Nadal / Djokovic and the Race to #1 !!!

Who will finish 2011 at the top?

  • Nadal

    Votes: 51 33.1%
  • Djokovic

    Votes: 103 66.9%

  • Total voters
    154
  • Poll closed .
I disagree with pretty much EVERYTHING here.

1. Nadal has not severely declined, his serve speed and BH are just a bit off and when facing god-mode Nole, that is enough to lose.
2. Although Nadal has lost so many times consecutively, you have to realize that this was all within a short 4-5 month span and Rafa would need time to develop and come up with a new gameplan.
3. The dude just turned 25 and is beating pretty much everyone else on the tour. Even conservatively speaking Djoker will not win more than half of the next 16 slams ( 4 years). Nadal will easily win a few more slams.
4. He IS a mental beast and in the past he has eked out many close matches against Djoker because of that mental strength. But he is not inhuman and every once in a while even the best have trouble.

IMO, Rafa has always respected Nole but I'm sure he believed that when playing his best, he would beat Nole with his standard gameplan. It's not arrogance but it's sort of a self belief based on your past success. Similar to how Fed has rarely changed his gameplan against Nadal even when it doesn't work because changing your gameplan is sort of an admission of "what i'm doing isn't working" and that's a hard thought for a top player to swallow.

Ironic as it sounds, I think once it truly sinks into Nadal's head that Joker is a better player than him (for now), he will start beating Joker!

Excellent post! Quoted for truth. Some of these idiots are truly deluded. Just because you don't win every tournament does not mean you're not at your best.
 

Talker

Hall of Fame
Nadal will have a tough time.
Djokovic is playing at least as well as Nadal on clay, this is where Nadal always had an advantage in gaining points.
Djokovic is better on hard court, that's all there is to it.

The points for #1 are just the best total for the past 12 months and right now Djokovic has the advantage on all surfaces so should maintain #1... theoretically.
No need to get into points being defended.
 

mattennis

Hall of Fame
To beat Djokovic, Nadal must improve his backhand big time.

Almost everytime they are in a neutral rally, and eventually Nadal start hitting backhands, sooner or later it lands short without much pace and from then on Djokovic take control of the point, Nadal start to run behind the ball and the point is over in two or three more shots.

Djokovic has been destroying Nadal's backhand time and time again this season.

At least in Indian Wells and Miami Rafa's backhand was a bit flatter with more pace and depth many times (almost as good as it was during his USOPEN final of last year), even flat winners down the line sometimes.

But after he lost those two finals, his confidence started to break down. On clay, in Madrid and Rome, he almost always looped his bachhand weak and short, with no pace, and most of the time crosscourt. Djokovic ate those weak looping backhands for lunch and murdered Rafa once and again.

It has got to a point (the low confidence in his backhand) that I am sure every time they are playing an important point, Nole is simply waiting Rafa to hit some backhands, and from then on, the point is his.

No matter how good he may serve, no matter how good his forehand may play everyday. As long as his backhand is such an inferior stroke to Djokovic's, chances are slim for Rafa.
 

veroniquem

Bionic Poster
Excellent post! Quoted for truth. Some of these idiots are truly deluded. Just because you don't win every tournament does not mean you're not at your best.



Especially when one has made every single (master and slam) final since the start of the season.
What decline?
People who claim Rafa will start losing in early rounds because of lack of confidence are completely deluded. They're totally underestimating Rafa's mental.
Reality is that Djoko and Rafa are the 2 best players on tour right now. In which order depends on so many parameters (either one of them being injured for instance could alter things drastically) that we'll just have to wait and see.
 

Bud

Bionic Poster
Well, this early loss in Montreal certainly doesn't help his cause :)

I'd say Djokovic is pretty much a wrap at this point.
 

aceX

Hall of Fame
What if Roger wins Montreal, Cincy, US Open, Shanghai, Bercy and WTF?

Not gonna happen but would he be #1 even if Djokovic came runner up in all of those?
 

veroniquem

Bionic Poster
Yikes Bud, most disastrous timing for my post. Well, mea culpa, I was wrong, the W loss affected Rafa's mental more than I thought.
I don't know if Djoko is a lock. His draw is much tougher than Fed's.
 

TennisFan3

Talk Tennis Guru
What decline?
.

There's so much wrong with this post, I don't know where to start.

Forget about the results, but if you look at the movement, footwork and the mental game of Nadal this year, you would know that at NO POINT this year, has he looked anywhere close to his 2010/2008 level..
 

Mustard

Bionic Poster
Nadal just looked burned out mentally, to me. The fire is not there. Even when he did a "Vamos", there was no real conviction behind it.
 

Herios

Rookie
Nadal now only 1090 points behind Djokovic :)

The Djoker got a zero pointer for not enough 500 tournaments played and Nadal's zero pointer is off the books

This has gotten even more interesting ;)

And now he gives away a big chunk of those points he got for Barca. Let's see if Novak makes it to the SF, and defends his points. I will reiterate to you, Novak is a better HC player than Rafa so it makes sense for him to stay ranked 1 for the rest of the year, unless Roger catches fire and beats him several times from here on.
 

Cormorant

Professional
What if Roger wins Montreal, Cincy, US Open, Shanghai, Bercy and WTF?

Not gonna happen but would he be #1 even if Djokovic came runner up in all of those?

Nope, in that scenario there would be more than 2,000 points between them year-end, even if Djoko qualified for the WTF final with only one win in the round robin.
 
D

Deleted member 77403

Guest
Nadal needs a huge reversal of fortune between him and Novak. Notice how Novak got through the topsy turvy first set, that I think he should have lost, but he won. And how Nadal lost tight sets that he should have won.

This game is so mental, and Nadal has been going on mental walkabouts a little too much for comfort. Personally I think Novak has simply been the better player and I hope he gets the year end number one this year, he's played spectacular, even Nadal has no answer to THIS Novak.
 
You can call it whatever you want to call it but he still bit the trophy and it's in his slam count. No matter how much you hate it. :)

Of course it's in his slam count, he won, why state the obvious? I don't hate it, I'm just point it out for what it is. Same way Fed winning FO2009, sure he won it, he has a career slam, but we all know (and he does too) that it happened because Nadal was taken out.

Same way Nadal won FO2011 because Djokovic was taken out.
 

Bud

Bionic Poster
Tonight's loss of Federer to Tsonga in Montreal round of 16 pretty much guarantees he won't be #1 at the end of 2011 .. for all of those who were upset that I didn't include him in the thread title ;)

Federer's Race point standing:
3,400 points behind Nadal
6,000+ points behind Djokovic (most likely when he wins)

I don't think Federer has many more than 6,000 potential points left in his schedule for the remainder of 2011 (WTF potential points are not included). He'd have to win every event from Cincy until the WTF to even smell #1.
 
Last edited:
N

NadalAgassi

Guest
Tonight's loss of Federer to Tsonga in Montreal round of 16 pretty much guarantees he won't be #1 at the end of 2011 .. for all of those who were upset that I didn't include him in the thread title ;)

Only the most delusional would have ever been considering his chances of year end #1 before this week anyway. Then again there is alot of those in Federer Palace (the unofficial name of TW).
 

tennis_pro

Bionic Poster
Wow if Djokovic wins Canada now he has a 3000 lead over Nadal in the race which means Nadal has to win at least 3000 more points than the Serb to be the year-end-no-1. Since almost every tourny from now on till London is played on medium/fast hard courts, well, ....ehm....I just don't see it.
 

Bud

Bionic Poster
Wow if Djokovic wins Canada now he has a 3000 lead over Nadal in the race which means Nadal has to win at least 3000 more points than the Serb to be the year-end-no-1. Since almost every tourny from now on till London is played on medium/fast hard courts, well, ....ehm....I just don't see it.

This early exit was pretty much the death knell for Rafa ending 2011 as #1. The only possible scenario of ending #1 is if Djoker is injured before the USO. IMO, Nadal won't make the USO final and I'd be surprised if he made the SF.

It will be Djokovic and some other person not named Nadal or Federer playing for the USO title this year.. perhaps Murray?

Nadal will once again end the year as the strong #2 player in the world.
 
Last edited:
D

Deleted member 77403

Guest
Novak 1
Rafa 2
Roger 3
Andy 4

That is how I see it at the end of the season.
 
D

Deleted member 77403

Guest
Is this race still happening?
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Bud

Bionic Poster
A race for third maybe :oops: The top 2 spots look pretty set

How many more points in race Nole needs to win to secure #1?

Not many ;)

Barring injury (or early exits from Cincy, the USO, Shanghai and Paris, it's nearly impossible for Nadal to pass him. Even then, Nadal would have to win or be the finalist in all of those tournaments as well.

Nadal at #2 also appears a foregone conclusion. The interesting finish at this point will be #3 and #4. It's possible Murray can still pass Federer.
 

Zildite

Hall of Fame
Yeah Federer should qualify comfortably as the cut bar drops down, the 6-8 spots could be interesting though.
 

Bud

Bionic Poster
Wow,that almost seems insurmountable considering Novak is winning everything. Hopefully Roger can pick up those points somewhere,but I don't know where it will be.

The bar will continue to decrease until the top 8 men qualify.
 
D

Deleted member 77403

Guest
The race is now a nice stroll in the park! LOL.

Novak deserves the number one, and I do hope he gets it. This has been a special year! Kudos to Rafa for putting up a fight also.
 

Bud

Bionic Poster
Bumpity-bump :)

K, heading into the final straightaway with Djokovic leading by 9 lengths :shock:
 

bullfan

Legend
What race? Novak is number 1, Rafa number 2. There's no possible way that Rafa can gain number 1 in 2011. Do the math. Shoot ask Rafa, he'd say that Novak will end number 1 for year, and say that Novak deserves it, he's said that Novak has had an awesome year many times, and that he deserves it.
 

Herios

Rookie
It ain't over until the fat lady sings ;)

Unless the fat lady kidnaps Novak and jails him, so he can't put his foot on the court for the rest of the season and Rafa wins EVERYTHING in sight: Tokyo, Shanghai, Paris and WTF, the race is over.
 
It ain't over until the fat lady sings ;)

4815153
 
D

Deleted member 77403

Guest
It would be quite an ending to the year if Nadal manages to get the number one ranking, despite being outclassed comprehensively by Djokovic this year, including being stripped of four of his titles by him,.
 

veroniquem

Bionic Poster
According to my calculations, it is mathematically impossible for Rafa to recover #1 this year even if he won everything and Djoko didn't win a single match. Rafa would have had to win USO to have a chance.
That is kind of fair. If a player with 3 slams and 5 masters didn't end the year as #1, I would seriously question the credibility of the ranking system...
Rafa should still care about reducing the gap to make it easier to recover #1 next year when Djoko won't be able to defend all his points.
 

Clarky21

Banned
According to my calculations, it is mathematically impossible for Rafa to recover #1 this year even if he won everything and Djoko didn't win a single match. Rafa would have had to win USO to have a chance.
That is kind of fair. If a player with 3 slams and 5 masters didn't end the year as #1, I would seriously question the credibility of the ranking system...
Rafa should still care about reducing the gap to make it easier to recover #1 next year when Djoko won't be able to defend all his points.


How do you know that he won't defend all of his points? He will come darn close considering there is nobody good enough to beat him.
 

veroniquem

Bionic Poster
I don't know for sure but I assume it will be difficult to have 2 seasons in a row without any early exit. I don't know any example of that happening.
 

dcdoorknob

Hall of Fame
The only way for Rafa to be #1 exactly one year from now is for him to score more points between now and then than Djokovic. Defending points may appear to have alot to do with in on a week to week basis, but it really doesn't.
 
Last edited:
Top