among others, I’m guilty of saying his career would be at least as good as Kudla - while I haven’t given up on that this early in his career, especially hampered by surgery, I probably would be less aggressive w that prediction if I could go back in time
but, I’ll own that L if he falls short of Kudla
bob’s Brooksby take - we’ll see when he owns that L
well, yes, true - but saying that someone will have a Kudla-like career is not really 'hyping', is it? It is a fairly good prediction based on how JJ Wolf performed till last year, his physical abilities, and so on. And not that having a Kudla-like career is something to sneeze at. So I wouldn't exactly calling your prediction (which I kind of hope comes through) 'hyping'.
I actually had a bet at the end of 2019 whether he reaches at least 120 rank by the end of September 2021. I've lost it since he was 120 _exactly_ for two weeks back in September 2020. I mean exactly 120, I should have bet 'better than 120'
On a related topic. Out of recent college players: McDonald, Cressy, Nakashima, Brooksby (let's include him as well on technicality) I still say that Cressy will be the best. There's just nothing the others do/can do to stand out. Cressy at least plays the unusual style, and he has a serve. When I was watching McDonald vs Nakashima few weeks back at Cincinnati it was like a college game: I start with a decent serve but nothing to write home about, then we are going to rally crosscourt fairly safe but hardly forcing shots until someone misses, then repeat. That is just not how pros play these days. You can only go so far by running after each shot, if nothing else your body will break after few seasons.