Nadal's 2010 season Vs. Fed's 2007 season....

[namelessone]

*******s logic: When Federer was dominating, the era was strong. When Nadal dominates, the era is no longer strong. hmmnn...

Of course, how else could he dominate?

 

[TMF]

You're right, it's the titles that count.

Last time I checked

12>7
8>7

(Mind you I think Fed's 2007 and Nadal's 2010 are on par if not Nadal in the lead. But Im just replying because you keep on insisting that somehow Nadal's 2010 is greater than even Fed's 2006 just on the basis of 3 slams on 3 different surfaces)

Yep. I caught him posting wreckless. The poll was nearly 90% in favor of Fed 2006 over Rafa 2010. Yet, he called everyone are *******s despite there's *******s even vote for Fed.

3 slams in the same season - done before.

3 slams in a row on 3 different surfaces - never done before!.

clean sweep on clay - never done before!.

Nadal 2010 by far the best season since Laver won the calender-slam.Even the biggest *******s/Nadal-haters at my club can see that, end of story!..

you guys talk about the number of matches lost and how many masters-1000 each guy won, thats irrelevant. Nadal achieved something this year that noone has ever been able to, not even Fed!.

 

[nolefam_2024]

Criteria	Federer	Nadal
ATP points	13480	12450
GOAT points (as per UTS)	74	67
Slams	3	3
Slam finals	4	3
Slam semis	4	3
Titles	8	7
Finals	12	11
Big titles	6	6
Big finals	10	7
Win%	88.3%	87.7
Top 5 win %	75	62.5
Top 10 win %	81	68.8

Federer decisively ahead in every single criteria. Especially in big finals the gap is huge. Fed was in 12 big finals and Nadal was in just 7.

2007 is Federer's probably third best year after 2006 and 2004. Very close to 2005

2010 is Nadal's probably best year.

Peak to peak Fed is much ahead.

 

[Mustard]

2010 is Nadal's probably best year.

2008 is when he had his best form. Nadal moved in 2008 far better than in 2010.

Nadal is behind Federer and Djokovic in terms of an entire calendar year dominance. That was never Nadal's strength. Nadal's strength was having the highest highs, i.e. his peak levels and peak moments are higher and more thrilling.

 

[Third Serve]

Criteria	Federer	Nadal
ATP points	13480	12450
GOAT points (as per UTS)	74	67
Slams	3	3
Slam finals	4	3
Slam semis	4	3
Titles	8	7
Finals	12	11
Big titles	6	6
Big finals	10	7
Win%	88.3%	87.7
Top 5 win %	75	62.5
Top 10 win %	81	68.8

Federer decisively ahead in every single criteria. Especially in big finals the gap is huge. Fed was in 12 big finals and Nadal was in just 7.

2007 is Federer's probably third best year after 2006 and 2004. Very close to 2005

2010 is Nadal's probably best year.

Peak to peak Fed is much ahead.

I think 2005 was better than 2007. He was stronger in most of the big tournaments. He did lose at the AO but he played worse in Wimbledon and USO 2007 and won those. Only real black spot is the YEC but he was injured in that one.

 

[nolefam_2024]

I think 2005 was better than 2007. He was stronger in most of the big tournaments. He did lose at the AO but he played worse in Wimbledon and USO 2007 and won those. Only real black spot is the YEC but he was injured in that one.

I don't think so. His 2005 was easier because the competition was weaker. Even then he is having less ranking points, less slams, less big finals, everything.
You can see his years compared here.

Big 3's top 5 seasons compared to each other.

Criteria 2008 2010 2013 2017 2019 ATP points 11400 12450 12030 10645 9585 GOAT points (as per UTS) 61 67 67 50 52 Slams 2 3 2 2 2 Slam finals 2 3 2 3 3 Slam semis 4 3 2 3 4 Titles 8 7 10 6 4 Finals 10 11 12 10 5 Big titles 6 6 7 4 4 Big finals 7 7 9 7 5 Win% 88.2 87.7 91.5...

tt.tennis-warehouse.com

He won more titles in 2005 and lost less but those were small tournaments. 2007 he won same number of big titles but more slams and more big finals.

 

[MichaelNadal]

I don't think so. His 2005 was easier because the competition was weaker. Even then he is having less ranking points, less slams, less big finals, everything.
You can see his years compared here.

Big 3's top 5 seasons compared to each other.

Criteria 2008 2010 2013 2017 2019 ATP points 11400 12450 12030 10645 9585 GOAT points (as per UTS) 61 67 67 50 52 Slams 2 3 2 2 2 Slam finals 2 3 2 3 3 Slam semis 4 3 2 3 4 Titles 8 7 10 6 4 Finals 10 11 12 10 5 Big titles 6 6 7 4 4 Big finals 7 7 9 7 5 Win% 88.2 87.7 91.5...

tt.tennis-warehouse.com

He won more titles in 2005 and lost less but those were small tournaments. 2007 he won same number of big titles but more slams and more big finals.

Bestie come chill and let’s talk about Nadal all day