BGod
G.O.A.T.
Both at 2 Wimbledons.
Murray with 4 more secondary grass titles (6-2), Nadal making 2 more Wimbledon finals. Murray Olympic Gold on grass as well.
I know how this will come across but Murray has better losses at Wimbledon to me. Outside of the Finals loss to Roger he lost to him in another semifinal. Lost 3 times to Natal but 08 he was too young and in 2010-2011 he played tight before his 2012-2013 peak. Lost to 09 Roddick. Made 10 consecutive quarters or better with worse losses being comeback 2014 to Dimitrov and 2017 injured to Querrey.
I personally take Murray because he obviously had the higher floor not losing to upstarts like Nadal in his prime. The 2 extra finals for Rafa are not much separation with Murray having 4 Semifinal exits.
Peak for peak since Murray wouldn't have the same matchup issues his form 2013 beats any Nadal runs at least to me.
Murray with 4 more secondary grass titles (6-2), Nadal making 2 more Wimbledon finals. Murray Olympic Gold on grass as well.
I know how this will come across but Murray has better losses at Wimbledon to me. Outside of the Finals loss to Roger he lost to him in another semifinal. Lost 3 times to Natal but 08 he was too young and in 2010-2011 he played tight before his 2012-2013 peak. Lost to 09 Roddick. Made 10 consecutive quarters or better with worse losses being comeback 2014 to Dimitrov and 2017 injured to Querrey.
I personally take Murray because he obviously had the higher floor not losing to upstarts like Nadal in his prime. The 2 extra finals for Rafa are not much separation with Murray having 4 Semifinal exits.
Peak for peak since Murray wouldn't have the same matchup issues his form 2013 beats any Nadal runs at least to me.
Last edited: