ATP M1000 Madrid Open 2024 - R4: Alcaraz[2] v Struff[23]

Who wins?


  • Total voters
    29
  • Poll closed .

nolefam_2024

Talk Tennis Guru
I will consider this match as a great wakeup call. Alcaraz is not invincible. He can lose focus and hit some terrible shots. He is current RG favorite but not invincible.
 

Tennisfan339

Professional
Well, what a match that was!!!
Congratulations to both players, the level was incredible.
Still amazed how good Alcaraz can be in Madrid and how he struggles (until now) in every other clay big tournaments.
 

alexio

G.O.A.T.
struff mistake was to use again serve and volley on last point considerin the previous one was unsuccessful
 

jl809

Hall of Fame
Can we talk about how bad Alcaraz’s dropper is when it’s bad? I really can’t decide how to judge the shot because it’s godly when it’s good but can think so many matches where his 50 IQ has him using it terribly
 

NoleFam

Bionic Poster
Alcaraz survives but that was anything but convincing. Opponents seeing him chocking from 3 match points up will sense he's vulnerable.
 

nolefam_2024

Talk Tennis Guru
Injury free he will be in the GOAT debate. Nothing wrong with his skillset, he is a complete player.
He is great player and probably second greatest for his age. But his problem will be he is tinier than the rest of the giants.
You will be fighting physics.
 

Rattie

Legend
Alcaraz survives but that was anything but convincing. Opponents seeing him chocking from 3 match points up will sense he's vulnerable.
Of course he is, he hasn’t had it particularly easy in the last few months and yet he still gets over the line. When his confidence is fully intact, look out.
 

nolefam_2024

Talk Tennis Guru
This is why I miss prime Thiem, felt like he was almost always better in TBs than the rest of the set
Shocking. He was worse than Andy and Stan. Only year he was barely 60% is 2020 which is pandemic year and none of the players were prepared well.
 

GAS

Professional
Can we talk about how bad Alcaraz’s dropper is when it’s bad? I really can’t decide how to judge the shot because it’s godly when it’s good but can think so many matches where his 50 IQ has him using it terribly

Missed shot is bad? Winner is good? Looks like you know what you're talking about when mentioned 50 IQ...
 

NoleFam

Bionic Poster
Of course he is, he hasn’t had it particularly easy in the last few months and yet he still gets over the line. When his confidence is fully intact, look out.
He had it easy in his 1st matches here but that wasn't great from him at the end of that 3rd set. He barely escaped and if Struff had made that sitter at the net at 5 all break point, then...
 

sortof

Semi-Pro
How cruel this is. Mighty effort by the veteran player, in the end he would have needed to find a couple of aces to win this. Still, Struff, now ranked #40, can be more than happy about his season so far.
 

Rattie

Legend
He had it easy in his 1st matches here but that wasn't great from him at the end of that 3rd set. He barely escaped and if Struff had made that sitter at the net at 5 all break point, then...
But he didn’t. Nerves play a part in matches like that, on both sides. Struff is coming off a clay title and he made last year’s final. Very confident. Carlos has been nursing an injury and missed out on two important tournaments, plus he’s defending a shed load of points, so the pressure is on him. A lot! The fact is he won a match he could easily have lost given all the circumstances.
I tend to see it differently :)
 

NoleFam

Bionic Poster
But he didn’t. Nerves play a part in matches like that, on both sides. Struff is coming off a clay title and he made last year’s final. Very confident. Carlos has been nursing an injury and missed out on two important tournaments, plus he’s defending a shed load of points, so the pressure is on him. A lot! The fact is he won a match he could easily have lost given all the circumstances.
I tend to see it differently :)
Struff played well, no doubt and is in good form. My criticism comes from him choking from 5-4 40-0 and making so many errors after that in that game. Opponents are licking that chops at that. It only gets more difficult from here and he needs to play better in the next round.
 
Top