokovic seems to match up poorly against Medvedev, Medvedev matches up poorly against Nadal and Nadal often matches up somewhat poorly against Djokovic. The last time Rafa and Novak played at AO, Djokovic destroyed him. I think it would have depended on what form Novak would have been in were he allowed to play. While this was a great win for Rafa, he never really looked great in this tournament so I think an in form Djokovic probably handles him comfortably.
 

kailash

Hall of Fame
It is unfortunate that Djokovic could not play. But as others said, it is hard to predict what would have happened if he has also played.

Many matches were so close; just minor margins and matches could have gone in different ways: Shapo, Felix, Berrettini, Monfils...and Medvedev was so close to finish off in straight sets.
 

DIMI_D

Hall of Fame
No I don’t think he did it’s mental thing, and Novak is the worse match up for Nadal and Novak just feels so confident on RLA vs Rafa
 

GummiiBear

Semi-Pro
I imagine Djokovic would've won.

Then again, I predicted Medvedev would win and that Nadal would have to pull off something a-mazing to win.
If anyone has the sheer grit to win like what we saw last night, it's Nadal. If anyone can prove 'em wrong, it's him.

And, echoing others, we'll never know. 8-B Djokovic "lost" before the tournament began.
 
Not sure if the transitive property applies though. It's often about the match ups. If you look at the current "Big 3" of Djokovic, Medvedev and Nadal, Djokovic seems to match up poorly against Medvedev, Medvedev matches up poorly against Nadal and Nadal often matches up somewhat poorly against Djokovic. The last time Rafa and Novak played at AO, Djokovic destroyed him. I think it would have depended on what form Novak would have been in were he allowed to play. While this was a great win for Rafa, he never really looked great in this tournament so I think an in form Djokovic probably handles him comfortably.
Nadal was fairly dominated by Djokovic in most of the 4 set match they played at rg. It's hard to see him beating Djokovic again looking at that.
Agree about the matchups; wawrinka seems a bad matchup for Djokovic at rg, but Nadal beats wawrinka comfortably there.
 

pj80

Legend
Medvedev blew Novak off the court and put him in tears the last time they met in a grand slam. Rafa just slapped Med. Therefore, and based on hardened transferable evidence, Rafa would beat Novak.
Novak slapped Medvedev a year ago, slapped Rafa on that same court....also slapped Rafa on his favorite court. so who knows what would have happened. We certainly were robbed of a good SF due to politics
 

Rafa24

Hall of Fame
Medvedev blew Novak off the court and put him in tears the last time they met in a grand slam. Rafa just slapped Med. Therefore, and based on hardened transferable evidence, Rafa would beat Novak.
this was what I was going to say. While Novak almost won the calendar slam last year he was far from his best level all season and then Med destroyed him.
 
D

Deleted member 762343

Guest
Yes i think he would have beat Djokovic. Mededev is a better hard court player currently and Djokovic does not have as big a serve as Medvedev or the huge wing span of Medvedev on return.
Rafa has re tooled his game. His return of serve was hugely improved all event

Medvedev blew Novak off the court and put him in tears the last time they met in a grand slam. Rafa just slapped Med. Therefore, and based on hardened transferable evidence, Rafa would beat Novak.

Wow. How can one be so clueless about how tennis works ?
 
D

Deleted member 762343

Guest
“Hardened transferable evidence” wasn’t a big enough clue for you, huh? It was a joke, dummy.

And two other members failing to understand it was a joke wasn't a big enough clue to realize your joke was a fail, huh ? Try to be funnier, dummy.
 

D.Nalby12

G.O.A.T.
Certainly no. If Medvedev almost straight setted him then against Djokovic it could have been worse. Without Djokovic Nadal would have won 2019 AO in very dominant fashion. It would be much more impressive win that this one.
 
D

Deleted member 762343

Guest
A lot of people like that post cuz it’s funny, dummy.

Find someone who can teach you how to make jokes. You fail every time.

Yes, "a lot of people". Literally only two people who happen to be Nadal fans.
 

vex

Legend
We have to ask this question.

They would have faced in the semi finals instead of Berretini.
I dunno. Rafa seemed up and down. But Djokovic has been up and down. That’s what age does to you. He’d beat the Djokovic that showed up to the Wimby final pushing balls and praying for errors. He’d lose to the Djokovic that showed up at the RG SFs
 
T

TheNachoMan

Guest
Novak would have won, but that’s his fault. Not RAFA’s.
 
For me even if somehow Nadal was able to defeat Novak there isn't any chance he'll also defeat Med in the final.We saw how close was the final ,imagine Nadal had to go Shapo 5th setter,Novak /most probably also enduring 5 setter/ and Med.With all my respect he is great champion but i think no chance he'll win it.The relatively easy SF vs Berrettini have impact on the final,not much but enough.
 

abmk

Bionic Poster
I dunno. Rafa seemed up and down. But Djokovic has been up and down. That’s what age does to you. He’d beat the Djokovic that showed up to the Wimby final pushing balls and praying for errors. He’d lose to the Djokovic that showed up at the RG SFs

nah, Djoko in Wim 21 was much better than AO 22 Nadal. even if he wasn't aggressive, serve+return was more than good enough.
But yeah USO 21 DJoko was more vulnerable. especially final was downright mediocre.
 
Top