kraggy
Banned
As others have mentioned, comparing Tendulkar and Federer is somewhat an apples to oranges comparison. I agree that tennis probably requires you to be more athletic than cricket, but by and large most cricketers are pretty athletic themselves (especially fast bowlers and great fielders), it is only few exceptions who are not. And those are the people with ridiculous talent to make up for their lack of fitness ( think Nalbandian equivalent) . Cricket in general requires a tremendous amount of talent and technique! For example if you took Michael Jordan and gave him 5 yrs to learn cricket, there is a good chance he would still suck.
And cricket being a team sport, you would have more than 1 GOAT - you need a GOAT team, GOAT bowler, GOAT batsman, GOAT fielder etc. But Tendulkar is as close to the GOAT batsman discussion as it gets. Sir Don Bradman was considered the GOAT batsman for a long time and he has some ridiculous records that are still to be broken. But I would imagine that Tendulkar currently holds the majority of the batting records in cricket. And Bradman never played in many formats of the game so we have no idea how he would have performed! In a sense the Bradman/Tendulkar discussion is somewhat of a Rod Laver vs Federer discussion. Generations too far apart to compare.
Anyways the ultimate point is that Federer and Tendulkar are both gods but they can't be compared.
And cricket being a team sport, you would have more than 1 GOAT - you need a GOAT team, GOAT bowler, GOAT batsman, GOAT fielder etc. But Tendulkar is as close to the GOAT batsman discussion as it gets. Sir Don Bradman was considered the GOAT batsman for a long time and he has some ridiculous records that are still to be broken. But I would imagine that Tendulkar currently holds the majority of the batting records in cricket. And Bradman never played in many formats of the game so we have no idea how he would have performed! In a sense the Bradman/Tendulkar discussion is somewhat of a Rod Laver vs Federer discussion. Generations too far apart to compare.
Anyways the ultimate point is that Federer and Tendulkar are both gods but they can't be compared.
Last edited: